Pizza was good. Asked for extra cheese but there was hardly any cheese on the pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tara Piscitelli
Picked up several pizzas, salad and garlic bread for a party. The guests hadn't had food from here before and loved it! The pizza sauce is just great, the toppings are wonderful! Pesto is super yummy! Closest thing I've found in Santa Fe that reminds me of home.
Jack A boi
Pepperoni and mushroom with olives on half of it and we got the extra large it was massive awesome best pizza one of the best pizzas here in Santa Fe if not the best
Daniela Hermosillo
paid $33 for a sub-par large pizza. I really wish they made me aware of the price when ordering. Will not be ordering again. I get very similar pizzas at the grocery store. $30 is insane no matter what specialty kind of pizza it is
KevinandErin Knox
Finally done with this place after too many tries. It's ostensibly a New York Style pizza place but it tramples the first rule of NY pizza: have pizza slices available at all times. On the contrary, they CLAIM (when you talk to them) to have slices available at lunch time but even then it is often not the case - as for example at 12:45 today. And to call the staff lackadaisical would be an understatement.
It's too bad because if you're willing to pony up for a whole pie or happen to get there on one of the rare occasions when they do have slices it's pretty good stuff in a city that otherwise has no NY-style pizza options. A very poorly-run business that could be wildly successful.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Joanna Tolentino
Food was great, but the prices online are very off. We ordered a small (12”) and a large (16”) pizza, expected it to be about $42 based on online prices, but it was a little over $60 when we picked up the pizzas. Staff was friendly, but the price difference was very deceiving. Ultimately not worth $60.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Randy Beckman
Great pizza and Caesar salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Paul Longenecker
Arrived to get late lunch (2pm) for the office crew, Three employees sitting at the table all on their phones and eating (slices) tell me that they are done serving slices for the day.
What the hell kind of pizza place doesn’t keep a pizza on deck for slices? This is figured into the cost of a slice. Such a joke. Don’t go here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Blessed AI
I always enjoy their pizza and they continue to maintain the quality. Worth a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
marcos sedillo
Okay everyone first please forgive me I was super hungry and forgot to take my photos. I order two slices, one of green chile and one just plain cheese. I have been looking for the best pizza in Santa Fe and this place was decent. The staff was very friendly, the place was clean and the wait for slices was roughly 10 minutes. I rated the food 4 because it wasn’t awful but also just wasn’t anything mouth watering to have to come back but it was good enough to try again. It was a little too thin for my taste and would prefer a little more tomato sauce.
I didn't eat in restaurant. The pizzas were advertised at one price and when I pick them up it was a different price. The pizza was good just disappointed in the pricing
J F
Hot inside. Only 3 tables. Advertises slices on menu but refuses to sell them, claiming ‘we don’t have any slices’. Extremely rude lady at counter. If y’all want to have better business, hire courteous employees that actually care and welcome customers. Lastly, don’t advertise something you won’t sell.
Pizza was good. Asked for extra cheese but there was hardly any cheese on the pizza.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Picked up several pizzas, salad and garlic bread for a party. The guests hadn't had food from here before and loved it! The pizza sauce is just great, the toppings are wonderful! Pesto is super yummy! Closest thing I've found in Santa Fe that reminds me of home.
Pepperoni and mushroom with olives on half of it and we got the extra large it was massive awesome best pizza one of the best pizzas here in Santa Fe if not the best
paid $33 for a sub-par large pizza. I really wish they made me aware of the price when ordering. Will not be ordering again. I get very similar pizzas at the grocery store. $30 is insane no matter what specialty kind of pizza it is
Finally done with this place after too many tries. It's ostensibly a New York Style pizza place but it tramples the first rule of NY pizza: have pizza slices available at all times. On the contrary, they CLAIM (when you talk to them) to have slices available at lunch time but even then it is often not the case - as for example at 12:45 today. And to call the staff lackadaisical would be an understatement.
It's too bad because if you're willing to pony up for a whole pie or happen to get there on one of the rare occasions when they do have slices it's pretty good stuff in a city that otherwise has no NY-style pizza options. A very poorly-run business that could be wildly successful.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Food was great, but the prices online are very off. We ordered a small (12”) and a large (16”) pizza, expected it to be about $42 based on online prices, but it was a little over $60 when we picked up the pizzas. Staff was friendly, but the price difference was very deceiving. Ultimately not worth $60.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great pizza and Caesar salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arrived to get late lunch (2pm) for the office crew,
Three employees sitting at the table all on their phones and eating (slices) tell me that they are done serving slices for the day.
What the hell kind of pizza place doesn’t keep a pizza on deck for slices? This is figured into the cost of a slice. Such a joke. Don’t go here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I always enjoy their pizza and they continue to maintain the quality. Worth a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Okay everyone first please forgive me I was super hungry and forgot to take my photos. I order two slices, one of green chile and one just plain cheese. I have been looking for the best pizza in Santa Fe and this place was decent. The staff was very friendly, the place was clean and the wait for slices was roughly 10 minutes. I rated the food 4 because it wasn’t awful but also just wasn’t anything mouth watering to have to come back but it was good enough to try again. It was a little too thin for my taste and would prefer a little more tomato sauce.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I didn't eat in restaurant. The pizzas were advertised at one price and when I pick them up it was a different price. The pizza was good just disappointed in the pricing
Hot inside. Only 3 tables. Advertises slices on menu but refuses to sell them, claiming ‘we don’t have any slices’. Extremely rude lady at counter. If y’all want to have better business, hire courteous employees that actually care and welcome customers. Lastly, don’t advertise something you won’t sell.
My fa Wauer all-time pizza! And fantastic gelato.
My fav local ny pizza joint!
Best pizza in Santa Fe
Loading...