Goldberg's Famous Bagels

We came here for coffee and breakfast on a Sunday morning in October. We ended up getting breakfast to go - there really wasn’t anywhere to sit inside and we had a nice balcony at our hotel.

We ordered coffee, a breakfast sandwich and an omelette. We asked for the omelette with just onion but it didn’t taste like any was added- I think it was just eggs but that was fine. The omelette came with a choice of bread - not bagel or flat, just toasted bread, and a has brown. The coffee and the bagel that was in the sandwich was good.

The employee who took our order wasn’t the most pleasant. Maybe he was having a tough morning or something.

Prices were comparable to other breakfast places.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

The most perfect beach wrap lunch. Got the Buffalo chicken, was perfect.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Goldberg loves bacon! Not kosher or halal. Good everything bagel. Toasted to a crispy bite. Bacon cooked well. Eggs were fluffy fried. Cheese well melted. BEC porportions were just right. A bit too much ketcup. Service could have b3en friendlier. Topped off the meal with a large ice coffee. Came out to over 16. Not sure how but ok. I still may come back.

Stopped by again last weekend of summer 2025.
Was staying at hither hills campground and going fishing at 8am that day. Wanted to start the morning off early with a fresh bagel and ice coffee. They open at 6am and we got there around 620. They didn’t have bagels yet. The guy behind the counter couldn’t say when they would get their bagel delivery, “ could be in 10 minutes, could be twenty,” he exclaimed.
:( Bae was disappointed and I was a little too. I settled with a bacon egg and cheese or …. A roll. Ate it on the boat.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Tried this place after camping on Wednesday Sept 10th, Ordered eggs and tomato on a toatest bagel. Asked to Add mayo and ketchup but the sandwich came out untoasted with a gross amount of mayo. The bagel was chewy and rubbery and the sandwich was dripping and the two clerks working had uncomfortable attitudes like they didn’t want to be there. 3x self made ice coffees and that one sandwich. $27 UNREAL AND NOT WORRH IT. We Hit the next one in east hampton and it was much better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bagel was tough, we don’t see the speciality of it. Would’ve been great if it was better textured and if they have a variety of coffee drinks rather than just pour over black coffee

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Long wait but worth the wait. Bagels are super fresh and everything tastes great there. I also think their iced coffee is delish and a fraction of the cost of the coffee shops near by! Worth the visit when in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Out of most things.

I went around 2:30 pm and they told me they were closing the grill. I ordered everything bagel with grilled chicken, tomato, and Swiss cheese. It was terrible, smelled of Windex, and I paid $21.35 for a bagel and a Snapple drink. I definitely do not recommend it. The service was terrible because you went close to closing time. My money was wasted. It was very expensive.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nice place is just crowed for a bagel and coffee, I guess is just summer in NY beaches, coffee a bit bitter for my taste, definitely will try it again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Was on a 3 day vacation to Montauk and went to this place each morning I was there, incredible dudes and great food for a very respectable price. Even better bagels than many places in NYC.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I really like this location from the others. Everyone is professional and gets the job done. It's a hit or miss with crowdedness. One of our mornings we were the only ones there, another the line was out the door. It all depends I suppose.
I like the make coffee your way feature. I didn't have the pleasure of having an egg sandwich yet, I will one of these days. And their bagels are just my type. Our staple for mornings in Montauk. We'll be back soon :)

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels, Montauk, Bacon Egg and Cheese, Scallion Cream Cheese

Great little spot for delicious bagels. I thought the prices were as expected for the Hamptons (we live in Brooklyn and pay similar). This location had a nice little back area with picnic tables so we could sit and eat. Coffee is fine.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great bagels! Must stop and grab a few on your way out to Montauk! The one suggestion I can give is this... they need fresh brewed Iced Tea! Unsweet and Sweet! Bottled tea is horrible!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

When you’re in the Hamptons… you have to stop at Goldberg’s for a bagel. There’s nothing better than going to the beach with an iced coffee and a loaded lox bagel. Crispy, chewy, salty, perfect. Goldbergs has been making bagels since 1949 and they are truly a Hamptons staple. The bagels were super fresh and delish. The lox was that perfect nova lox. They have plenty of parking out front and there’s a cute bench to eat your bagels and coffee on or just take them to the beach! It’s right across the street!

🌀Lox Sandwhich- Scallion cream cheese, lox, red onion and tomato.

🌀 The Spicy Hobo- Two eggs, bacon, pepper jack cheese, hash brown and hot sauce.

🌀 The Montauk- Roast beef, swiss, russian and slaw on rye

🌀Two eggs any style with bacon and hash brown

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love Goldberg’s and always have, but $18.07 for an everything bagel with cc and 3 slices of lox is absurd.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2