il Buco al Mare

231 Main St, Amagansett
(631) 557-3100

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Forest Mushroom Foccacia
Whole Roasted Branzino
Rosemary Focaccia
Black Garlic Steak
Littleneck Clams
Margherita Pizza
Chocolate Cake
Grilled Prawns
Duck Breast
Fluke Crudo

Menu

Ancient Grain Focaccia
Margherita
tomato, mozzarella, basil, and peperoncino
Grilled forest mushroom Focaccia
Three types of mushrooms, fava, ramps provolone + lemon
Rosemary, Salt, and Nocellara Olive Oil
Housemade with ancient triticum durum flour from Sicily.
Eggplant, Anchovy, Tomato, Peperoncino +Mozzarella
Housemade with ancient triticum durum flour from Sicily.

Tins
Sardines in Olive Oil
Served with housemade buckwheat rye and sweet butter
Octopus in olive oil + garlic
Fried mussels in marinade
served with housemade buckwheat rye bread + sweet butter
Razor Clams in Brine
Served with housemade buckwheat rye and sweet butter.
Mackerel fillets in olive oil
Served with housemade buckwheat rye and sweet butter
Mediterranean Sardines in Olive Oil
served with house-made buckwheat rye and sweet butter

Small Plates
Mustard green salad
cherries, almonds + aged cheddar
Charred Prawns, cream, shabazi, lime
Charred Prawns, chermoula + lime
Roasted Little Neck Clams, fresno chili, green garlic, and grilled bread
Shaved & charred octopus, early girl tomatoes + nocellara olive oil

Mains
Black Garlic Skirt Steak and Montreal Spice
Smoked Senat chicken
fingerling potatoes, grilled cabbage & preserved lemon
Local striped bass, green apricot, celery + castelvetrano olives
Long Island Duck Breast
baby carrots, asian pear, chili + sesame
Whole roasted Montauk fluke + charred lemon
Whole roasted Montauk fluke for Two

Vegetables
Broccolini, garlic, pickled chili, and breadcrumbs
Crispy cannelini beans, celery, parsley + lemon

Desserts
Chocolate Cake with local fruit
Seasonal Fruit Crostata, and labneh

Coffee
Iced Latte
Iced Cappuccino

Galvanina Organic Italian Sodas
Cola
Lemon
Ginger Beer

Fever Tree Sodas
Lime and Yuzu
Mediterranean Tonic
Ginger Beer

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+32 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+31 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Amazing food. So much so we came back twice during our trip to the area. Service was a bit impersonal and slow the first night, but the second night our server Max took care of us and we had a great experience.

Get the margherita focaccia, crispy canellini beans, and skirt steak. You won’t be disappointed.

Seating is a bit tight, but the ambiance is lovely. We will definitely be back!
September 2025
My husband and I are huge fans of the Il buco restaurants generally, and al Mare in Amagansett didn’t disappoint. Every corner of the establishment is beautiful so one can’t really go wrong with where they choose to sit. My favorite was the sea bass with eggplant, peppers, tomato and pine nuts- a really simple dish, celebrating each and every ingredient. We were a bit surprised by the limited pasta options on the menu but the seafood more than made up for it.
September 2025
Although it was a busy July night, our waitress was really on top of things. The food was nothing to write back home. We had big, totally unseasoned slabs of tuna, stringy broccolini, lukewarm but tasty bucatini and the very doughy pizza focaccia. The music was terrible - classic rock in department store makeover - but nobody goes there for the music, and for the food probably neither ;-) Nice atmosphere and a lot of people watching. The restaurant could really benefit from...
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Fini Pizza Amagansett - 237 Main St
Pizza, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
Bonfire Coffeehouse - 249 A Main St
Breakfast, Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Gelato, Coffee
Organic Krush Kitchen & Eatery - 207 Main St
Juice Bar & Smoothies, Acai Bowls, Vegan

il Buco al Mare

231 Main St, Amagansett, NY 11930
(631) 557-3100