Fudgy's Ice Cream

4789 NY-22, Amenia
(845) 373-8291

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Very Family oriented. Tia is faithful to her shop and loves what she does💕. Fred is Tia’s life time helper and he has always been a hard worker and I’ve known both of them and there children and their children for many wonderful years-and it’s so nice to see the family all help . Tia has a gift 💝 for making those yummy cakes of any kind you ask for . Tia has made several ice cream cakes for me when my kids were young . .. she is a great friend and I wish her many more...
This was my first experience with Fudgy's after hearing so much positive feedback from my wife it was time to try it...Well I was somewhat disappointed, as I ordered a chocolate malted milkshake which barely tasted like a malt, and was basically tasteless period!
I was supposed to give my order and i completely messed it up and somehow the girl taking my order got it exactly right. I was very impressed, I would’ve been pretty annoyed if i received my order and probably would’ve gotten it completely wrong.

More Reviews