Fudgy's Ice Cream
4789 NY-22, Amenia
(845) 373-8291
Customers' Favorites
Hot Fudge Sundae with Queen of Hearts and Toasted Almond Amaretto Ice Cream
Kahlua Almond Amaretto
Chocolate Ice Cream
Brownie Sundae
Ice Cream Cone
Cookie Dough
Banana Split
Coffee Ice
Menu
Photos
+29 photos
+28 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Very Family oriented. Tia is faithful to her shop and loves what she does💕. Fred is Tia’s life time helper and he has always been a hard worker and I’ve known both of them and there children and their children for many wonderful years-and it’s so nice to see the family all help . Tia has a gift 💝 for making those yummy cakes of any kind you ask for . Tia has made several ice cream cakes for me when my kids were young . .. she is a great friend and I wish her many more...
This was my first experience with Fudgy's after hearing so much positive feedback from my wife it was time to try it...Well I was somewhat disappointed, as I ordered a chocolate malted milkshake which barely tasted like a malt, and was basically tasteless period!
I was supposed to give my order and i completely messed it up and somehow the girl taking my order got it exactly right. I was very impressed, I would’ve been pretty annoyed if i received my order and probably would’ve gotten it completely wrong.
You May Also Like
El Avocado Café - 4789 NY-22
![]()
Mexican, Cafe, American
Four Brothers Pizza Inn - 4957 NY-22
![]()
Pizza, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian