Recommended dishes: Irish Egg Rolls, Guinness Draught and Malbec
Richard Rossetti
Service was exceptional, especially on a busy Saturday. Food and atmosphere, just as great. Can't wait to go again. Well done!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kim H.
Highly recommend Celtic chicken dish, it was delicious!! All three of us would definitely order again. My only recommendation is to have the mustard sauce on my side and ask for brown gravy for your mashed potatoes. The vegetables were fresh and cooked to perfection with a delightful seasoning. Adriana our waitress was attentive to our every request and took such great careof us we will be back on a Wednesday to see her again The restaurant was decorated with beautiful green lights for St. Patrick's Day creating a beautiful ambiance!! Visit Carneys you will be happy you did!!
Chris A.
Very nice Irish pub/restaurant. I stopped by for the St Patrick's Day menu. It has so many Irish dishes. They also have one heck of a great draft beer menu - Harp and Smithwick's on tap . I tried the fish & chips , coating was good and fries tasty . The highlight for me was the Smithwick's. The beer was so fresh and poured perfectly. Very nice staff (Denise) and nicely arranged tables .
Bart M.
Dinner was not as good as it should have been. Waitress was sweet, but the place is kinda old and not crisp and clean.
Mikey
Best Irish food I've ever had on long island! The owner was very friendly and you can tell he cares about the people that work and go there. God bless him and this restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Chin
corned beef sandwich needs more corned beef.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
NANETTE TURNER
I had the Shepherd's pie and mu husband, corned beef and cabbage. I loved my meal and my hubby said he finally found the restaurant that served a delicious corned beef mealThank you@
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noreen M.
Best burger I ever had, warm and friendly atmosphere, great service . I will be back soon.
John L.
At Carneys the food is good. The beer is good the wine is good. The service is good. The atmosphere is great. You will not be disappointed
Server was unbelievable friendly fun food was good atmosphere eh could use a spruce up overall nice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Levi C.
The food was delicious! The service was thoughtful and kind, and the restaurant felt cozy without being cramped.
Robert McGuirk
They had a guy playing guitar ? he was good ,I'd go
Atmosphere: 4
Gabrielle B.
Thank you so much to Pete and his crew for helping us to throw a celebration of life for my grandmother! Large dining space seated 50+ easily, with room for at least 10-20 more. Their party package food options are extensive. So many choices, including carving station! Service was great. Food was delicious. Our grandmother loved it here. Great choice for your next gathering, Highly recommended food: Fish and chips Chicken francese Salmon Dijon Tuscan pasta Corned beef Roasted potatoes Shepherds pie!!
Kim M.
When we planned a lunch after a funeral we were never given menu options just a bill for guests who did not attend due to the nature of the day. When asked to take the time to adjust the bill, or at least the drink portion of the order off the final bill the owner / manager refused. It was truly an experience we would like to forget, or an experience that we hoped to have assistance with. With all of the options nearby go elsewhere.
Great place with live music and friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Irish Egg Rolls, Guinness Draught and Malbec
Service was exceptional, especially on a busy Saturday. Food and atmosphere, just as great. Can't wait to go again. Well done!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend Celtic chicken dish, it was delicious!! All three of us would definitely order again. My only recommendation is to have the mustard sauce on my side and ask for brown gravy for your mashed potatoes. The vegetables were fresh and cooked to perfection with a delightful seasoning. Adriana our waitress was attentive to our every request and took such great careof us we will be back on a Wednesday to see her again The restaurant was decorated with beautiful green lights for St. Patrick's Day creating a beautiful ambiance!! Visit Carneys you will be happy you did!!
Very nice Irish pub/restaurant. I stopped by for the St Patrick's Day menu. It has so many Irish dishes. They also have one heck of a great draft beer menu - Harp and Smithwick's on tap . I tried the fish & chips , coating was good and fries tasty . The highlight for me was the Smithwick's. The beer was so fresh and poured perfectly. Very nice staff (Denise) and nicely arranged tables .
Dinner was not as good as it should have been. Waitress was sweet, but the place is kinda old and not crisp and clean.
Best Irish food I've ever had on long island! The owner was very friendly and you can tell he cares about the people that work and go there. God bless him and this restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
corned beef sandwich needs more corned beef.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I had the Shepherd's pie and mu husband, corned beef and cabbage. I loved my meal and my hubby said he finally found the restaurant that served a delicious corned beef mealThank you@
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best burger I ever had, warm and friendly atmosphere, great service . I will be back soon.
At Carneys the food is good. The beer is good the wine is good. The service is good. The atmosphere is great. You will not be disappointed
Restaurantji Recommends
Server was unbelievable friendly fun food was good atmosphere eh could use a spruce up overall nice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food was delicious! The service was thoughtful and kind, and the restaurant felt cozy without being cramped.
They had a guy playing guitar ? he was good ,I'd go
Atmosphere: 4
Thank you so much to Pete and his crew for helping us to throw a celebration of life for my grandmother! Large dining space seated 50+ easily, with room for at least 10-20 more. Their party package food options are extensive. So many choices, including carving station! Service was great. Food was delicious. Our grandmother loved it here. Great choice for your next gathering, Highly recommended food: Fish and chips Chicken francese Salmon Dijon Tuscan pasta Corned beef Roasted potatoes Shepherds pie!!
When we planned a lunch after a funeral we were never given menu options just a bill for guests who did not attend due to the nature of the day. When asked to take the time to adjust the bill, or at least the drink portion of the order off the final bill the owner / manager refused. It was truly an experience we would like to forget, or an experience that we hoped to have assistance with. With all of the options nearby go elsewhere.