Fratellis Italian Gourmet Market

94 Montauk Hwy, Amityville
(631) 608-8775

Recent Reviews

NECATI Kocak

All around a great place. Very welcoming and always excellent experience. The quality of the meats they provide is unlike any other deli, the coldcuts are super fresh, and the sandwiches are delicious. Defiantly recommend for anyone who has not been here yet.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hazan Orhan

Great place to get fresh meats and deli products. Absolutely the best!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erin B.

Love this place !! I am here at least 1x week and I've been a very happy customer since they opened. I get prepared sandwiches which are fresh and amazing . They have excellent meatloaf , chicken cutlets , steaks , salads and fresh cold cuts. I highly recommend this place for catering and holiday parties . Family operated with love and care . Try it you will be pleasantly surprised !!

Anthony D.

Disgusting service and over priced food. Brought this back and pointed out the old black chicken and the first words the manager says are "what's wrong with it?"

Gean Morringiello

Love this place! Everything always fresh and delicious. Friendly atmosphere.

Scott L Roberts

I’m disappointed with this store and their poor management. The pork for starters smells really sour which is definitely not normal… The really tall kid with the glasses who wears hoodies is always giving me a difficult time. Him and the short guy with the tattoos who I assume is the boss. Gave me a huge attitude when I mentioned the sour smell of the pork and purposely tried to make me feel idiotic. It is also very frequent to find expired grocery items. I shopped here for years and never had a bad experience but will no longer shop here after my recent experiences. Get your act together and quit with the attitude.

joyce pannone

Great local Italian Market and butcher. Fresh meats, deli products and bread! They have canned goods, some produce and fresh dairy. It's nice to have the store in the neighborhood.

Don Tant

Excellent Italian deli ..Food is always fresh , people are always courteous and friendly .Great place to get a sandwich or a meal , they also make up beautiful catering platters ..I have been going there for 6 years continually...stop in , you will be delighted

Elizabeth Mauras

Clean and friendly staff! Great food!!

Mike Cody

Great selections friendly servicegenerous portions

Joseph Morin

Excellent quality food thats reasonably priced. Business owners are great to deal with.

James MALAMUTE

Fratelli's' is the BEST, Real Italian home goodness cooking. I live around the corner, and really enjoy their home made meat balls. Just like Moms. So flavorful, and nutritious. Forget about McDonalds, or Burger King. Eat home made from Fratellis ♥

brendan kerrigan

Great deli sandwiches and Italian products

Jack Columbano

One word, "Amazing" !I moved here from Brooklyn 2 yrs ago, this place is my bloodline back home to Gravesend. Nuff said

Bernadette Marie

Best everything!

Load More

Fratellis Italian Gourmet Market

94 Montauk Hwy, Amityville, NY 11701
(631) 608-8775