Reyes Deli

80 Montauk Hwy UNIT C, Amity Harbor
(631) 608-9081

Recent Reviews

Robert McElroy

I have to say I have had alot of hungry man heros and I think this one made here is hands down so far the best one I have had! I'll be back for sure ! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yosselin Pérez

The food is delicious and the service is wonderful.

Bryan Baker

There’s a reason Reyes Deli is rated so high. Walking into the deli, you’re greeted with a spacious and decorated dining area and coffee bar. The breakfast and lunch menus are easy to read above the display case and counter. There is a nicely decorated and clean bathroom available as well.I ordered a BEC with salt and pepper on a plain bagel which cost just under $8.00. The sandwich was excellent; fresh, flavorful, and delicious. I rate the sandwich as a 9/10. My coworker ordered ham and eggs (with extra ham) on a roll for $11. The extra ham serving was plentiful. He rated his sandwich 9/10.Parking: A few parking spots along the storefront and also street parking available.Kid-friendliness: Dining area is clean and spacious. Tables and chairs available.Wheelchair accessibility: Parking in front with curb cuts. No stairs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

kitty Hartt

Ordered on Uber eats. Restaurant accepted the order then closed 20 minutes later without even canceling the order or reaching out to myself or the driver who also drove there to pickup the order.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Google user

There’s a reason Reyes Deli is rated so high. Walking into the deli, you’re greeted with a spacious and decorated dining area and coffee bar. The breakfast and lunch menus are easy to read above the display case and counter. There is a nicely decorated and clean bathroom available as well. I ordered a BEC with salt and pepper on a plain bagel which cost just under $8.00. The sandwich was excellent; fresh, flavorful, and delicious. I rate the sandwich as a 9/10. My coworker ordered ham and eggs (with extra ham) on a roll for $11. The extra ham serving was plentiful. He rated his sandwich 9/10.

Donna Ward

The best New York bacon, egg and cheese! Very nice people and the deli is the best!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Home Fries, Turkey Bacon, Sandwich, Bagel with Butter, Soup, Turkey Club

Joey Dechirico

If I could give more than 5 stars - I would! I just recently moved to Copiague and was looking for a good sandwich when my neighbor recommended me to Reyes' Deli. The sandwich was incredible - they followed the special instructions I had given and it was SO FRESH. I will definitely be a repeat customer and if you haven't gone there already - YOU'RE MISSING OUT!

Kat R.

Ok Reyes deli breakfast sandwich was beautiful and delish and throwing peppers and onions on the home fries for me was great thanks

Jaelle B.

This is one of the worst delis I've been to on the island. I say this as someone who has given them several opportunities over the last few years and the only reason I have done that is out of convenience. Not once have I ever been satisfied as a customer. Overpriced and no value for your dollar. As you can see by the photo the sandwich is mostly bread. Almost zero flavor too. I asked for red peppers not green peppers if possible. I was told "ok no problem" instead i got no peppers. Spend your hard earned dollar at a great deli like Brothers in lindenhurst or lulus and better bagel in amityville.

Christopher M.

Always fresh food and never stingy about the amount they give you. Husband and wife owners are really nice people who also give back to the community. Staff is very friendly. If you're in the area stop by. You'll thank me.

Marcelo E.

If you want to wait 25 minutes for your order this is your spot !!!! 10 minutes waiting on line not one person asked if I'm being helped. Place is a mess. I will never come here myself again or recommend this place to anyone.

Chris Marks

$8+ for a basic egg sandwich? The audacity. Even with rising grocery costs, that’s a reach. Unless you’re slaughtering the animals and hatching the eggs in the Kitchen, there’s no way the price is justifiable. I was just in the Hamptons at the most famous Bagel shop on L.I, even their sandwiches are a better value.

Rich Griffin

Nice new place with lots of variety. Wine to vodka they have you covered

Yvette Hector

I feel like today is my lucky day! I order breakfast a couple of times a week from local delis. Today I decided to try Reyes and what an amazing experience! One of my standbys is western omelette this was the BEST I have ever had. Home fries were also excellent! I even took a chance on paying extra for a side of avocado and it was just right - now that’s luck! I NEVER take pics of my food but had to stop enjoying and take one.

JoE Weinstein

Best deli hands down on Long Island!! I put their bacon egg and cheese up against anyone’s!! And for lunch they have everything, amazing menu with great specialty hero’s/sandwiches. My favorite is the Packers which is cooked roast beef on delicious garlic bread with a side of gravy to dip. So friggin good! Best taco’s in town and a sweet array of healthy choices that are yummy.Customer service and cleanliness both 10/10!! Nice family place with an amazing catering selection.Love it, thanks Reyes deli!

Load More