Toomey's Tavern

251 S Ketcham Ave, Amityville
(631) 264-0564

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wisestan Stanwise

Nice easygoing local place, relaxed atmosphere

Peter

Fantastic service. Great food along with huge portions. Extremely long wait time until appetizers and meal came out.

Bart Asa

Cash only after 9 is pretty lame

James Reardon

Great place to see band on the water

Josepl Tavella

Great food, Service, atmosphere and people

Chris Kane

Grew up there, and it hasn't changed much.Thats what makes it great !

Timothy C. Smith

Great place to relax

R O (MRO)

Great location on the pier and water. You can see good views from a number of places. It is clearly a super local and popular place. Most people seem to know the staff and they know clients by name.

Drinks (beers) were hit or miss as some were on a flat side, yet the bartender didn’t even notice.

Food is mostly good. Ordered clams oreganatta, but received stuffed clams, once again the staff didn’t even notice. They were good nonetheless. Fries were good as well.

The “famous” fish sandwich is embarrassing but edible if you are hungry or drunk enough. It was basically four fish sticks on a bun with tartar sauce on the side. These fish sticks looked like they came out of some COSTCO frozen box or something. Do NOT order it under any circumstance!

The staff were too overwhelmed to check in with you or notice that the beer is flat or that they served you a different dish. Generally, the place seemed understaffed for when it got busy. The bill was actually illegible and incoherent, so you wouldn’t know what you paid for.

Jesus Centeno

Amazing service, people and views. The Burger is the best in Long Island.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pretzel, Sliders, Chicken Fingers, Wag's Wings, Clams on the Half Shell

James Girardi

A great hidden gem on the South Shore.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Joyce Quagliata

Great place on the water with bands in the summertime. Regular pub food. Had a blast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Spike Lee

Nice place, Great atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

James Florio

Good place for apps and beer. Plenty of indoor and outdoor dining.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gerald Parker

They're trying to change it up

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 3

Charlie Scheer

I used to go here often but don’t anymore because there NO door in the mens room. I don’t want to be looked at while I’m taking care of business. And I don’t want to look at anyone taking care of business. Either way, PUT A DAMN DOOR UP IN THE BATHROOM!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Loading...