Goodfellas Pizza
$$ • Pizza
Hours:
1 Hewitt St, Amsterdam
(518) 842-2202
About Goodfellas Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Goodfellas Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about Goodfellas Pizza
The best pizza in the area
Hadn't ordered a pizza from here in quite some time. I don't know why, I guess there's just too many pizza places to choose from in this city. Anyway, I ordered tonight and it was excellent. I had asked for extra cheese - I got extra cheese, something that rarely happens when I ask for extra cheese. That was a huge plus for me..... if I am asking you for extra cheese, that means I like cheese. Another thing I noticed... the crust itself was not tough. Over the past couple of weeks,...read full review
Just ordered $60 worth of pizza, wings and sampler platter for delivery and the driver couldn’t find our house with only 5 houses on the road and ours clearly numbered, the sampler platter was missing the marinara sauce and they wanted us to come pick it up and the wings with xtra sauce had NO xtra sauce. Like wtf. We are regulars but not anymore.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 10PM |
| Friday | 2 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 2 - 8PM |
Goodfellas Pizza is a local restaurant that provides delivery and take-out services. Known for its generously sized calzones, which look like folded pizzas, it also offers a variety of popular dishes. The garlic knots have a crispy exterior and a rich garlic butter flavor that customers love. The white pizza and Hawaiian pizza are highly recommended, along with the wings, which many consider the best. Customers have noted that the crust on the pizzas is excellent, not tough or chewy, making it a standout feature. The restaurant is praised for its reasonable prices and friendly staff, who are always in a good mood and provide great service. Recently, a customer mentioned that they received extra cheese, which is a rarity at other places, and appreciated the quick and professional service, even near closing time. Overall, Goodfellas Pizza is seen as a fantastic local option, delivering high-quality meals at reasonable prices and deserving of more recognition.