Macelleria Italian Steakhouse Armonk

Was a very disappointing dinner. First off the service was slow. We ordered appetizers and they were out of something so the kitchen decided to substitute without asking. The mussels were terrible and needed to be sent back. When the entrees came, one was missing and we were told that the kitchen forgot it. Two people ordered steak, which looked and tasted like it had been boiled. Both were sent back.

I enjoyed eating Chicken Martini with mashed potatoes and broccoli. The chicken is so succulent and delicious. My family member loved the Chicken Parmigiana with broccoli. The server Ada is always so welcoming and nice. The owner Nick always greets us and is very friendly. The ambiance was quiet and warm.

I came here for a large party and left hungry, thirsty, and extremely disappointed. Every single mixed drink that was ordered was beyond gross ! Two drinks were sent back because they couldn’t even attempt to drink them. The waitress seemed annoyed that the drinks were sent back . The bartender had to be new. The drinks ordered were all from the cocktail menu, so they should know how to make them. One of the guests described their drink as tasting like sewage.
The appetizers were ehh. Nothing was amazing. The octopus was very chewy. The Caesar salad was all iceberg lettuce. There was no green to the salad at all.
We were all expecting the steak to be great bc it’s a Steak restaurant. They never mentioned they were out of the Tomahawk, so that was disappointing. We got there at 7pm, so I’m not sure how they sold out in the two hours they were open prior to us arriving . My steak was still alive basically. It was supposed to be medium and it was rare. My friend sent his back bc it was under cooked, and when it was brought back it was still undercooked. The waitress said the corn was her favorite side so we got that. It was bland. There was no seasoning at all.
My friends said the pasta was great. I guess we should have known to get the pasta at a steakhouse. 🙄.

They also refused one of the guests to come bc he would have to wear a hat due to a medical condition.

Overall I would never come back.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Meatballs

Drinks were disgusting / food was horrible

Thick cut bacon - all fat
Steak - came out rare sent back still came back rare while ordering it medium
All drinks tasted like cheap alcohol

Only good thing was the crab cakes

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Macelleria Italian Steakhouse offers such a wide array of dinner selections. We started off with some warm bread with olive oil. I enjoyed a Beet salad with arugula and Goat cheese and grilled chicken which was superb! My family loved the steak and Chicken Parmigiana with clams with spaghetti. The owner Nick is so nice and friendly and always greets at the door and checks on his customers. The server Ada is always lovely too and takes our drink and dinner orders and does a wonderful job!

All of us had a wonderful dining experience. We loved everything from Chicken Martini, Chicken Parmigiana to steak along with sides of mashed potatoes, and broccoli. We also started off with warmed bread and olive oil as well as cheese, prosciutto wrapped over asparagus and peppers. Everything was so delicious. The service is amazing. There is free and ample parking and conveniently located off of Route 22 in the heart of Armonk.

Placed an order for delivery on their website at 7:45, website and email confirmation said 30min approximate delivery time. Called to check-in on the order at 8:45 and had to speak to multiple people, the last one finally saying they don’t do delivery and that they know their website says they do and it’s a know problem. They said they would make an exception for me which was weird as I ordered delivery from their website and food then arrived at 9:00 and was close to cold. It was missing one main entree, had to call and then wait another 25min for it. All of the food was mediocre at best. Terribly confused restaurant and service. So many options 100x better in town. Pass on this one.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Came here with high expectations and left pretty disappointed.

Service was friendly but lagged a bit. Drinks were pretty good.

Appetizers were not great. We order calamari which was BLAND and zucchini flowers that were tasty, but seemed to contain mostly batter and not much zucchini flower.

I ordered the NY Strip and was probably given the fattiest NY Strip I have ever ordered in my life. 1/3 of the steak was fat and inedible; it was also on the blander side and needed to be dressed up with sauces. It was, however, cooked correctly, and the sides we ordered were decent as well.

Portions are small; others ordered chicken dishes and were given two small pieces--so it's almost necessary to order the a la carte sides along with your entree.

Prices are fair for a "steakhouse"; however, I think the prices seem to reflect the portion and quality of the food-- so this may explain why it was cheaper than most others I've been to. Overall, was just okay, and it did not feel like, nor provide, the quality of a steakhouse.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

A wonderful dinner at this restaurant located in the heart of Armonk right off Route 22 and 684. There is always free and ample parking. The owner Nick always greets us with his great smile. Ada the waitress is so lovely and very friendly. My friend Cathy loved the Fried Calamari and Octopus as her dinner. I loved the Chicken Martini with mashed potatoes and broccoli. We shared a carrot cake and it was so delicious. Try dinner here Tuesday through Sunday, you will love it!

What ever this restaurant used to be, it is no longer. Billing it self as a high end Italian Steakhouse is just insulting.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Excellent dining experience in the heart of Armonk, NY. I loved the chicken martini with broccoli and mashed potatoes. My son, James, and his friend Chad, each enjoyed their steak and mashed potatoes. Chad loved the tartufo, and I enjoyed the hot cocoa and coconut sorbet. Wonderful service by Ada. Nick, the owner greeted all of us and said us at our table and was very nice to us.

Wonderful dinner with my son and our friend. My son and I both loved the Chicken Martini with broccoli. I also had a side of mashed potatoes which was so delicious. The restaurant was very busy but we still had great service. The owner Nick and server Ada were very friendly and nice to us.

New Years Eve was quite hectic and service was erratic. Second time we've dined here and I would recommend diners visit on regular weekends not holidays.

We were greeted by the wonderful owner Nick and lovely server Ada. I enjoyed and loved the Chicken Martini with broccoli and mashed potatoes. My family member loves the Chicken Parmigiana. The ambiance was nice and quiet. The restaurant is decorated with beautiful holiday decor. Service was excellent!

Where do I start. I wish I could give 10 stars all around. First time here and was floored. Greeted by owner, Nick. He was attentive all night. Great guy. Fairly new owner and doing it right. Wish him the best. Everything we ordered was over the top fantastic. Appetizers, Main Course, Sides, etc. We ordered Tomahawk steak and Porterhouse. Both came to table sliced and cooked perfect. Place is comfortable and not loud at all. We will be making this a regular stop and I wish Nick all the best.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5