Stellas Pizzeria 2

6 S Water St, Athens
(518) 945-1010

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maxim Milo

Pizza ok . Pasta not. Place set u back 50years . Ants on walls

Steve Junkins

Went on a Sunday for lunch with my daughter. Awesome little place. Great staff. Awesome food. Definitely will be back

Crystal P

Many times you order online & they never see your order. Today I waited an hour and a half for what I thought would be delivered because online you can select delivery. I called and the rude older woman answered saying they never received our order “let me grab this stupid tablet” then she sees it there immediately and says oh we no longer deliver during the day time. Why advertise delivery and have it as an online option if you don’t deliver?? Lately their food has been disgusting last week I got inedible garlic knots that tasted like uncooked flour was put on them instead of cheese. My calazone is always and I mean ALWAYS raw in the middle and most times I have random toppings thrown inside when I only ordered mushrooms. When we do get delivery the driver won’t come inside and calls to have us exit ththe apartment building and meet him outside… terrible service for being the only local place other than all the bars…

Jeff Wood

Tried it once again. I ordered Linguine and red clam sauce. There were raw plum tomatoes and the hard tops of the raw tasting sauce. No claim flavor at all. All I could taste was raw tomatoes. No seasoning at all. No oregano, basil... nothing. Not going back. Promise.

Bob Ricketson

Great service. The food is good. Try the soup, I sometimes get one to go for later. If it is really busy, it will be noisy.
I live close by, so it is easy to pick times it isn't so busy.

Bush

Best cheese pizza in the area! Never had a bad experience or long wait in many visits. 👍👍

voidsavage

Went there at 8:15. The site says they are open until 9. There is no one at all there.

Amber Clark

Great for breakfast lunch or dinner

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Sutton

The people are great and the food even better.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Quesadilla, Chicken Bacon Ranch Tostada

Kathleen McQuaid Holdridge

We come here regularly, mostly for breakfast on Sunday morning. We've also had dinner here. Portion sizes are always generous. Like most businesses now, sometimes there isn't enough serving staff. But even on hectic days they do their very best, especially Dawn.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Siobahn Pellegrino

3 stars for breakfast, not so much for dinner. Chicken tenders tasted fishy even though they were out of fish and chips.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

ed akus

Ordered a italian sub, chicken tenders, and a calzone. The sub wasn't very well put together and was more onion than anything. The chicken tenders were good. The calzone was huge but taste wise was very underwhelming. The staff was super friendly and the restruant was very comfortable. I will try them again for other things considering there menu is extensive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

George Chast

Wonderful breakfast. Perfectly done to our requests. Real Home Fries, not "breakfast potatoes" - perfect bacon and eggs, French toast and good coffee. Friendly and fast
Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 2-Eggs Home Fries and Toast, French Toast

Shawn Pett

First time there..Ordered boneless wings and sicilian pizza. Boneless wings had a coating that was more than the chicken and held the grease. Celery and carrots had brown ends and wilting, not fresh. Not advisable. For the best, go to Main street rest in Saugerties. The pizza was thin, and tasted of oil. Again not very good. was hoping this to be a new spot but I think I'll pass. Not for me. Can get better at Pompadoros. Sorry.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Cass L

Western omelet and French toast was DELISH !!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...