Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria Auburn

The best pizza in Auburn by a long shot and probably the best slices I've ever had. All the staff are fun and friendly, it's an awesome place to go sit down and have a slice, and they're not overpriced like every other pizza place seems to be nowadays.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Closing time or not, the attitude was awful, the place unsanitary, and the pizza old. Next time, this won’t just be a review—it’ll be a report to the health board. When kids are left to run a business without oversight, things go downhill fast.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Authentic Italian. Try the fried eggplant and ricotta pizza - it's heavenly. Welcoming and friendly staff. Great quality every time. Buona!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

I called and asked if they made Sicilian because I'm new to the area and I gave a local pizza shop a chance last night and was very disappointed. They said they sure do and they definitely did! Great tasting sauce and exactly what I was looking for.. thanks again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have never had a problem with the pizza and wings. When I ordered the pizza and wings, few of the wings not cooked fully or over cooked. The pizza was over cooked and the crust was hard

great pizza by the slice, for sure in our top 3 with Secret Pizza at the Comso in Vegas and Guido's in STL.

This place is Absolutely fantastic! I Absolutely love your food! Your workers are super sweet/welcoming! Great location for my lunch breaks at Five Below! I Absolutely love Mammas!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza big sloppy wet mess looks like they dumped juice all in the crust fell apart trying to pick it up who puts whole slice of deli ham on it to

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

I come to this pizza shop religiously, and I absolutely love the pizza and usually have amazing service here.

But tonight, I was made to feel like I was a thief. I walked in to have a dinner with my five year old. We went in to get slices. Told them I would like one slice of cheese and one slice of pepperoni and two breadsticks and one water bottle. We checked out and the total was $12 and some change. I paid thinking nothing of it, then went outside and we only had two slices of cheese and the bottle of water. I went inside and just asked if we could have a slice of pepperoni since my daughter loves that and that’s what I asked for. My pepperoni was still in the oven and they gave us the slice and I asked if they wanted the regular cheese back and the worker said no we are fine and can keep it. I walked back outside to enjoy our dinner and then realized, wait we didn’t get our breadsticks. So I went back inside again, and very nicely said we did not get our two bread sticks. The worker at register was fine and said oh I didn’t know you got breadsticks, but gave them to me anyways. I walked back outside again to eat my dinner , and I hear all of the workers loudly talking about me and how she didn’t hear me order the breadsticks multiple times, and I didn’t pay. I went in AGAIN and said and repeated everything I originally ordered and said I want to make sure I paid for everything and didn’t pay for something I received because I am not that type of person to get free stuff. The owner(I believe it is, the older Italian man), comes over to register and was VERY rude and raising voice in front of everyone at resteraunt at me saying no you got 4 slices of pizza!!! I said no I did not. Again, they only originally gave me two slices of plain pizza and a water and the total was $12. The owner then starts to press very loudly as he was typing in my total to see the price of what he “thought” I guess, he kept saying I got 4 slices when I literally only ordered two, and repeatedly said I underpaid. I said I would pay for what I didn’t apparently pay for, as literally it was ALL a misunderstanding and the worker not hearing me.

Again, I love this place usually and have spent a lot of money on pizza but the way I was treated was not right at all and super embarrassing.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizzas, Bread Sticks

2 cheese slices and a soda for $7 is on par for the area. Pizza is good, although a true New York pizza would be thin crust. This was a little on the doughy side. Otherwise a good deal for lunch.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizzas

Lord have mercy, best pizza I’ve had ever.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely the best!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza in Auburn, hands down. Great wings, great customer service, great garlic knots and baked goods too. Mama Maria's is gonna make me fat and happy about it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza in town, with tons of variety and helpful employees! My go-to lunch in Auburn!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They are on point. I don't remember when was the last time i walked into a place with this much care about they're customers. Not to mention the delicious food.
Great work guys thank you and I'll be back.. .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5