Michael's Restaurant

312 Clark St, Auburn
(315) 252-6194

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nicole Holmes

Best Italian I had in the area!

wagsman

We were there for a nice dinner. It was a nice dinner till we were presented our bill. We presented a gift certificate that was a few months expired. The waitress explained to us that they could not honor it. I told her I would pay the bill but will be calling the owner. I did during the week. He told me he would not honor it. After talking some more to him he did say he would honor it for $10, that was a quarter of the gift certificate vale of $40. My advice to anyone make sure your gift certificate is not expired. Needless to say we do not go to this restaurant and do not recommend it to anyone. This visit was about 4 years ago.

Karl Schneeberger

Website says they're open. However, they are closed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Andy Hunter

The Chicken Riggies were delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Desiree Nicotra

We went here for Mother’s Day for the first time. I’m a wheelchair user & online it stated “wheelchair accessible entrance & parking.” It was not wheelchair accessible at all. Parking was across the street. The table we were sat at was so long that you literally had to stretch your arm as far as possible to pass the bread basket. We ordered fried calamari appetizer & it was so bland & extremely fishy tasting. My pasta dish tasted like pasta straight out of the water it was boiled in. It had no flavor or seasoning at all, even with the sauce on it. My fiancé ordered stuffed shells that you could tell were frozen & they were awful. The side salads were lettuce, shaved carrots & 1 cherry tomato. I told our waitress about it & she sent another waitress over who was great. She said she was going to have the cook come out. No one came to the table to address the issues. The waitress came back & said,”I have to charge for the calamari & the soda.”

Niki W

Went for a friend's birthday, food was great and our waitress, Erin, was wonderful! Get the cheesecake!

D2950PBjackier

We have been to Michael's Restaurant quite a few times recently. Their sauce is literally the BEST I have ever had. The food is amazing, portions are plenty and the service is exceptional. Cozy, intimate atmosphere for a delicious dinner and a romantic night out!

Giveita Shank

Hidden gem! The waitstaff was very friendly and helpful. The food portions were large and well priced. The sauces were well executed and balanced. They even serve their food on Mckenzie Child plates.

Bob Ratliff

Food was amazing! We had the Valentines dinner for 2. I can’t say enough good! The Potatoes were like nothing we ever had! The Prime was huge! We couldn’t eat it all! We are going back soon! The place is a hidden gem!

Laurie Leitten

Was very disappointed as I have eaten here through the years and it was always good. Wait staff was polite, professional and very good other than being a bit rushed. We had stopped in due to the fact that we had called and they supposedly had gluten free options. My husband is celiac. Upon arrival we were told they were out of gluten free pasta. They didn't have any potatoes other than french fries with shared gluten items. My husband had the tenderloins and they were absolutely delicious, but that was all he could eat as they were out of all their gluten free options - even though we called beforehand. My husband got no sides, just meat and a side salad that was entirely lettuce greens with dressing - no tomato - nothing. So he had a very pricey meal with meat only. Would not go back. Have been warning people how bad it's gotten as it used to be really nice. All that money for three small pieces of meat. SMH

Keith Armitage

The atmosphere is good except for restrooms and booth seating. Both need an overhaul.

Shrimp scampi and pasta bolognese were great. So was our waitress Jenna.

Jackie Reilly

We recently had dinner at Michael’s and it was AMAZING! What a hidden gem! I absolutely love their sauce! Portions were very generous and the food was amazing and so was the service! We will definitely be back soon!!!

lgeisinger

We visited Michael’s on a Sunday evening with our family of 6. Such a perfect place for a family dinner! The staff was very attentive and so friendly. From the simple fresh crisp iceberg salads to our delicious entrees, everything was perfect! The tomato sauce served with pasta is beyond compare, the best sauce I’ve ever had, rich, sweet , simple but complex, nothing like it! Excellent meatballs too! Michael’s is like going to Sunday dinner at your Gramma’s. Homey, delicious, comfortable. We really had such a good time! Try it, or try it again!

Amy B

Fantastic as always. Prime Rib and veal for New Year’s Eve. Flambés bananas amaretto for dessert was phenomenal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jamie Walters

Food is always good! Absolutely love the appetizers and desserts.

Loading...