What a great neighborhood bar. I've lived 3 blocks over from the bar and never had any issues with noise or nuisance. I stop in once every 6 months. We have friends that come from all over the world to work for a week or two in Auburn, we always send them to Otoole's. The bar is quiet, has it's regulars, and cheap prices. O'Tooles has been a staple to the community for decades. Unfortunately the noisy neighbor who has no community ties - outsider -- has surveillance all over the place. Mind your manners outside or you can be posted to social media in one of his oppressive feeble posts.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Larry
Bar tender on Friday and Saturday is a absolute smoke show.
Erica I.
I've been waiting years to visit O'Toole's aka Jack's if you're a local, and tonight was my lucky night! I had the honor of meeting Jack, had a great conversation with him, had some cheap beer, played some pool and had the time of my life! It's a little divey but it's clean and has a ton of charm! Stick to canned beer/mixed drinks and you won't be disappointed! It's off the beaten path but worth a visit!
Pamela Anderegg
Friendly bartender, generous drinks and good service.
Deanna Brown
Little pricey. Nice layout
Heather
The atmosphere wasn't particularly friendly. My boyfriend thought that the bartender was kind of rude. Typical Auburn bar that just keeps hanging on.
James Udall
The general bar vibe is unfriendly and it is frequented by a regular clique who go there to drink almost daily and get hammered. 23 service calls to APD since June 2020 according to public records. . It’s quite something to see a venerable 115 year old bar being run into the ground. It’s a shame.
Melissa Clarke
Love this bar!
irishman1981 phill
O'Tooles Tavern is the best bar in auburn NY, great bartenders, and all around just fun to hang out. My favorite bar of choice hands down.??????
Funnn times
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
What a great neighborhood bar. I've lived 3 blocks over from the bar and never had any issues with noise or nuisance. I stop in once every 6 months. We have friends that come from all over the world to work for a week or two in Auburn, we always send them to Otoole's. The bar is quiet, has it's regulars, and cheap prices. O'Tooles has been a staple to the community for decades. Unfortunately the noisy neighbor who has no community ties - outsider -- has surveillance all over the place. Mind your manners outside or you can be posted to social media in one of his oppressive feeble posts.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Bar tender on Friday and Saturday is a absolute smoke show.
I've been waiting years to visit O'Toole's aka Jack's if you're a local, and tonight was my lucky night! I had the honor of meeting Jack, had a great conversation with him, had some cheap beer, played some pool and had the time of my life! It's a little divey but it's clean and has a ton of charm! Stick to canned beer/mixed drinks and you won't be disappointed! It's off the beaten path but worth a visit!
Friendly bartender, generous drinks and good service.
Little pricey. Nice layout
The atmosphere wasn't particularly friendly. My boyfriend thought that the bartender was kind of rude. Typical Auburn bar that just keeps hanging on.
The general bar vibe is unfriendly and it is frequented by a regular clique who go there to drink almost daily and get hammered. 23 service calls to APD since June 2020 according to public records. . It’s quite something to see a venerable 115 year old bar being run into the ground. It’s a shame.
Love this bar!
O'Tooles Tavern is the best bar in auburn NY, great bartenders, and all around just fun to hang out. My favorite bar of choice hands down.??????
Restaurantji Recommends
Not a bad place to have a couple of beers and chill
Nice bar, we had never been there before. Bartenders were very friendly & it was a nice place.
great service, cold beer
fun place to hang out, lot of nice people there
The service wasn't too great. Not as many options as other places in town, good prices though. Good environment for halloween!