Papa Paulie's Pizza
247 Genesee St, Auburn
(315) 253-5371
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Best pizza in the world. Not just Auburn. Loved it since is was Picirillos. This pizza is the OG of Auburn and kudos to the owner and staff for keeping it the same. Picirillo would be proud!
If there is a heaven I hope it smells like Papa Paulies!!!
I used to love Piccirillos pizza and literally cut my first tooth on their crust 59 years ago. When they sold the business I was heart broken but Paulies made the transition with the same recipes, quality and amazing flavor I loved as a child FLAWLESSLY!!
Hands down and second to none, they are the very best pizza!
I drive in at least once a month from Oswego just to get a pie from them. Crazy?...
I used to love Piccirillos pizza and literally cut my first tooth on their crust 59 years ago. When they sold the business I was heart broken but Paulies made the transition with the same recipes, quality and amazing flavor I loved as a child FLAWLESSLY!!
Hands down and second to none, they are the very best pizza!
I drive in at least once a month from Oswego just to get a pie from them. Crazy?...
If there is a heaven I hope it smells like Papa Paulies!!!I used to love Piccirillos pizza and literally cut my first tooth on their crust 59 years ago. When they sold the business I was heart broken but Paulies made the transition with the same recipes, quality and amazing flavor I loved as a child FLAWLESSLY!!Hands down and second to none, they are the very best pizza!I drive in at least once a month from Oswego just to get a pie from them. Crazy? Until you've had one you'll...
You May Also Like
The Sub Stop - 251 Genesee St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Salad, Fast Food, Pet Friendly
Spoon and Fork Asia Cuisine - 264 Genesee St
![]()
Asian, Sushi Bar, Thai, Vegetarian