Smitty's Fish House

343 Genesee St, Auburn
(315) 253-4043

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tim Rouse

These folks provide our fish for the fair, and the quality is always perfect

Kevin Brezee

Ordered 2 fish sandwiches to go tonight. 1 of them with fries. 1 of them with onion rings. Both pieces of fish weren't quite crispy..... Possibly not cooked long enough..... Not horrible. But not really good either.... semi-soggy..... And I wish I had looked in the box before I left. My wife had the order with French fries..... There was a big heaping pile of them. I had the order with onion rings. It came with 3. Yes 3 onion rings. That was it.
You can find better elsewhere.

Anna Crim

I’m a huge fan of fish dinners, so this place is one of my favorites!
I know they are always pretty busy and rushed on fish fridays, but I’ve never experienced bad service here. Their costumer service has always been wonderful and their food is super delicious and consistent, which is a big deal!
Besides there fish sandwiches, I recommend their onion rings and mac and cheese. 🤌🏻🤌🏻

thomas Decker

Best fish dinners I've ever had

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Catie Lynn

Underrated!! Super happy with our dinner choice tonight! Fried haddock dinner was spot on! Hands down my new favorite in town!

Jet40015163862

Excellent they sure can cook the fish dishes are well done.. Couldn't ask for better cooking 10 star for fish... or anything they have

Passport17757645593

It's over priced out of the freezer food. The Mac n cheese was terrible. Dry, little to no flavor and prob sat under a heat lamp for a couple days. 0 out of ten do not recommend. Rude service didn't help either.

Brandon Dacy

Raw food and rude employees...

TJ C

This is the best fish fry in town! Their fried fish sandwich is delicious. It has such a crisp fresh taste every time. I am hooked on it. Thank you Smitty's!

Conor Cushing

Service wasn’t friendly at all. Prices are absolutely ridiculous. Chicken sandwich and small Mac and cheese was $20. Fish sandwich and large Mac and cheese was $24. Going to price themselves right out of service.

Sandra Simmons

Excellent service. Outstanding food‼️

Marco Decoco

The new ATM machine and refusal to take credit cards any more goes along great with the fact they are always out of onion rings (must be the onion supply chain issues I've been reading so much about lately)Maybe just charge your customer a small extra % if they want to use their credit card instead of installing an ATM machine with a $3 fee attached to it would be the better business decision? That and not running out of onions two weeks in a row.Smittys was far and away the best place to get fried fish dinners in auburn years ago. Things aren't looking good right now.

Matthew Crossman

Great lil fish house.always good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matt Kim

owner came out and made my order even though the shack was closed. put together some fire food

Paul Gordon Carter

Our Fish was as we expected freshly ? cooked

Loading...