XL Cookie Company

33 Columbus St, Auburn
(315) 730-2711

Recent Reviews

Sort by
mikeylikesit2222

Best cookies I've had in a very long time! The cranberry white chocolate one was divine.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dana Stanton

These cookies are *chef's kiss*!

Courtney Johnston-Smith

I was having some cravings this morning and saw the Facebook post about what was in the shop this morning and had to go! It was my first time and I was blown away! The service was amazing, we chatted and had a great interaction that was super helpful and fun. Everything I've bought has been delicious. Cookies, hot cocoa bomb and baklava! I will absolutely be back and telling everyone I know.

Rick Warren

This morning I happened stop in this bakery, now being a chef my self, I indulged in 3 chocolate chip cookies, wow.. Outstanding.. You have to try it for yourselves...

Jodi Green

The lemon sugar cookie is amazing (ly soft)!

Stefanie Trop

6 stars! We pre-ordered cookie trays for a party. Casi was unbelievably communicative and friendly. She wanted to make sure I had nothing to worry about at all for my event and of course, the cookies were delicious and just what I wanted - simple, delicious, and feel homemade. The giant cookies she sells out of the case are also amazing. They kept well for several days. Thank you so much!

Kathy Lander-Garuccio

Just bought some cookies today - we have tasted 2 of the flavors so far and they are the best cookies we’ve ever had!!! Sooooo good!!! Cookies are huge too!!!

Joe Varga

What a great little shop! Great appearance, very clean, well organized, easy to see selections, and spectacular cookies!

Brittney Colton

The BEST cookies around! A variety of types of cookies, bars, and bombs; will make the decisions hard.Owner strives for perfectionAlways has fresh warm cookies

Brittney Mikula

Some of the best cookies you can find in NY, their size makes them extra unique.

Dawn Mosher

She always has the best cookies. I stop on every time I'm in New York

Brittney Mikula

The BEST cookies around! A variety of types of cookies, bars, and bombs; will make the decisions hard.

Jodi Lamphier

The lemon sugar cookie is amazing (ly soft)!

Diana Bunnell-Remillard

These are not your mother's cookies! They are XL and delish!!

zz rd

Local maple syrup and 2 different cookies made with it?! Yes Please!! Casi loves what she does and it absolutely shows! I'll be back to try more soon (-:

Loading...