We had a great experience a few months ago - this time around the potato was uncooked and dinner entrees were bland, wondering if they have a new chef or something- unfortunately I would probably not return to this restaurant next time I'm visiting
Very nice hotel restaurant with a great chef. The 4 course meal with international wine pairings is excellent. Although the wine may be from open bottles, only the champagne seemed a bit flat. The course selections are varied; the food quality an presentation are excellent. In addition the server was very attentive and well informed.
The four course meal experience was phenomenal. My sister and I chose different dishes from each other for each course so we got to sample double the food, and let me tell you, that was a great decision! Everything was deliciously and beautifully prepared. Service was excellent. 
We always love dining at 1833. Just being in the beautifully taken care of historical rooms is wonderful. Combine that with wonderful food which is beautifully presented, friendly and knowledgeable servers, and the gorgeous view...it's a fabulous place to spend some time.
Everything here was marvelous. This was our first time in Aurora and we were celebrating my boyfriend's 30th birthday. When booking the dinner reservation, I mentioned this. The staff was super thoughtful and charismatic the entire time. The small details of seating us by the window during sunset down to the perfect subtle birthday touch for dessert, I will always come here for the most special occasions because of the perfect night they gave us that we will remember forever.
RandyfromRochester
WE had a party of 6 and we made a reservation for 7:30pm and we were promptly seated. Our waitress was wonderful and on point- not too intrusive, but very attentive. Choices to order ala carte or a 4 course meal, and our party did both. Food was excellent, perfect temperature and a good amount of food.
PattiW
On the day of the total eclipse, we were so happily surprised At the wonderful brunch, fantastic view, ambience, great service, great food at great value, and the quiet atmosphere. So worth the trip - will come again.
It was a wonderful experience, food was great. Presentation was great the waiting staff was wonderful, polite, kind, timely mannered they ambience is beyond belief. What a wonderful place to be at on a sunny day. The Cayuga Lake is extraordinary.
KristineE
We had an amazing time during our 4-course meal + Finger lakes pairings! The first course and the dessert were our favorites, and the staff was knowledgeable and incredibly helpful. We would absolutely come back!
Maria C
Our server was SO courteous, professional and patient. He actually waited to talk to us and didn't interrupt our family conversation. It was incredibly kind and we will always remember this level of service....wish other wait staff in other restaurants did this.
Enjoyed the 4 course experience. First two courses were very well thought out with unique combination of flavors. The scallop entree was slightly oversalted. The pheasant entree was seasoned well and was not to dried out for a lean meat. Overall a nice experience but slightly below par for the expectation.
MichelleB
FANTASTIC fine dining experience. Incredible, creative food, friendly and professional staff, and an elegant, romantic evening setting. I cannot offer enough compliments to 1833 Kitchen & Bar, and am already planning my 6 hour drive to return for more meals!
Phil Porter
Great atmosphere, Alexandra was our waitress and was exceptionally perfect. We had the 4 course Valentine's Special, in which you select from 3 to 6 options for each course. You could also do wine pairings for each course as well, though we opted for the superb and interesting cocktails. Amazing dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MichelleS
Lovely! I have Celiac and I saw on Instagram that they had a new gluten free dessert, white mocha cream cake, and I had to try it. It was just as fabulous as it sounds. The staff here was so wonderful, and the food and views were off the charts. Try the banana spritz, by the way! You won't be disappointed!
We had a great experience a few months ago - this time around the potato was uncooked and dinner entrees were bland, wondering if they have a new chef or something- unfortunately I would probably not return to this restaurant next time I'm visiting
Very nice hotel restaurant with a great chef. The 4 course meal with international wine pairings is excellent. Although the wine may be from open bottles, only the champagne seemed a bit flat. The course selections are varied; the food quality an presentation are excellent. In addition the server was very attentive and well informed.
The four course meal experience was phenomenal. My sister and I chose different dishes from each other for each course so we got to sample double the food, and let me tell you, that was a great decision! Everything was deliciously and beautifully prepared. Service was excellent. 
We always love dining at 1833. Just being in the beautifully taken care of historical rooms is wonderful. Combine that with wonderful food which is beautifully presented, friendly and knowledgeable servers, and the gorgeous view...it's a fabulous place to spend some time.
Everything here was marvelous. This was our first time in Aurora and we were celebrating my boyfriend's 30th birthday. When booking the dinner reservation, I mentioned this. The staff was super thoughtful and charismatic the entire time. The small details of seating us by the window during sunset down to the perfect subtle birthday touch for dessert, I will always come here for the most special occasions because of the perfect night they gave us that we will remember forever.
WE had a party of 6 and we made a reservation for 7:30pm and we were promptly seated. Our waitress was wonderful and on point- not too intrusive, but very attentive. Choices to order ala carte or a 4 course meal, and our party did both. Food was excellent, perfect temperature and a good amount of food.
On the day of the total eclipse, we were so happily surprised At the wonderful brunch, fantastic view, ambience, great service, great food at great value, and the quiet atmosphere. So worth the trip - will come again.
It was a wonderful experience, food was great. Presentation was great the waiting staff was wonderful, polite, kind, timely mannered they ambience is beyond belief. What a wonderful place to be at on a sunny day. The Cayuga Lake is extraordinary.
We had an amazing time during our 4-course meal + Finger lakes pairings! The first course and the dessert were our favorites, and the staff was knowledgeable and incredibly helpful. We would absolutely come back!
Our server was SO courteous, professional and patient. He actually waited to talk to us and didn't interrupt our family conversation. It was incredibly kind and we will always remember this level of service....wish other wait staff in other restaurants did this.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Outstanding food, atmosphere and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Enjoyed the 4 course experience. First two courses were very well thought out with unique combination of flavors. The scallop entree was slightly oversalted. The pheasant entree was seasoned well and was not to dried out for a lean meat. Overall a nice experience but slightly below par for the expectation.
FANTASTIC fine dining experience. Incredible, creative food, friendly and professional staff, and an elegant, romantic evening setting. I cannot offer enough compliments to 1833 Kitchen & Bar, and am already planning my 6 hour drive to return for more meals!
Great atmosphere, Alexandra was our waitress and was exceptionally perfect. We had the 4 course Valentine's Special, in which you select from 3 to 6 options for each course. You could also do wine pairings for each course as well, though we opted for the superb and interesting cocktails. Amazing dinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely! I have Celiac and I saw on Instagram that they had a new gluten free dessert, white mocha cream cake, and I had to try it. It was just as fabulous as it sounds. The staff here was so wonderful, and the food and views were off the charts. Try the banana spritz, by the way! You won't be disappointed!