My husband and I happened upon a small bag of Jamaican Me Happy at a winery during a visit to NY- it was love at first cup…first sniff, really haha. Since then, I’ve had to get my fix by ordering online. TWICE now, these lovely humans have upsized items in our online order, and thrown in amazing bonuses as well!! Few things in this world are better than large quantities of high quality, delicious coffee!! It’s worth the out of state shipping cost when we receive our “happy mail”.Thanks Evening Star! You know we’ll be back!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robert Bowes
This is my first coffee order I received from Evening Star. The coffee was roasted to perfection, fresh, and tasted delicious. Evening Star is who I will order my coffee from now on.
Service: 5
Erin McCormick
Truly the best coffee I've had. I've been drinking Jamaican Me Happy for the last ~7-8 years whenever I could get my hands on a bag, but each time I drink it it brings the same amount of joy as my first ever cup! Fast shipping, and the sample that gets thrown in with orders is much appreciated. Looking forward to trying many more flavors in the years to come!
Adrian Hornby
Good coffee, great prices, rapid delivery and a freebie in each package. Great to support a local family company and save $! Ground coffee is too coarse for espresso machines, but works for filter or press. Fantastic service, highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Luce
Amazing coffee and a great family business!! Jamaican Me Happy is 7 stars!
Ruth L.
I got a text from my staff on a Saturday morning that the brewer wasn't working. I texted Jody and within 30 min he was there, and had it fixed quickly. He always goes over and above.
Karen Miceli
We received a sample of Irish Cream coffee from Jody and it was delicious. It was not to sweet, flavor not overpowering, rich coffee taste, and the right amount of caffeine, and the smell was amazing. Great coffee?
Anne Richardson Fitzgerald
I love their coffee and their customer service! Your order arrives quickly and everyone is very helpful if you have any questions or issues.Order some coffee today!
dee fuller
What a nice guy! Recently ran into to Jody delivering coffee at Peppermints in Avon, NY. He gave me a sample I can't wait to try! Was excited to find out I could do a drive by pick up! Thank you Jody!
dena frydman
I was gifted a bag of Peru dark roast by the" Coffee Man", totally better than the Candy Man. It really made my day. It is deelish smoth no bitter or aciduc after taste. How did you kniw I drink Dark Roasr? Excellent coffee. Thanks again
I am so fortunate to have discovered Evening Star Coffee! Not only do I get to support a local business but the quality and value are outstanding! There are so many different varieties that we are tasting our way through the menu. My husband has proclaimed the Creation Roast “the best coffee he has ever had”. I am currently enjoying the Sugar and Spice. The easy curbside pickup makes it a breeze to grab your order when convenient. It’s totally worth the drive from Monroe County!
Denise Scannell
If you haven’t tried Evening Star Coffee then you’re missing out. The quality is superb—smooth taste with a variety of dark to blonde roasts and interesting and delicious flavors. Our customers love our special MacFaddens Blonde roast and bananas foster. The family owned business has great customer service too.
shannon morgan
I cannot rave enough about this coffee! I was not a big coffee drinker until I had this! “Jamaican Me Happy” is a must, and absolute favorite! Amazing customer service as well! Highly recommend!
Michael Heisler
Amazing customer service and product! Made my first order and when I went to pick it up I got to meet the owner Jody who gave me a tour and showed me the coffee bean process and gave a couple free samples, the Captain Jack is great with awesome flavor. Great company and awesome customer service!
Sandy Holdridge
Great to have a coffee roaster locally. There are so many choices and they are very easy to work with. Answered questions about all the choices to help me decide. Found it very easy to pick up my order curb side. Thank you, can’t wait to try blonde roast tomorrow morning.
My husband and I happened upon a small bag of Jamaican Me Happy at a winery during a visit to NY- it was love at first cup…first sniff, really haha. Since then, I’ve had to get my fix by ordering online. TWICE now, these lovely humans have upsized items in our online order, and thrown in amazing bonuses as well!! Few things in this world are better than large quantities of high quality, delicious coffee!! It’s worth the out of state shipping cost when we receive our “happy mail”.Thanks Evening Star! You know we’ll be back!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is my first coffee order I received from Evening Star. The coffee was roasted to perfection, fresh, and tasted delicious. Evening Star is who I will order my coffee from now on.
Service: 5
Truly the best coffee I've had. I've been drinking Jamaican Me Happy for the last ~7-8 years whenever I could get my hands on a bag, but each time I drink it it brings the same amount of joy as my first ever cup! Fast shipping, and the sample that gets thrown in with orders is much appreciated. Looking forward to trying many more flavors in the years to come!
Good coffee, great prices, rapid delivery and a freebie in each package. Great to support a local family company and save $! Ground coffee is too coarse for espresso machines, but works for filter or press. Fantastic service, highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing coffee and a great family business!! Jamaican Me Happy is 7 stars!
I got a text from my staff on a Saturday morning that the brewer wasn't working. I texted Jody and within 30 min he was there, and had it fixed quickly. He always goes over and above.
We received a sample of Irish Cream coffee from Jody and it was delicious. It was not to sweet, flavor not overpowering, rich coffee taste, and the right amount of caffeine, and the smell was amazing. Great coffee?
I love their coffee and their customer service! Your order arrives quickly and everyone is very helpful if you have any questions or issues.Order some coffee today!
What a nice guy! Recently ran into to Jody delivering coffee at Peppermints in Avon, NY. He gave me a sample I can't wait to try! Was excited to find out I could do a drive by pick up! Thank you Jody!
I was gifted a bag of Peru dark roast by the" Coffee Man", totally better than the Candy Man. It really made my day. It is deelish smoth no bitter or aciduc after taste. How did you kniw I drink Dark Roasr? Excellent coffee. Thanks again
Restaurantji Recommends
I am so fortunate to have discovered Evening Star Coffee! Not only do I get to support a local business but the quality and value are outstanding! There are so many different varieties that we are tasting our way through the menu. My husband has proclaimed the Creation Roast “the best coffee he has ever had”. I am currently enjoying the Sugar and Spice. The easy curbside pickup makes it a breeze to grab your order when convenient. It’s totally worth the drive from Monroe County!
If you haven’t tried Evening Star Coffee then you’re missing out. The quality is superb—smooth taste with a variety of dark to blonde roasts and interesting and delicious flavors. Our customers love our special MacFaddens Blonde roast and bananas foster. The family owned business has great customer service too.
I cannot rave enough about this coffee! I was not a big coffee drinker until I had this! “Jamaican Me Happy” is a must, and absolute favorite! Amazing customer service as well! Highly recommend!
Amazing customer service and product! Made my first order and when I went to pick it up I got to meet the owner Jody who gave me a tour and showed me the coffee bean process and gave a couple free samples, the Captain Jack is great with awesome flavor. Great company and awesome customer service!
Great to have a coffee roaster locally. There are so many choices and they are very easy to work with. Answered questions about all the choices to help me decide. Found it very easy to pick up my order curb side. Thank you, can’t wait to try blonde roast tomorrow morning.