I enjoyed the nice, beautiful atmosphere in Fratelli's. The menu in this authentic Italian restaurant is impressive. I ordered the linguine with vodka sauce, and the dish was delicious! The portion sizes are absolutely huge. I ordered a half plate and still took a box home. I would have given the food 5 stars based on the great taste. However, the dish I had was a bit oily, and I believe it gave me some stomach distress. Overall, my first impression is that this is a nice place. I will try something else on the menu next time I visit Fratelli's.
Julie C.
Very overpriced and LOUD in the dining area. Would not recommend!!!
Joe Spagnuolo
Fratelli’s is a decent Italian place for in person dining. They receive this score for one big reason. Their takeout experience is unacceptable. They charge full restaurant prices for portions that are about half the size. We have stopped ordering salads altogether from them when we take out- it’s generously a third of the in person size. Our most recent order was the breaking point. We will go elsewhere for takeout Italian.
Erika O'Brien
Fratelli’s: my favorite restaurant until tonight. I had been waiting to go for so long & then we went. No wait for a Friday night - kind of odd. The warm bread was amazing! Our server was wonderful and attentive.
I have nothing good to say regarding the food other than the bread. Long time favorites were gone from the appetizer menu. No little neck clams or shrimp cocktail. The clam chowder was runny with no flavor except for a strong fishy one. The seafood dish I had was full of pasta and short on flavor and seafood. The juice (?) it was in was very plain and needed seasoning. There were a lot of chopped clams and a few chewy shrimp. Some giant scallops and very small mussels. I hardly ate any of it and would rather throw it away than have it for leftovers, even at $38 a plate. We spent way too much money on terrible food. I actually never want to go there again which is so sad. The food used to be flavorful and delicious. Every bite was to be savored. This was pathetic. Yes, cutting costs in today’s economy makes sense. But taking away good food and maybe a good chef does not make sense at all. You can still provide good food. I was always willing to pay good money for the prior delicious food, and still would. I thought I was tonight, but it was just a waste of money.
Becks McKeown
A local gem! Everything is delicious, but it’s hard for me to get anything other than the gnocchi. It’s the best I’ve had!
Cheryl Duffy
I order the breaded fish fry once in a while. The fish fry is very good but also very expensive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Michael Seidel
Always top notch Italian food. It would be hard to find a better meal.
The meal was chicken Parm with rigatoni. It was a great sized meal . We were there for a presentation so there was a bit of distraction
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana over Pasta
Roger Reddy
I don't give perfect reviews very often but this is the best Italian restaurant in the western Finger Lakes. Huge portions, delicious food, welcoming staff and superlative service. Our server, Andrea, was a delight. She even staged our family picture in the lounge area.
Excellent place for very good food. The staff is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tour of Italy, Alfredo
Patricia Ficarella
Went for our anniversary every year loved the food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce, Tour of Italy, Alfredo
beth fitzsimmons
Four of us arrived with a small child without a reservation. We understood we may not be able to eat there. When we asked the hostess if it would be possible her first response, said very rudely, was “this is going to be a tricky problem”. She then took her arm and waved it at us telling us to “move over there while I take care of the people with reservations.” We were in shock. We then all mutually decided we were not going to wait for an answer, we were not staying in an establishment where the hostess treats people so incredibly rudely. My advice? Do NOT go there without a reservation!
Service: 1
Justin Flint
Great place, with tons if room for larger groups, often live music by the bar when you walk in, servers were wonderful, food was delicious- does not have traditional Italian restaurant drink menu. Would eat here again
Parking: At front door and around building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Tour of Italy, Homemade Ravioli
I enjoyed the nice, beautiful atmosphere in Fratelli's. The menu in this authentic Italian restaurant is impressive. I ordered the linguine with vodka sauce, and the dish was delicious! The portion sizes are absolutely huge. I ordered a half plate and still took a box home. I would have given the food 5 stars based on the great taste. However, the dish I had was a bit oily, and I believe it gave me some stomach distress. Overall, my first impression is that this is a nice place. I will try something else on the menu next time I visit Fratelli's.
Very overpriced and LOUD in the dining area. Would not recommend!!!
Fratelli’s is a decent Italian place for in person dining. They receive this score for one big reason.
Their takeout experience is unacceptable. They charge full restaurant prices for portions that are about half the size. We have stopped ordering salads altogether from them when we take out- it’s generously a third of the in person size. Our most recent order was the breaking point. We will go elsewhere for takeout Italian.
Fratelli’s: my favorite restaurant until tonight. I had been waiting to go for so long & then we went. No wait for a Friday night - kind of odd. The warm bread was amazing! Our server was wonderful and attentive.
I have nothing good to say regarding the food other than the bread. Long time favorites were gone from the appetizer menu. No little neck clams or shrimp cocktail.
The clam chowder was runny with no flavor except for a strong fishy one. The seafood dish I had was full of pasta and short on flavor and seafood. The juice (?) it was in was very plain and needed seasoning. There were a lot of chopped clams and a few chewy shrimp. Some giant scallops and very small mussels. I hardly ate any of it and would rather throw it away than have it for leftovers, even at $38 a plate.
We spent way too much money on terrible food. I actually never want to go there again which is so sad. The food used to be flavorful and delicious. Every bite was to be savored. This was pathetic.
Yes, cutting costs in today’s economy makes sense. But taking away good food and maybe a good chef does not make sense at all. You can still provide good food. I was always willing to pay good money for the prior delicious food, and still would. I thought I was tonight, but it was just a waste of money.
A local gem! Everything is delicious, but it’s hard for me to get anything other than the gnocchi. It’s the best I’ve had!
I order the breaded fish fry once in a while. The fish fry is very good but also very expensive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Always top notch Italian food. It would be hard to find a better meal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Homemade Bread, Lasagna, Homemade Ravioli, Alfredo
The meal was chicken Parm with rigatoni. It was a great sized meal . We were there for a presentation so there was a bit of distraction
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana over Pasta
I don't give perfect reviews very often but this is the best Italian restaurant in the western Finger Lakes. Huge portions, delicious food, welcoming staff and superlative service. Our server, Andrea, was a delight. She even staged our family picture in the lounge area.
Wheelchair accessibility: Ground level, flush entry.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana over Pasta, Sausage, Homemade Bread, Tour of Italy, Chicken French, Vodka Sauce
Ordered to go.ready on time. So incredibly salty that it was not enjoyable
Food: 2
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Good food, service and atmosphere is very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent place for very good food. The staff is amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tour of Italy, Alfredo
Went for our anniversary every year loved the food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce, Tour of Italy, Alfredo
Four of us arrived with a small child without a reservation. We understood we may not be able to eat there. When we asked the hostess if it would be possible her first response, said very rudely, was “this is going to be a tricky problem”. She then took her arm and waved it at us telling us to “move over there while I take care of the people with reservations.” We were in shock. We then all mutually decided we were not going to wait for an answer, we were not staying in an establishment where the hostess treats people so incredibly rudely. My advice? Do NOT go there without a reservation!
Service: 1
Great place, with tons if room for larger groups, often live music by the bar when you walk in, servers were wonderful, food was delicious- does not have traditional Italian restaurant drink menu. Would eat here again
Parking: At front door and around building
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Antipasto Salad, Tour of Italy, Homemade Ravioli
Loading...