We had dinner there on Thanksgiving Day. The special menu was 3 courses, price fixed. A wonderful selection of items, something for everyone's tastes. The food was delicious, well plated and well timed. Staff were cheerful and energic, ambience was lovely and the manager, Joe, went out of his way to greet and take a polaroid of each table. We have eaten there other times as well and the experience has been consistent. Highly recommend.
PaulU
Food was excellent! Large portions, service excellent! Nice decor and ambiance, looking forward to going back
Kathy
Fantastic dinner at Argyle Grill! We all had the prix fixe special since we were there on a weeknight for its' offering. Appetizers were short rib Wellington (out-of-this world!) and spicy tuna on rice cakes (amazing!) For the mains we had short ribs with mashed potatoes and wine demi glaze and the chicken sorrentino (delicious). Portions are generous (we had to box up half of each order) and the weekday special also includes dessert. The snickers cheesecake and tiramisu —- big portions of decadent goodness! Enjoyed every bite. The staff was attentive and welcoming - the restaurant has tables nicely spaced between parties which helps to have conversations. Highly recommend —- we'll, definitely, be returning! Thanks Argyle Grill!!
Darcy
The staff all around was phenomenal, waiter especially. We went for brunch & though it may seem limited, the options are mint. Brioche French Toast is an absolute must. Top 3 Avocado Toast IMO. Crunchy toast, REAL AVOCADO slices, just perfect. If you're a Bloody Mary person, the loaded is for you! Great location, lots of parking, definitely a Long Island staple.
Niamh
The service was impeccable and the food delectable. My 40th birthday will surely be remembered. Thank you Argyle!
Sean
The new owners brought this place back to life. The food was incredible and our waiter was great too. The manager Joe took great care of us as well. We will definitely be coming back! Thank you!!!
MichaelC
Argyle Grill is a great place with very good food and service. The bar area and booths adjacent is very noisy. The dining room in back is better. A little pricey for what you get, but that is the story with most places these days.
Kim
Great dining experience - food and service were exceptional. Great way to spend a special occasion !
Donna Liucci
Absolutely Blown Away by The Argyle Grill!
I just had one of the best dining experiences in recent memory at The Argyle Grill in Babylon Village, and I had to share it. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and had a great classic vibe, but the food and drinks truly stole the show.
I ordered the skirt steak, and it was cooked to absolute perfection—tender, juicy, and seasoned flawlessly. It was one of those meals you don't want to end. For sides, we went with the sautéed spinach and the mac and cheese. The spinach was fresh and flavorful, and the mac and cheese was the ultimate comfort food: creamy, cheesy, and delicious. Every single bite of food was incredible.
The quality didn't stop with the food. A huge shout-out to my bartender, Jay, who is a true drink master! I had an old fashioned that was perfectly balanced and smooth. We also ordered a gin dirty martini, which was expertly crafted—crisp, cold, and exactly how it should be made.
Overall, it was a 10/10 experience. Amazing food, perfect drinks, and a great setting. If you're in Babylon Village, you absolutely have to check out The Argyle Grill. I'm already planning my next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Fleischman
Just one of the best places. The food. The people. Atmosphere. This place has an energy and life about it that is complimented by its staff and food that is simply perfection. Thank you for saving it!!
We had the absolute pleasure of celebrating our mom's birthday at this incredible restaurant, and from start to finish, everything was nothing short of perfect. A massive thank you to Joe, whose attention to every single detail did not go unnoticed. His care, professionalism, and genuine warmth made us feel so welcomed and cared for—he sets the tone for the entire experience, and it shows. Every moment felt intentional and seamless, and that's all thanks to his leadership and dedication. The staff were equally wonderful—attentive, kind, and on point the entire evening. And a special shoutout to Holly behind the bar—not only are her drinks amazing, but her energy and personality lit up the room. She's a gem! And of course, the food... wow. Absolutely delicious. Every dish was beautifully presented and packed with flavor—truly a celebration in itself. We're so grateful to have had the chance to celebrate such a special occasion in such a special place. Thank you again for making our mom's birthday so memorable—we'll be talking about it for a long time, and we can't wait to come back!
Paula
Since the reopening and new owners, the food and service has been excellant!! and the prices are reasonable and the portions are big.
Marvyn Blake
My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Dawn
We celebrated our son's birthday- delicious salads, meatballs, steaks and bass- excellent service
Steve
Food was great. Service was amazing. Everyone was very nice and helpful! This quickly became our go to spot for date night :)
We had dinner there on Thanksgiving Day. The special menu was 3 courses, price fixed. A wonderful selection of items, something for everyone's tastes. The food was delicious, well plated and well timed. Staff were cheerful and energic, ambience was lovely and the manager, Joe, went out of his way to greet and take a polaroid of each table. We have eaten there other times as well and the experience has been consistent. Highly recommend.
Food was excellent! Large portions, service excellent! Nice decor and ambiance, looking forward to going back
Fantastic dinner at Argyle Grill! We all had the prix fixe special since we were there on a weeknight for its' offering. Appetizers were short rib Wellington (out-of-this world!) and spicy tuna on rice cakes (amazing!) For the mains we had short ribs with mashed potatoes and wine demi glaze and the chicken sorrentino (delicious). Portions are generous (we had to box up half of each order) and the weekday special also includes dessert. The snickers cheesecake and tiramisu —- big portions of decadent goodness! Enjoyed every bite. The staff was attentive and welcoming - the restaurant has tables nicely spaced between parties which helps to have conversations. Highly recommend —- we'll, definitely, be returning! Thanks Argyle Grill!!
The staff all around was phenomenal, waiter especially. We went for brunch & though it may seem limited, the options are mint. Brioche French Toast is an absolute must. Top 3 Avocado Toast IMO. Crunchy toast, REAL AVOCADO slices, just perfect. If you're a Bloody Mary person, the loaded is for you! Great location, lots of parking, definitely a Long Island staple.
The service was impeccable and the food delectable. My 40th birthday will surely be remembered. Thank you Argyle!
The new owners brought this place back to life. The food was incredible and our waiter was great too. The manager Joe took great care of us as well. We will definitely be coming back! Thank you!!!
Argyle Grill is a great place with very good food and service. The bar area and booths adjacent is very noisy. The dining room in back is better. A little pricey for what you get, but that is the story with most places these days.
Great dining experience - food and service were exceptional. Great way to spend a special occasion !
Absolutely Blown Away by The Argyle Grill!
I just had one of the best dining experiences in recent memory at The Argyle Grill in Babylon Village, and I had to share it. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was welcoming and had a great classic vibe, but the food and drinks truly stole the show.
I ordered the skirt steak, and it was cooked to absolute perfection—tender, juicy, and seasoned flawlessly. It was one of those meals you don't want to end. For sides, we went with the sautéed spinach and the mac and cheese. The spinach was fresh and flavorful, and the mac and cheese was the ultimate comfort food: creamy, cheesy, and delicious. Every single bite of food was incredible.
The quality didn't stop with the food. A huge shout-out to my bartender, Jay, who is a true drink master! I had an old fashioned that was perfectly balanced and smooth. We also ordered a gin dirty martini, which was expertly crafted—crisp, cold, and exactly how it should be made.
Overall, it was a 10/10 experience. Amazing food, perfect drinks, and a great setting. If you're in Babylon Village, you absolutely have to check out The Argyle Grill. I'm already planning my next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just one of the best places. The food. The people. Atmosphere. This place has an energy and life about it that is complimented by its staff and food that is simply perfection. Thank you for saving it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We had the absolute pleasure of celebrating our mom's birthday at this incredible restaurant, and from start to finish, everything was nothing short of perfect. A massive thank you to Joe, whose attention to every single detail did not go unnoticed. His care, professionalism, and genuine warmth made us feel so welcomed and cared for—he sets the tone for the entire experience, and it shows. Every moment felt intentional and seamless, and that's all thanks to his leadership and dedication. The staff were equally wonderful—attentive, kind, and on point the entire evening. And a special shoutout to Holly behind the bar—not only are her drinks amazing, but her energy and personality lit up the room. She's a gem! And of course, the food... wow. Absolutely delicious. Every dish was beautifully presented and packed with flavor—truly a celebration in itself. We're so grateful to have had the chance to celebrate such a special occasion in such a special place. Thank you again for making our mom's birthday so memorable—we'll be talking about it for a long time, and we can't wait to come back!
Since the reopening and new owners, the food and service has been excellant!! and the prices are reasonable and the portions are big.
My wife and I enjoyed the service, they were friendly. We went on a Sunday, so we were happy to get parking. Food was a hit and miss. So were the drinks. The margarita was delicious and the short rib wellingtons were amazing. I would recommend giving this restaurant a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
We celebrated our son's birthday- delicious salads, meatballs, steaks and bass- excellent service
Food was great. Service was amazing. Everyone was very nice and helpful! This quickly became our go to spot for date night :)
Loading...