On a busy Saturday, the crew at Argyle was most accommodating to a large group of us, including an elderly patron. Great food, pleasant, professional service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jack Hyde
Saw an employee use the bathroom and not wash his hands afterwards. Not coming back.
Danielle C
My husband and I came here for his birthday dinner. The hostess was so friendly and pleasant. Something we unfortunately have not experienced lately and it is definitely an important detail that plays a part in setting the tone for a dining experience. When we were seated, the waiter was prompt with introducing himself and getting drink orders. Throughout the night, he was attentive, prompt and so sweet. I had a Watermelon martini. There's was a little issue with the drink but very happy to say it was taken care of immediately. We had the calamari, Brie stuffed pretzel, skirt steak and stuff salmon. Everything was delicious. The one issue that I did have was that when we went to pay the bill with my Citibank card, the waiter returned and said that there is an issue with their machine so they can't take the card. When I questioned this, he said this has been happening for a few years where their machine doesn't process the Citibank cards. I was surprised to hear this because if it has been an issue that can't be resolved, something should be posted and patrons should be notified. I have worked in the restaurant business and have never heard of an issue like this lasting for years without it being resolved. My thought was though, what about patrons that all they have are citibank cards to pay without the option of getting cash. They would have dined and would be unable to pay? Overall we had a nice dining experience and will visit again but I hope the Citi issue can be resolved or posted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Calamari
Christine I.
Very impressed with the food and service here. Extremely friendly and helpful staff and the food was very good. They had a prix fix menu - $35 for a salad, main course, and a dessert and all of it was delicious. Would definitely go back!!
Carol C
Nice place but loud. Food was very good. Easy parking in rear lot.Parking: Free lot in back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Philip Kohler
Loved it. Along with really good food and really nice staff, there's some terrific photography in the back section.
The service was awesome and the drinks were strong. Highly recommend the stuffed clams
Maria C.
Growing up in Babylon the Argyle's a staple. Always a great bar crowd with the best cocktails. Their food is also amazing. We went for lunch today and started with the king pow shrimp and calamari over soba noodles. Always delicious. We also got the goat cheese salads with skirt steak on top. Very yummy. Their watermelon martinis are a must try! Everything was good but the service was not it today. Our dude Matt must have went on a long break or just went home cause 35 minutes he never came back lol I got up looking for him and a female server came over to help us. She refilled our drinks and then brought us the check. Just really weird to leave in the middle of having a table without saying a word.
linda marshall
Will go back. Love it. My firest time going there.
Hosted a birthday brunch for our Mom. The manager Carissa was extremely accommodating and professionally. She was on top of the event and assisted with the cake and decorations. The staff went above and beyond my expectations. Food was delicious and everyone had a great time. Highly recommend.
J A.
My recent visit to Argyle Grill was disappointing. Despite hearing great things and arriving at 3 pm the restaurant was empty, creating an awkward atmosphere. The staff, though polite, insisted on reservations, which felt unnecessary and more about exclusivity than demand. I won't be returning and can't recommend it based on my visit.
Robert M
Good local food and drink.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sliced Sirloin Steak
Kimberly A.
Not sure why this place is rated as low as it is. Came here for a ladies night with my aunt and cousin. We came on a Saturday night around 8:30pm and we were told it was a 20-25min wait. Hostess was extremely sweet and greeted us with a smile. The wait was not a problem for us, we grabbed a drink at the bar. Prices were very reasonable, and the wine was a generous pour. The bartender, Joe was outstanding! Personable, funny, and even gave my aunt napkins when she started sneezing out of nowhere... I would come back just to sit at the bar when he was there! I loved the ambiance of the restaurant. Music was on, but not too loud, and I am never bothered by noise created by people having a good night. They also had 2 TVs, each showing the NY hockey games (one had the Rangers, one had the islanders). The food all around was FANTASTIC. The clam chowder bowl was the appetizer! I thought it would have been a cup! The Portobello stack was AMAZING. Even my aunt who doesn't like portobello enjoyed her bite she took. My aunt and cousin both enjoyed their entrees as well - very generous portions. Our server, Annabella was superb. Attentive, made good suggestions, and very friendly. I will definitely return the next time I come to visit my family! Edited: We went to go bar hopping and we weren't impressed, so we came back to see Joe, and he was so excited to see us back! We were served by both him and Arthur, who was equally amazing, personable, and because the crowd had settled a bit, was able to chat a bit. Absolutely a place I will return to!
Pablo E.
This is not our first visit to Argyle. We stopped in on a Monday night and were promptly seated. We ordered the Monday $10 burger and a quesadilla. Our food was very tasty and came with a wonderful presentation. The food tasted very good and was of proper temperature Etc. The desert selection is very nice also. We chose the red velvet cake which was delicious. So all in all the food is a five star worthy visit. Where it all falls to SxxT is Margo the waitress. I might have to call the board of labor and have them investigate whether she is suffering forced labor. She was the most cold, impersonal waitress possible. No introduction, no interaction, just the facts. Maybe her entire family abandoned her recently and she is devastated but she is not my candidate for waitress of the year. In 2023 I guess some people do not value a personal touch and some friendly interaction. Hey, maybe even a smile? For this she was tipped appropriately. If we go back hopefully Margo will have found a career more fitting her personality, or lack thereof.
Great food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
On a busy Saturday, the crew at Argyle was most accommodating to a large group of us, including an elderly patron. Great food, pleasant, professional service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Saw an employee use the bathroom and not wash his hands afterwards. Not coming back.
My husband and I came here for his birthday dinner. The hostess was so friendly and pleasant. Something we unfortunately have not experienced lately and it is definitely an important detail that plays a part in setting the tone for a dining experience. When we were seated, the waiter was prompt with introducing himself and getting drink orders. Throughout the night, he was attentive, prompt and so sweet. I had a Watermelon martini. There's was a little issue with the drink but very happy to say it was taken care of immediately. We had the calamari, Brie stuffed pretzel, skirt steak and stuff salmon. Everything was delicious. The one issue that I did have was that when we went to pay the bill with my Citibank card, the waiter returned and said that there is an issue with their machine so they can't take the card. When I questioned this, he said this has been happening for a few years where their machine doesn't process the Citibank cards. I was surprised to hear this because if it has been an issue that can't be resolved, something should be posted and patrons should be notified. I have worked in the restaurant business and have never heard of an issue like this lasting for years without it being resolved. My thought was though, what about patrons that all they have are citibank cards to pay without the option of getting cash. They would have dined and would be unable to pay? Overall we had a nice dining experience and will visit again but I hope the Citi issue can be resolved or posted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Calamari
Very impressed with the food and service here. Extremely friendly and helpful staff and the food was very good. They had a prix fix menu - $35 for a salad, main course, and a dessert and all of it was delicious. Would definitely go back!!
Nice place but loud. Food was very good. Easy parking in rear lot.Parking: Free lot in back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved it. Along with really good food and really nice staff, there's some terrific photography in the back section.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes, Sliced Sirloin Steak, Sesame Seared Tuna, Babylon Clam Chowder, Coconut Crusted Shrimp
The service was awesome and the drinks were strong. Highly recommend the stuffed clams
Growing up in Babylon the Argyle's a staple. Always a great bar crowd with the best cocktails. Their food is also amazing. We went for lunch today and started with the king pow shrimp and calamari over soba noodles. Always delicious. We also got the goat cheese salads with skirt steak on top. Very yummy. Their watermelon martinis are a must try! Everything was good but the service was not it today. Our dude Matt must have went on a long break or just went home cause 35 minutes he never came back lol I got up looking for him and a female server came over to help us. She refilled our drinks and then brought us the check. Just really weird to leave in the middle of having a table without saying a word.
Will go back. Love it. My firest time going there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sliced Sirloin Steak
Restaurantji Recommends
Hosted a birthday brunch for our Mom. The manager Carissa was extremely accommodating and professionally. She was on top of the event and assisted with the cake and decorations. The staff went above and beyond my expectations. Food was delicious and everyone had a great time. Highly recommend.
My recent visit to Argyle Grill was disappointing. Despite hearing great things and arriving at 3 pm the restaurant was empty, creating an awkward atmosphere. The staff, though polite, insisted on reservations, which felt unnecessary and more about exclusivity than demand. I won't be returning and can't recommend it based on my visit.
Good local food and drink.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sliced Sirloin Steak
Not sure why this place is rated as low as it is. Came here for a ladies night with my aunt and cousin. We came on a Saturday night around 8:30pm and we were told it was a 20-25min wait. Hostess was extremely sweet and greeted us with a smile. The wait was not a problem for us, we grabbed a drink at the bar. Prices were very reasonable, and the wine was a generous pour. The bartender, Joe was outstanding! Personable, funny, and even gave my aunt napkins when she started sneezing out of nowhere... I would come back just to sit at the bar when he was there! I loved the ambiance of the restaurant. Music was on, but not too loud, and I am never bothered by noise created by people having a good night. They also had 2 TVs, each showing the NY hockey games (one had the Rangers, one had the islanders). The food all around was FANTASTIC. The clam chowder bowl was the appetizer! I thought it would have been a cup! The Portobello stack was AMAZING. Even my aunt who doesn't like portobello enjoyed her bite she took. My aunt and cousin both enjoyed their entrees as well - very generous portions. Our server, Annabella was superb. Attentive, made good suggestions, and very friendly. I will definitely return the next time I come to visit my family! Edited: We went to go bar hopping and we weren't impressed, so we came back to see Joe, and he was so excited to see us back! We were served by both him and Arthur, who was equally amazing, personable, and because the crowd had settled a bit, was able to chat a bit. Absolutely a place I will return to!
This is not our first visit to Argyle. We stopped in on a Monday night and were promptly seated. We ordered the Monday $10 burger and a quesadilla. Our food was very tasty and came with a wonderful presentation. The food tasted very good and was of proper temperature Etc. The desert selection is very nice also. We chose the red velvet cake which was delicious. So all in all the food is a five star worthy visit. Where it all falls to SxxT is Margo the waitress. I might have to call the board of labor and have them investigate whether she is suffering forced labor. She was the most cold, impersonal waitress possible. No introduction, no interaction, just the facts. Maybe her entire family abandoned her recently and she is devastated but she is not my candidate for waitress of the year. In 2023 I guess some people do not value a personal touch and some friendly interaction. Hey, maybe even a smile? For this she was tipped appropriately. If we go back hopefully Margo will have found a career more fitting her personality, or lack thereof.