Cold Stone Creamery

255 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon
(631) 539-7570

Recent Reviews

Grim OX

Cold Stone. Absolutely classic. The ice cream itself is much better than a lot of places out here. Lotta different options in terms of toppings and pre made creations. Cones are good too. Was worried this place would be overrated, definitely not the case.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Fermin

Employees look sooo unhappy

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Solow Sports

Fast service and quality staff. Birthday cake remix all day would be my suggestion!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake Batter Confetti - Ready Now

Chris Castellano

Great ice cream. Service was quick.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarbelia B

Been a customer for over a decade. Their ice cream cakes are great and they always do a great job personalizing cakes.Kid-friendliness: Kids love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Devotion, Milk & Oreo Cookies, Mix and Go Create Your Own Creation

Ny Elliott

I went in to purchase a small cake for my 5yr daughter Birthday today and the staff this evening wasn't so welcoming. No one asked me if I needed assistance or acknowledge my presence. I picked a cake went to the register and was asked at that time if I'll like writing? I said sure please put Happy Birthday Bria. She walked away and returned to check me out. Still no acknowledgment, I paid with a card and she walked away from the register before it went through. I ripped my own receipt off the machine she went to the back to finish her bottle of water. FYI, the store wasnt busy at this time I was the only customer in there at 5:15-5:20pm. However the cakes are amazing not so much the service.

Kevin Naldrett

Cold Stone was great clearly a different style ice cream.Just like everything else prices not so great.You get what you pay for

Gianna dazzo

Katerina is such a pleasure. She leaves me satisfied every single time. She always makes my icecream with love !!! She’s a keeper.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lizmarie Cortes

THE SMELL! I went to pick up a cake and as soon as I walked in I smelled strong bleach/cleaning products. Ok A+ on cleanliness but guess what also smelled like bleach? The bag the cake was in and the cake itself. It must have permeated through the plastic casing. I was so embarrassed when everyone started to point this out while eating the cake. $40 cake- inedible. I think management needs to look at how much cleaning products they’re using and when they’re using them. Won’t be going back unfortunately.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Anthony

Bought a $40 cake and candles online. When we went to pick it up around 1pn 12/23 we didn't like the candles, we wanted something different but the older Spanish lady said no refunds for the candles. I explained we didn't even pick it up yet and it's just candles in a box and still in her possession lol. Either way she refused so we took them. It was only $3, so don't understand why make a fuss about it and I wasn't busy either.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Robert Mickens

Great icecream ? ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mix and Go Create Your Own Creation

I Never Was

So disappointing to report after two decades, this location has started to add water into their ice cream. Had ice crystals in every batch we bought. To make it worse, mix ins were so mininal that we had to pay extra to get to the level it was even until last year. This location was a staple around town for so long. So sad.My original review for this place was over 7 years old too! Had to update it to write the above.

Ricky Yunas

The older Spanish lady with the glasses will ignore you until you say something to her they all have an attitude in there they make people wait and they act like they’re busy but the older Spanish lady with the glasses but black hair has an attitude and she think she’s better than everyone working at the ice cream store lol at like 30 years old

Recommended dishes: Oreo

Catherine Serra

Love the ice cream better the Kilwins cause they are to over priced . Cold stone has it on ball with everything.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: OH Fudge, Gelato, Chocolate Devotion, Banana Caramel Crunch, Cheesecake Fantasy, Cake Batter Confetti - Ready Now, Mango Pineapple Smoothie, Birthday Cake Remix, Cold Stone Creamery Creation in Hand, Pineapple Blueberry Smoothie, Mix and Go Create Your Own Creation, Don't Cry over Spilled Silk, Tall Dark & Delicious, Cookie Dough Delirium - Ready Now, Cookie Dough Pie, Strawberry Banana Rendezvous, The Way the Cookie Crumbles, Oreo

Michael sparacino

GREAT PLANT BASED ICE CREAM BUT WOW TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. We called the next day to let them know that there was a mistake on our Uber Eat ice cream . We paid $4 for toppings that were not added !!! Instead of apologizing the only thing the girl on phone wanted to know was why we didn’t call the night of. I explained It was late and after Uber eats said they couldn’t help us the store was closed. I then as a business owner hung up because she was dismissive and nasty. We will now take our business elsewhere.

Load More