A bit of a disappointment. Chicken Marsala was two very thin small pieces of chicken breast, a potato crocket and spinach for almost $30 A tiny loaf of bread for five people. Rice ball appetizer was small balls the size of a quarter covered in way too much mozzarella.and some bacon. Don’t think I ever found the rice ball in there. I felt like they skimped on everything. Overpriced for the portions for sure! Will not be going back Below is a photo of the chicken masala and the rice ball appetizer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Asaf Bochman
First, the service was outstanding! We weren’t waiting long for anything and the staff was warm and personable.
Having said that, the food is still outrageously overpriced. $35+ for mains that have little to no flavor.
If management is reading, maybe a little bit more time spent on flavor and a little less time spent on making sure the Ferrari is sitting out front.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Sarah Johnson
Last night I had the pleasure of dining here, and it was truly unforgettable. The food was some of the best I’ve ever had, and the entire experience exceeded my expectations. From the welcoming staff to the incredible atmosphere, everything was perfect. If you’re in the Long Island area, I highly recommend making a stop here—you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alan Zysberg
First time here. Nice restaurant. Food was good. Service was excellent. Free parking lot. Would go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
John Gatto
Great food and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
KingChocolate 62
Great place! The atmosphere is so pretty as it really felt like an Italian restaurant that would be in Italy itself. I was satisfied with the service as my server was friendly and accommodating. The food was all delicious yet it took awhile, but as they say good things come to those who wait. I’m glad that I came across this place as it’s worth trying when seeking a hardy Italian meal!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donna D
Hosted a dinner event for 22 people tonight at Gemelli. George the owner set us up with a big long table next to the fireplace. The Christmas decor was still up and lended itself to the festive nature of our gathering. The food was very good. We had a special 3 course menu set and everything was delicious ! The service was great, we had 3 servers tend to our table and frankly they anticipated every move , from keeping water glasses filled to clearing dishes. They were good team. Coffee and cookies and pastries rounded out the night ! A very good time was had by all ! Thank you to George for helping us celebrate tonight ! So glad I chose Gemelli to host us !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Dee
Very Good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathy Murphy
The place has totally changed, would never recommend this restaurant. The food portions were very small.One of the dishes the pasta was all stuck together basically not edible. We ordered drinks.. Gin & tonics, jack & soda When we received the bill we noticed we were charged extra for the tonic & extra for the soda. How do you charge $22 for a mixed drink then charge more for tonic water & soda in a full price mixed drink. They claim that’s how they do it. We will never go here again. What a rip off.
noa kahana
Just don't go there!!!!! I used to come here years ago and it was great, but something happened along the way and this place is horrible! The food was salty and honestly disgusting, we sent it back to the kitchen without eating it. The server was talking up a different restaurant she works at🤔 and then charged us full price for our uneaten meals with no discount or anything. Atmosphere? What atmosphere? We were the only people in there, which should have been the first red flag...
Terrible terrible terrible!! Had veal saltimbocca that was essentially inedible. Meatball appetizer was ok. When I told the waitress the meal was "terrible" she asked if we wanted something to take home and we declined. Waitress was very nice and accommodating but the check arrived with zero discounts noted on the check. I should have turned and walked out as soon as I walked in when I saw that we were the only people in the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Lori Franko
We stopped by Gemelli Ristorante last evening after a family funeral, to enjoy a meal together before the five of us parted ways to head home to PA and MD. So glad we did! After an emotional couple of days we all appreciated the warmth of the staff at Gemelli’s as well as the amazing food and ambiance of this fantastic restaurant!! We were greeted at the door by a lovely lady who seated us in their beautiful outdoor garden area. And the food - ?. Everything was excellent, from the bread with olives and garlic to the wine, entrees and dessert. Their meatballs are fantastic!! Everybody enjoyed their meals, from pasta to pizza. I’ve had some really great Italian food in my 60 years and the food at Gemelli’s did not disappoint. Last but not least, I have to say our server Kim was THE BEST ?. She put up with some of our bad jokes and even shared a few of her own (hers were better ?). Her sense of humor and personality are terrific - just what we all needed to lift our spirits after the funeral. If you are ever in Babylon NY I encourage you to visit Gemelli’s. I believe you will be very happy you did. Enjoy ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
leonard m
After spending an enjoyable Sunday afternoon at the Argyle Theater, we decided to try Restaurante Gemilli and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, Gusippe our server was friendly and attentive, the restaurant is immaculately maintained. We started with the hot antipasto, for the entrees we had fresh ravioli in a light tomato sauce and linguine with shimp, clams, calamari and mussels. We finished with a fresh made pastry topped with apple and carmel sauce and a large scoop of vanilla ice cream, and a couple of Cappuccino's. The restaurant has a large parking lot so there is no worry about parking or having to walk any great distance. This restaurant definitely exceeded our expectations.
A bit of a disappointment.
Chicken Marsala was two very thin small pieces of chicken breast, a potato crocket and spinach for almost $30
A tiny loaf of bread for five people.
Rice ball appetizer was small balls the size of a quarter covered in way too much mozzarella.and some bacon. Don’t think I ever found the rice ball in there.
I felt like they skimped on everything.
Overpriced for the portions for sure!
Will not be going back
Below is a photo of the chicken masala and the rice ball appetizer
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
First, the service was outstanding! We weren’t waiting long for anything and the staff was warm and personable.
Having said that, the food is still outrageously overpriced. $35+ for mains that have little to no flavor.
If management is reading, maybe a little bit more time spent on flavor and a little less time spent on making sure the Ferrari is sitting out front.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Last night I had the pleasure of dining here, and it was truly unforgettable. The food was some of the best I’ve ever had, and the entire experience exceeded my expectations. From the welcoming staff to the incredible atmosphere, everything was perfect. If you’re in the Long Island area, I highly recommend making a stop here—you won’t be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here. Nice restaurant. Food was good. Service was excellent. Free parking lot. Would go back
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place! The atmosphere is so pretty as it really felt like an Italian restaurant that would be in Italy itself. I was satisfied with the service as my server was friendly and accommodating. The food was all delicious yet it took awhile, but as they say good things come to those who wait. I’m glad that I came across this place as it’s worth trying when seeking a hardy Italian meal!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hosted a dinner event for 22 people tonight at Gemelli. George the owner set us up with a big long table next to the fireplace. The Christmas decor was still up and lended itself to the festive nature of our gathering.
The food was very good. We had a special 3 course menu set and everything was delicious ! The service was great, we had 3 servers tend to our table and frankly they anticipated every move , from keeping water glasses filled to clearing dishes. They were good team. Coffee and cookies and pastries rounded out the night ! A very good time was had by all !
Thank you to George for helping us celebrate tonight ! So glad I chose Gemelli to host us !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very Good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place has totally changed, would never recommend this restaurant. The food portions were very small.One of the dishes the pasta was all stuck together basically not edible.
We ordered drinks.. Gin & tonics, jack & soda
When we received the bill we noticed we were charged extra for the tonic & extra for the soda. How do you charge $22 for a mixed drink then charge more for tonic water & soda in a full price mixed drink.
They claim that’s how they do it.
We will never go here again. What a rip off.
Just don't go there!!!!!
I used to come here years ago and it was great, but something happened along the way and this place is horrible! The food was salty and honestly disgusting, we sent it back to the kitchen without eating it. The server was talking up a different restaurant she works at🤔 and then charged us full price for our uneaten meals with no discount or anything.
Atmosphere? What atmosphere? We were the only people in there, which should have been the first red flag...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food and service
Terrible terrible terrible!! Had veal saltimbocca that was essentially inedible. Meatball appetizer was ok. When I told the waitress the meal was "terrible" she asked if we wanted something to take home and we declined. Waitress was very nice and accommodating but the check arrived with zero discounts noted on the check. I should have turned and walked out as soon as I walked in when I saw that we were the only people in the restaurant.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
We stopped by Gemelli Ristorante last evening after a family funeral, to enjoy a meal together before the five of us parted ways to head home to PA and MD. So glad we did! After an emotional couple of days we all appreciated the warmth of the staff at Gemelli’s as well as the amazing food and ambiance of this fantastic restaurant!! We were greeted at the door by a lovely lady who seated us in their beautiful outdoor garden area. And the food - ?. Everything was excellent, from the bread with olives and garlic to the wine, entrees and dessert. Their meatballs are fantastic!! Everybody enjoyed their meals, from pasta to pizza. I’ve had some really great Italian food in my 60 years and the food at Gemelli’s did not disappoint. Last but not least, I have to say our server Kim was THE BEST ?. She put up with some of our bad jokes and even shared a few of her own (hers were better ?). Her sense of humor and personality are terrific - just what we all needed to lift our spirits after the funeral. If you are ever in Babylon NY I encourage you to visit Gemelli’s. I believe you will be very happy you did. Enjoy ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After spending an enjoyable Sunday afternoon at the Argyle Theater, we decided to try Restaurante Gemilli and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious, the service was excellent, Gusippe our server was friendly and attentive, the restaurant is immaculately maintained. We started with the hot antipasto, for the entrees we had fresh ravioli in a light tomato sauce and linguine with shimp, clams, calamari and mussels. We finished with a fresh made pastry topped with apple and carmel sauce and a large scoop of vanilla ice cream, and a couple of Cappuccino's. The restaurant has a large parking lot so there is no worry about parking or having to walk any great distance. This restaurant definitely exceeded our expectations.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bring an empty stomach!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...