The best pizza in Babylon! They use high-quality, organic ingredients. Aldo and his family truly deserve ten stars for their care, love, and kindness. I love the pizza and the family!
A A
Bella Pazza makes a great pizza consistently. A nice, family run establishment.
We’ve been impressed with the pizza every visit this summer. He makes a great pie that has brought us back time and again. This time we got the garlic knot pie that I’ve been eyeing since I saw it on the menu. I didn’t have enough patience to photograph before digging in, but I posted a photo of what was left over. This was an awesome creation.
Not every pizzeria in the area makes good food. They know how to make good food here. The dough is the right thinness, the sauce is great, and they get the crust-sauce-cheese ratio correct. If the website is true in that they don’t use brominated flour, that’s the “icing on the cake.” I’ve been eating pizza in the Babylon/West Islip/Bay Shore area for 30 years and now when my family wants pizza takeout, we have to get it from Bella Pazza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria M
Stumbled onto this place completely by accident. My daughter and I ordered 1 garlic knot slice each. Owner was supper nice and friendly. The place was clean and cute and the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely will recommend and come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alyssa Gervasi
Great pizza, great pasta, great staff. Aldo is amazing helpful and an exquisite pizza cheff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon D'Onofrio
Was just here for a late afternoon lunch with my mom. Pizza was delicious no doubt about that. However, the customer service from the guy behind the counter could’ve been a little bit better. Also, the sprite and dr. pepper did not dispense correctly and came out as water from the machine and no ice at all btw. That’s why I’m giving this 3 stars and not 4 or 5, like I really wanted to. Oh and the guy charged me $1.00 extra for the meatball topping after I paid when I had clearly asked for meatball before while I was ordering and didn’t even look to say, “Thank you for coming, or have a great rest of your day!” as we were leaving. It’s the little things like manners that can really make a difference. Just somethings to think about.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Grandma
Richard B
Pizza is low mid and overpriced. Ate there once, I wasn’t even asked if i wanted to stay or to go, the owner wrapped to go “as if I wasn’t welcomed eating there”. I got back the following day to see if the attitude changed, store was empty as usual but the owner and the other fella working there didn’t want to serve me. I wouldn’t suggest going here. Being nice is free, and you never know the demons a person is fighting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Vin M
Such a step up from the previous pizzeria Gino’s. Owner is a gentleman and the pizza is great. Make sure to get the upside down slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Troy G
Love this pet sore
Mooch King
Great food and owned by a great family man. Love this place. The everything seasoned pinwheels are delicious, a must try. And the pizza and pasta ? I’m here at least once a week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan
Robin Maida
FANTASTIC! This was the best pizza I’ve had in Babylon and I’ve lived here wince 2002. The owners were friendly and considerate making sure to cook the pizza how I wanted it to be. I look forward to going back trying more food!
Dietary restrictions: They had gluten-free and vegetarian options on the menu.
Parking: We went after 6p so parking was free, but the restaurant is right by the train station so if it’s during the day, there’s paid street parking:
Great Pizza, and hero’s only Italian Restaurant I go too.!!!!!!!
Kristopher Lindsey (Kris)
Can not say enough great things about Bella Pazza. Pizza is fantastic, service is quick, atmosphere is top notch. Enough seating to sit down and eat however service is quick so if you just want a to get a slice and run you can. However what's most impressing is there menu they offer so much more than just pizza or specialty pizzas. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Audrey Ann
The family running this place are really great. Nice people and the guys who work there are just as nice. Friendly atmosphere. I usually go in alone. I was there a few days ago to grab some food to take home and ended up staying over an hour just shooting the breeze.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Schein Parents
After our stroll by Argyle lake, we ventured to the place. I had read a review when it first opened. We finally made a point to go. We observed that Pizza slices are popular items, but we tried some entrees. Garlic knots were a starter. Then he ordered Chicken parm and rototini pasta, while I has the Chicken Sorrentino with salad. Each entrees was accompanied by Italian bread. I loved the Chicken Sorrentino and have been missing that flavor profile for many years. Needless to say, the portions were generous. And now I have leftovers! We will be visiting again!
Vegetarian options: Cauliflower crusted Pizza, with vegetable toppings... not vegan.
Wheelchair accessibility: Roll straight in from sidewalk.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Chicken Parmesan
Renee Frye
This place has good pizza! We've been here before and loved it! We've been to many pizzareias on Long Island and this one ranks one of our top favorites!
Check out the pizza with the garlic knot crust! Their regular pizza is a little thinner.
The best pizza in Babylon! They use high-quality, organic ingredients. Aldo and his family truly deserve ten stars for their care, love, and kindness. I love the pizza and the family!
Bella Pazza makes a great pizza consistently.
A nice, family run establishment.
We’ve been impressed with the pizza every visit this summer. He makes a great pie that has brought us back time and again. This time we got the garlic knot pie that I’ve been eyeing since I saw it on the menu. I didn’t have enough patience to photograph before digging in, but I posted a photo of what was left over. This was an awesome creation.
Not every pizzeria in the area makes good food. They know how to make good food here. The dough is the right thinness, the sauce is great, and they get the crust-sauce-cheese ratio correct. If the website is true in that they don’t use brominated flour, that’s the “icing on the cake.” I’ve been eating pizza in the Babylon/West Islip/Bay Shore area for 30 years and now when my family wants pizza takeout, we have to get it from Bella Pazza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stumbled onto this place completely by accident. My daughter and I ordered 1 garlic knot slice each. Owner was supper nice and friendly. The place was clean and cute and the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely will recommend and come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, great pasta, great staff. Aldo is amazing helpful and an exquisite pizza cheff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was just here for a late afternoon lunch with my mom. Pizza was delicious no doubt about that. However, the customer service from the guy behind the counter could’ve been a little bit better. Also, the sprite and dr. pepper did not dispense correctly and came out as water from the machine and no ice at all btw. That’s why I’m giving this 3 stars and not 4 or 5, like I really wanted to. Oh and the guy charged me $1.00 extra for the meatball topping after I paid when I had clearly asked for meatball before while I was ordering and didn’t even look to say, “Thank you for coming, or have a great rest of your day!” as we were leaving. It’s the little things like manners that can really make a difference. Just somethings to think about.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Grandma
Pizza is low mid and overpriced. Ate there once, I wasn’t even asked if i wanted to stay or to go, the owner wrapped to go “as if I wasn’t welcomed eating there”.
I got back the following day to see if the attitude changed, store was empty as usual but the owner and the other fella working there didn’t want to serve me. I wouldn’t suggest going here.
Being nice is free, and you never know the demons a person is fighting.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Such a step up from the previous pizzeria Gino’s. Owner is a gentleman and the pizza is great. Make sure to get the upside down slice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this pet sore
Great food and owned by a great family man. Love this place. The everything seasoned pinwheels are delicious, a must try. And the pizza and pasta ? I’m here at least once a week.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan
FANTASTIC! This was the best pizza I’ve had in Babylon and I’ve lived here wince 2002. The owners were friendly and considerate making sure to cook the pizza how I wanted it to be. I look forward to going back trying more food!
Dietary restrictions: They had gluten-free and vegetarian options on the menu.
Parking: We went after 6p so parking was free, but the restaurant is right by the train station so if it’s during the day, there’s paid street parking:
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Pizza, and hero’s only Italian Restaurant I go too.!!!!!!!
Can not say enough great things about Bella Pazza. Pizza is fantastic, service is quick, atmosphere is top notch. Enough seating to sit down and eat however service is quick so if you just want a to get a slice and run you can. However what's most impressing is there menu they offer so much more than just pizza or specialty pizzas. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The family running this place are really great. Nice people and the guys who work there are just as nice. Friendly atmosphere. I usually go in alone. I was there a few days ago to grab some food to take home and ended up staying over an hour just shooting the breeze.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After our stroll by Argyle lake, we ventured to the place. I had read a review when it first opened. We finally made a point to go. We observed that Pizza slices are popular items, but we tried some entrees. Garlic knots were a starter. Then he ordered Chicken parm and rototini pasta, while I has the Chicken Sorrentino with salad. Each entrees was accompanied by Italian bread. I loved the Chicken Sorrentino and have been missing that flavor profile for many years.
Needless to say, the portions were generous. And now I have leftovers! We will be visiting again!
Vegetarian options: Cauliflower crusted Pizza, with vegetable toppings... not vegan.
Wheelchair accessibility: Roll straight in from sidewalk.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Chicken Parmesan
This place has good pizza! We've been here before and loved it! We've been to many pizzareias on Long Island and this one ranks one of our top favorites!
Check out the pizza with the garlic knot crust! Their regular pizza is a little thinner.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...