I came here quickly for a lunch break and the food was fresh and came quickly. Tasted great and the staff were so friendly and helpful. I loved the cozy feel inside the restaurant too. I wish I lived closer so I can come more often. Thanks again!
Lori G.
Greek salad is weak. Disapponted to say the least. The lunch special was described as dinner salad ( greek) and cup soup. Salad was a side salad with mainly lettuce- 1 small tomato slice, 1 olive and piece of cucumber. The feta was microscopic sprinkle. Still hungry- waste of $15. and gas to get there.
Gina S.
Amazing food and service!! Great atmosphere! Highly recommended Owners are delightful
Alexa Wyllie
Above and beyond service and food!
Nina Z.
Very nice owners, good food. I got the falafel and rice and it was very good. The salad was one of the best greek salads I've had. Again the people were so friendly and welcoming, would definitely recommend.
Joanna Borriello
The food we had was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger Deluxe, Chicken and Broccoli, Soup
Frangelico T.
It was ok. Not bad, but certainly not a place I'd want to go back to. The hospitality was wonderful, but the food was subpar. My friend's gyro was kind of bad. The sauce was too bitter. My gyro was ok, but nothing special.
Gary Gisonda
Good food at reasonable prices. It has been around a long time in Babylon and always delivers a tasty greek meal.
Greek garden is my absolute favorite! Whether we are dining in or getting food catered it truly never disappoints. It’s my go to place whenever I am hosting company and want a meal to have everyone leaving full and happy. Rose is the kindest person and always so helpful when ordering. We will be customers for life, Thank you so much! - Meg and Kyle
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Malzone
Just absolutely love the food! Great Service, mostly get takeout, but great ambience in the
The Greek Garden is a great local place! We took out a meal this first time to this place, but will really want to eat in the next time. It looks clean and has a very welcoming atmosphere. The gyro is full of flavor, packed solid and equal to or above the best out there! The chicken souvlaki stuffed full with chicken chunks lettuce and tomato. Both so delish! The falafel and spanokopita are very authentic too and a must try...
First time with my husband. We were actually on our way to Argyle and passed Greek Garden and I thought it looked so adorable and was in the mood to try something new / something more with that homey, niche feel. It is just that, it's so cute inside & the people are so sweet. The service was also super fast, and the food was soo delicious!! We have lived in West Islip for so long and never heard about this place before. So happy to have found it.
Joe P
Very welcoming restaurant & staff. We stumbled upon this gem after making a wrong turn getting through Babylon. Hands down one of the best Greek places I've been to. We've been very satisfied with any meal we've had there so far.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad and Spanakopita, Greek Salads, Gyro Meat
Unfortunately the food has not been great lately. We had weird chicken a few times in a row.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Fantastic Greek food. Nothing compares to it. Friendly welcoming staff. If you don't go you are missing out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad and Spanakopita, Gyro Sandwich, Greek Chicken, Spinach Pie, Salad, Yogurt Sauce
I came here quickly for a lunch break and the food was fresh and came quickly. Tasted great and the staff were so friendly and helpful. I loved the cozy feel inside the restaurant too. I wish I lived closer so I can come more often. Thanks again!
Greek salad is weak. Disapponted to say the least. The lunch special was described as dinner salad ( greek) and cup soup. Salad was a side salad with mainly lettuce- 1 small tomato slice, 1 olive and piece of cucumber. The feta was microscopic sprinkle. Still hungry- waste of $15. and gas to get there.
Amazing food and service!! Great atmosphere! Highly recommended Owners are delightful
Above and beyond service and food!
Very nice owners, good food. I got the falafel and rice and it was very good. The salad was one of the best greek salads I've had. Again the people were so friendly and welcoming, would definitely recommend.
The food we had was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger Deluxe, Chicken and Broccoli, Soup
It was ok. Not bad, but certainly not a place I'd want to go back to. The hospitality was wonderful, but the food was subpar. My friend's gyro was kind of bad. The sauce was too bitter. My gyro was ok, but nothing special.
Good food at reasonable prices. It has been around a long time in Babylon and always delivers a tasty greek meal.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Gyro Meat, Chicken Souvlaki
Restaurantji Recommends
Greek garden is my absolute favorite! Whether we are dining in or getting food catered it truly never disappoints. It’s my go to place whenever I am hosting company and want a meal to have everyone leaving full and happy. Rose is the kindest person and always so helpful when ordering. We will be customers for life, Thank you so much! - Meg and Kyle
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just absolutely love the food! Great Service, mostly get takeout, but great ambience in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baklava, Gyro Sandwich, Yogurt Sauce, Greek Salads, Greek Chicken, Falafel, Gyro Meat, Chicken Souvlaki
The Greek Garden is a great local place! We took out a meal this first time to this place, but will really want to eat in the next time. It looks clean and has a very welcoming atmosphere. The gyro is full of flavor, packed solid and equal to or above the best out there! The chicken souvlaki stuffed full with chicken chunks lettuce and tomato. Both so delish! The falafel and spanokopita are very authentic too and a must try...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad and Spanakopita, Gyro Sandwich, Yogurt Sauce, Spinach Pie, Gyro Meat
First time with my husband. We were actually on our way to Argyle and passed Greek Garden and I thought it looked so adorable and was in the mood to try something new / something more with that homey, niche feel. It is just that, it's so cute inside & the people are so sweet. The service was also super fast, and the food was soo delicious!! We have lived in West Islip for so long and never heard about this place before. So happy to have found it.
Very welcoming restaurant & staff. We stumbled upon this gem after making a wrong turn getting through Babylon. Hands down one of the best Greek places I've been to. We've been very satisfied with any meal we've had there so far.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad and Spanakopita, Greek Salads, Gyro Meat