Service was exceptional. Great and friendly staff. That makes a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Koija
They let in underage ppl but when me and my friend came on st Patrick’s day we had our real ny ids declined by one of the bouncers. This guy tried to size us up and down and looked at our ids with no flashlight or verification, then says we can’t get in with these and asks us for a second form of id (a credit card in particular) which wouldn’t prove anything besides the name on the id, very unprofessional won’t ever see me here again
Service: 1
Doreen Lobasso
Just had a birthday dinner for my mom's 80th and can't say enough good things about my experience. Such great customer service with Damien (Manager)and Chris the chef. Chris went above and beyond to provide a great menu and setting for the evening. Nicole the catering manager was great to work with. A Big shout out to Will, who was our go to for everything that night (bartender, server etc)! He really had his hands full and did everything with a smile and no problem attitude. Everyone enjoyed their food and praised the staff. My Mom was so surprised and loved how casual and friendly everyone was. Thank you again to Everyone at Lily's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Vicari
Meant to write this a while back. Security almost didnt let me in because i was wearing casual clothing and not dress down to a bar night. I understand some places implement dress codes and recommendations but being a restaurant and bar at night in babylon of all places that’s kinda stupid. After being told I cannot enter i told my friends to go in and i’d uber home. Security then proceeds to let me “slide” only because i handled it well and didn’t throw the tantrum they were looking for. This all roots from security needing an excuse to assault customers. Nobody wants to get in THAT bad.
Dorothy
Delicious food ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Skirt Steak
Mike R.
Time for a new Irish flag. The orange has faded to yellow. A good idea to put up a new flag on March 1st for Irish American heritage month and St Patrick's Day. Thank you
Joe Innace
Food was above average, not great, but the staff/service is terrific.Place is a bit noisy if you plan on having a conversation.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Frank Cox
Went to the Sunday Comedy Brunch. 100% will I recommend this event to all. The food was delicious, the comedians were great, and if you stick with the brunch cocktails (unlimited) it's $135 per couple which includes tax and tip. The event is 3 hours so it left us time to go downstairs and enjoy a few pints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Butera
Great place all around. Now they have Comedy Brunch!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mai Vio
This was our first visit to Lily's and although the food was excellent our service was not. She seemed friendly enough with other tables but when she came to our table she barely looked at us, reached across my face to pick up dishes while taking to table next to us. I think she even sighed when we asked for dessert to go. Unfortunately we had to reflect this in our tip. We frequent the restaurants in this area a lot and we love tipping generously to show our appreciation of good friendly service. Not sure if we'll be back here. Maybe only if we get a different server.
A very nice Irish man pub in every way. Good Guinness too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Costelloe
Sat at bar for 3hrs.Dropped $160.00 between my wife and I on a tab.Not one bye back. Apologies to the staff for not tipping appropriately but bar policy sucks.
Service: 5
Michael C.
Was at venue 01/27 for a great Irish band. Sat at the bar, great service from the staff. $160.00 later no/not one buyback. Apologies to the staff for no tip but not having it... I
Linda Dee
Attended private party on 1/20/24! the food was outstanding as was the service.
Service was exceptional. Great and friendly staff. That makes a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They let in underage ppl but when me and my friend came on st Patrick’s day we had our real ny ids declined by one of the bouncers. This guy tried to size us up and down and looked at our ids with no flashlight or verification, then says we can’t get in with these and asks us for a second form of id (a credit card in particular) which wouldn’t prove anything besides the name on the id, very unprofessional won’t ever see me here again
Service: 1
Just had a birthday dinner for my mom's 80th and can't say enough good things about my experience. Such great customer service with Damien (Manager)and Chris the chef. Chris went above and beyond to provide a great menu and setting for the evening. Nicole the catering manager was great to work with. A Big shout out to Will, who was our go to for everything that night (bartender, server etc)! He really had his hands full and did everything with a smile and no problem attitude. Everyone enjoyed their food and praised the staff. My Mom was so surprised and loved how casual and friendly everyone was. Thank you again to Everyone at Lily's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Meant to write this a while back. Security almost didnt let me in because i was wearing casual clothing and not dress down to a bar night. I understand some places implement dress codes and recommendations but being a restaurant and bar at night in babylon of all places that’s kinda stupid. After being told I cannot enter i told my friends to go in and i’d uber home. Security then proceeds to let me “slide” only because i handled it well and didn’t throw the tantrum they were looking for. This all roots from security needing an excuse to assault customers. Nobody wants to get in THAT bad.
Delicious food ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Skirt Steak
Time for a new Irish flag. The orange has faded to yellow. A good idea to put up a new flag on March 1st for Irish American heritage month and St Patrick's Day. Thank you
Food was above average, not great, but the staff/service is terrific.Place is a bit noisy if you plan on having a conversation.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Went to the Sunday Comedy Brunch. 100% will I recommend this event to all. The food was delicious, the comedians were great, and if you stick with the brunch cocktails (unlimited) it's $135 per couple which includes tax and tip. The event is 3 hours so it left us time to go downstairs and enjoy a few pints.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place all around. Now they have Comedy Brunch!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was our first visit to Lily's and although the food was excellent our service was not. She seemed friendly enough with other tables but when she came to our table she barely looked at us, reached across my face to pick up dishes while taking to table next to us. I think she even sighed when we asked for dessert to go. Unfortunately we had to reflect this in our tip. We frequent the restaurants in this area a lot and we love tipping generously to show our appreciation of good friendly service. Not sure if we'll be back here. Maybe only if we get a different server.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
A very nice Irish man pub in every way. Good Guinness too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sat at bar for 3hrs.Dropped $160.00 between my wife and I on a tab.Not one bye back. Apologies to the staff for not tipping appropriately but bar policy sucks.
Service: 5
Was at venue 01/27 for a great Irish band. Sat at the bar, great service from the staff. $160.00 later no/not one buyback. Apologies to the staff for no tip but not having it... I
Attended private party on 1/20/24! the food was outstanding as was the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent Food And Excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5