Got some lovely chocolate-covered strawberries for Valentine’s Day. The staff were friendly and helpful. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the sweets. Great experience, the kind that makes you want to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kayla Lopez
Every time I do my nails across the street, I always say to myself, “That’s such a cute bakery, I definitely need to give it a try. Today, I decided it was time, and it was the best choice ever!!! As soon as you walk in, you get a nice, cozy, warm, homey feeling. I picked up a few good such as the apple and blueberry turnover, pignoli cookies, cannolis, and sfogliatella and everything was phenomenal!! You can taste the freshness and I love that. It's very hard to find that now a days. Definitely going back again. People, it is very, very important to support local businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cathy Seftner
I've finally found a bakery that meets my high expectations! This is real old school Italian baking at it's finest.
dino cammerto
I went there for the first time yesterday and we got a bunch of sweets, the lobster tails were amazing as well as everything else. Gabriella was so nice, the place is great and the staff is friendly. This will be a regular spot for us. Thank you Gabriella.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jim Hill
This place is a little gem in Babylon. It’s not just great Italian pastries, EVERYTHING they make is top notch. Family owned and operated, Mom up front taking care of customers and the son is the baker. Can’t recommend more highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe M
Excellent strawberry shortcake for my wife's birthday. Made special. Thank you Anthony and Gabriella. Everyone loves it 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Smythe
A lot of fresh pastry options.. very clean. Family business. Very nice store, friendly staff and good food. Busy on Thanksgiving so we had to wait, but they were faster with those who ordered ahead. Definately a Fav!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Nick Giglio
The best freshly made bakery products which we always enjoy.
Donna Cusack
My granddaughter loves red velvet cake. Last year for her birthday I got half sheet cake from Mario’s and everyone loved it. So this year once again everyone requested it so I had to take the cake into the city again. 45 people raved and said they never tasted anything better. Thanks for being so great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dr Christine Antoldi
Highly Recommend! The Lobster Tails, Cannolis, and cookies are delicious. Anthony is super nice and accommodating, A must try.
Been coming here for years n years. All I can figure is don’t go the day before they leave on a week plus vacation!! Hubby bought my usual birthday treats. Napoleons and Linzer tarts. The napoleons were not napoleons. No icing , with the chocolate swirls just powdered sugar. With fruit in top. Nope. The cream was what? I do not know terrible is what and the light pastry was so soggy you couldn’t even break it. Trashed all 3 ..$$ down the drain and a birthday surprise I look forward to every year ruined. The Linzer tarts had congealed jelly and were so hard I couldn’t bite it. More wasted $$. Not sure what happened but there are other bakeries I’m planning on trying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Brandon Berté
I put in a custom half-sheet cake order for a wedding celebration just a week in advance, and the team at Mario’s Pasticceria could not have been more accommodating. They were attentive to every detail and made the process easy and stress-free. The cake itself was absolutely incredible—even guests who don’t normally like sweets couldn’t stop raving about it! I’m beyond grateful for their flexibility and for what might be the most delicious cake I’ve ever had. Thank you, Mario’s!
Norah B13
Always my very favourite place to go. Angelica is fantastic. As well as Anthony!.. grazie mile!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dalia Kay
Beautiful atmosphere and great pastries!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Fruit Tart, Muffin, Linzer Torte
Jessica Spitaleri
We’ve tried Italian cheesecake from many different bakeries and always ended up disappointed and they went in the trash. But then we discovered Mario’s Pasticceria in Babylon! Their Italian cheesecake is absolutely the best we’ve ever had! It was rich, creamy, and had the authentic flavor we’d been searching for. It tasted amazing!! We will definitely be going back for more!
Got some lovely chocolate-covered strawberries for Valentine’s Day. The staff were friendly and helpful. My wife thoroughly enjoyed the sweets. Great experience, the kind that makes you want to come back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every time I do my nails across the street, I always say to myself, “That’s such a cute bakery, I definitely need to give it a try. Today, I decided it was time, and it was the best choice ever!!! As soon as you walk in, you get a nice, cozy, warm, homey feeling. I picked up a few good such as the apple and blueberry turnover, pignoli cookies, cannolis, and sfogliatella and everything was phenomenal!! You can taste the freshness and I love that. It's very hard to find that now a days. Definitely going back again. People, it is very, very important to support local businesses.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've finally found a bakery that meets my high expectations! This is real old school Italian baking at it's finest.
I went there for the first time yesterday and we got a bunch of sweets, the lobster tails were amazing as well as everything else.
Gabriella was so nice, the place is great and the staff is friendly.
This will be a regular spot for us.
Thank you Gabriella.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is a little gem in Babylon. It’s not just great Italian pastries, EVERYTHING they make is top notch. Family owned and operated, Mom up front taking care of customers and the son is the baker. Can’t recommend more highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent strawberry shortcake for my wife's birthday. Made special.
Thank you Anthony and Gabriella.
Everyone loves it 😁
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A lot of fresh pastry options.. very clean. Family business. Very nice store, friendly staff and good food. Busy on Thanksgiving so we had to wait, but they were faster with those who ordered ahead. Definately a Fav!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The best freshly made bakery products which we always enjoy.
My granddaughter loves red velvet cake. Last year for her birthday I got half sheet cake from Mario’s and everyone loved it. So this year once again everyone requested it so I had to take the cake into the city again. 45 people raved and said they never tasted anything better. Thanks for being so great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly Recommend! The Lobster Tails, Cannolis, and cookies are delicious. Anthony is super nice and accommodating, A must try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Been coming here for years n years. All I can figure is don’t go the day before they leave on a week plus vacation!! Hubby bought my usual birthday treats. Napoleons and Linzer tarts. The napoleons were not napoleons. No icing , with the chocolate swirls just powdered sugar. With fruit in top. Nope. The cream was what? I do not know terrible is what and the light pastry was so soggy you couldn’t even break it. Trashed all 3 ..$$ down the drain and a birthday surprise I look forward to every year ruined. The Linzer tarts had congealed jelly and were so hard I couldn’t bite it. More wasted $$. Not sure what happened but there are other bakeries I’m planning on trying.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
I put in a custom half-sheet cake order for a wedding celebration just a week in advance, and the team at Mario’s Pasticceria could not have been more accommodating. They were attentive to every detail and made the process easy and stress-free. The cake itself was absolutely incredible—even guests who don’t normally like sweets couldn’t stop raving about it! I’m beyond grateful for their flexibility and for what might be the most delicious cake I’ve ever had. Thank you, Mario’s!
Always my very favourite place to go. Angelica is fantastic. As well as Anthony!.. grazie mile!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful atmosphere and great pastries!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cannoli, Fruit Tart, Muffin, Linzer Torte
We’ve tried Italian cheesecake from many different bakeries and always ended up disappointed and they went in the trash. But then we discovered Mario’s Pasticceria in Babylon! Their Italian cheesecake is absolutely the best we’ve ever had! It was rich, creamy, and had the authentic flavor we’d been searching for. It tasted amazing!! We will definitely be going back for more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...