Mary Caroll’s

121 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon
(631) 581-6181

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Hand Cut

Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Fingers
Giant Pretzel
With beer cheese.
Buratta Flat Bread
A generous helping of two large delicious Barrata balls on Toast with chopped Tomato, Shaved Parm', Basil, Olive Oil, and a Balsamic Glaze
Ultimate Nachos

Wings
BONELESS WINGS
WINGS SMALL
Tossed in choice of sauce.
WINGS LARGE
Choice of Sauce

Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Old school buttery Texas toast and American cheese. Served with French fries, coleslaw, or side salad.
Bistro Steak Sandwich
Pan seared rib eye, caramelized onions, melted provolone, Homemade butter, and rustic roll. Served with Had Cut French fries, Coleslaw, or Side Salad.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Served with French fries, coleslaw, or side salad.
Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Caramelized onions, avocado, melted pepper Jack, avocado ranch, and rustic roll. Served with French fries, coleslaw, or side salad.
Philly Cheesesteak

Seafood
Fried Calamari
Served tossed in choice of sauce.
Fish and Chips
Guinness beer battered fresh haddock and hand cut fries.

Fries
Hand Cut Fries
Disco Fries
Mozzarella, gravy and bacon.
Build Your Own Fries
Truffle Fries
With parmesan and chives.
GARLIC CHEESE & CHIPS
Large Platter of Fries smothered in homemade garlic mayo and melted cheddar

Burgers
Build Your Own Burger
Quinoa Black Bean

Irish
Shepherd's Pie

DESERT
ANDY'S FAMOUS CHEESECAKE
Homemade by Andy, our Top Chef. It's so good, it's our ONLY desert !!!

SALADS
CAESAR
Classic Caesar with Crisp Romaine, Grand Croutons, 5 Cheese Blend & Tuscan Caesar Dressing
SOUTHWEST
Black Beans, Corn, Carrots, Baby Tomatoes, Shredded Cheddar, Tortilla Chips, Romaine & Avocado Ranch Dressing

GRAIN BOWLS
MEDITERANIAN
On a Bed of Quinoa & Red Cabbage & Arugula - Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Greek Olives, Chickpeas and a 5 Cheese Blend. Drizzled with Olive Oil, Balsamic Glaze & Basil
BAD HOMBRES
A Bed of Quinoa & Red Cabbage. Black Beans, Corn, Diced Tomatoes & Shredded Cheddar Jack, with Avocado Publano Ranch Dressing

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+63 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+62 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We hosted a birthday party in the back beach area and it was amazing! Great and personal service from Connor, Francis and Matt and Mary Carroll’s was extremely accommodating and helpful in planning our party to be exactly what we wanted! Everyone had a great time and the food and drinks were fantastic! Could not recommend them more to host any event
June 2025
I love everything about this Irish pub. Most importantly though, it’s actually ran by an Irish person unlike another so called Irish pub in Babylon…but anyway! The food is so good, like it’s not shitty bar food. I order take out from them because I love their food so much. It’s the perfect spot for young people to have fun and hang out! It has a real Irish pub atmosphere. The back with the tables is fantastic and great for the night life. I always have a fantastic time...
March 2025
My favorite hometown bar…and I’ve been to a few, friends. Fun place, fun crowd, football fans, cool bartenders and beefy security guys who can double as your flag football team’s ringers. Four separate areas AND the food is 4/5.
January 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Del Fuego - 117 Deer Pk Ave
Tex-Mex, Mexican, Bar, Tacos, Gluten-Free
The Brixton - 111 Deer Pk Ave
Cocktail Bar, Tapas Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegan
The Green Fork - 101 Deer Pk Ave Suite B
Salad, Health Food

Mary Caroll’s

121 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon, NY 11702
(631) 581-6181