Good food excellent and attentive service generous portions
Thank you for a great dining experience
Maria DeGennaro
I’ve been a customer for over 40 years of this pizzeria. The family that’s been running at the last 25++ years is aware that I’ve been a very very good customer. I will never ever go to this pizzeria ever again. I asked a simple request several days ago. I asked them to make me larger size garlic knots, because I wanted to prepare it for my family lunch with filet mignon that I would be preparing at home. Task became an issue for them because they couldn’t comprehend a simple request. Not only did they come to my house and deliver PLAIN rolls, NOT garlic knots In a larger format to accommodate the lunch at my home today.- Tom whoever he is, a manager hung up on me when I was obviously clearly upset because a simple request with only an hour and a half to spare before my family arrives was not met. Let me also mentioned that Tom is the same individual called me to tell a few days ago to inform me I would have to pay extra money to have the delivery of the garlic knots (that were not garlic knots as I found out today at 11:30 AM today) on Sunday because they would have to ask a driver to come in much sooner in order to deliver at my requested time at 11:30 AM. Can you imagine????!!!!I Now I have to pay for a driver salary to have a driver come in earlier? This is beyond unprofessional and it was certainly not the right thing to ask a very loyal customer of over 40 years to pay for the driver out-of-pocket. Meanwhile, it’s a beautiful Sunday tons of football going on all day today, do you think they would be prepared and have a driver ready to deliver for those afternoon football games or other events that people may have in their homes today. I was threatened after they came back and did a half assed job throwing on cheese and parsley onto the plane rolls, but if I did not pay today, they would take everything back. I suggested that I would come in after work tomorrow to speak to Chris because of this extreme aggravation over a simple task and a simple request for larger size garlic knots. I will no longer ever go to this pizzeria order from this pizzeria or have anything to do with this family ever again. Tom , the manager when I propose I would come in tomorrow after work hung up on me once again. This is poor Business and I feel ashamed for their behavior. Per Tom he said that Chris stated that if I did not pay today, then he will take back the garlic knots that they screwed up anyway so basically he threatened me as opposed to acting in a professional capacity and having a conversation with me tomorrow along with apology that I certainly would deserve after being treated poorly as well as them screwing up my order.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dominick Bianco
If you like overpriced , poorly made food with good service, this is the pace for you.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
BARRY Rosenberg
Best ? in Babylon. Nobody's even close!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Spencer Romero
Really well cooked pizza and quick wait time, very nice inside decor as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh
Long story short our waiter was not satisfied with her tip and made it be known in front of our entire family that her tip wasn't enough. It was extremely embarrassing and unprofessional on her part. We will be taking our business across the street to the pizzeria from now on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
CPNY
Although the regular slice was on the thick side, it was pretty good. I got a vodka slice that had no hint of vodka sauce-maybe he gave me the wrong one-I'll go back and try again. The counter people were nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Teresa L
Great authentic Italian style food. Service is great and atmosphere is nice too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
alyssa emmanuel
Very good food very good staff. Big portions recommend highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Kaitlyn McKendry
Marcy was absolutely amazing. Food was amazing it was all so good
We were having a special Almafi coast bridal shower on Sunday July 14th under tents in my yard. We had 50 people and we specifically served itslian apps and food. We ordered a half tray of fried calamari which was about 100.00 dollars. My son went to pick it up at 1200 which was the specified time and he waited a half hour. Which the bridal shower was for his fiancé on top of it. We set it out as soon as he arrived….. no one ate it I still have the whole tray. It was all rubbery chewy and filled with all breadcrumbs. Quite a few people told me this. I was upset since it was part of the chosen apps. I called to speak to the owner Nicole explained what happened I told her I have the whole tray would you like it back since no one can eat it. She declined and said the best she could do was offer me a 25 dollar certificate which is a slap in the face. I spent close to 100 dollars and still have the whole tray which is being dumped. She could care less about the times I told her we were there through the YEARS for many family functions that’s why I chose the place. Because she didn’t credit me back I will no longer ever go to this restersunt in babylon ny ever again. Disgraceful. I am not even using the gift certificate. I wouldn’t give that place any more of my hard earned money!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Coleen Arceri
Dietary restrictions: Allergy conscious
Parking: Parking right out front
Kid-friendliness: Pizza
Wheelchair accessibility: Accessibile
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Salad
Matt Arceri
Always a great meal ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lulu moskowitz
Food svc atmosphere were excellent! Went for bday dinner ..very nice. Owner friendly, and a doll!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lulu Michaels
Dining room elegant and comfy, and not noisy. Went for my bday, had the gorganzola calamari..omg..delish..had the meatballs with spaghetti bolnaise. My date had the stuffed rigatoni bolanaise..delish too. Owner nice man..!
Good food excellent and attentive service generous portions Thank you for a great dining experience
I’ve been a customer for over 40 years of this pizzeria. The family that’s been running at the last 25++ years is aware that I’ve been a very very good customer. I will never ever go to this pizzeria ever again. I asked a simple request several days ago. I asked them to make me larger size garlic knots, because I wanted to prepare it for my family lunch with filet mignon that I would be preparing at home. Task became an issue for them because they couldn’t comprehend a simple request. Not only did they come to my house and deliver PLAIN rolls, NOT garlic knots In a larger format to accommodate the lunch at my home today.- Tom whoever he is, a manager hung up on me when I was obviously clearly upset because a simple request with only an hour and a half to spare before my family arrives was not met. Let me also mentioned that Tom is the same individual called me to tell a few days ago to inform me I would have to pay extra money to have the delivery of the garlic knots (that were not garlic knots as I found out today at 11:30 AM today) on Sunday because they would have to ask a driver to come in much sooner in order to deliver at my requested time at 11:30 AM. Can you imagine????!!!!I Now I have to pay for a driver salary to have a driver come in earlier? This is beyond unprofessional and it was certainly not the right thing to ask a very loyal customer of over 40 years to pay for the driver out-of-pocket. Meanwhile, it’s a beautiful Sunday tons of football going on all day today, do you think they would be prepared and have a driver ready to deliver for those afternoon football games or other events that people may have in their homes today. I was threatened after they came back and did a half assed job throwing on cheese and parsley onto the plane rolls, but if I did not pay today, they would take everything back. I suggested that I would come in after work tomorrow to speak to Chris because of this extreme aggravation over a simple task and a simple request for larger size garlic knots. I will no longer ever go to this pizzeria order from this pizzeria or have anything to do with this family ever again. Tom , the manager when I propose I would come in tomorrow after work hung up on me once again. This is poor Business and I feel ashamed for their behavior. Per Tom he said that Chris stated that if I did not pay today, then he will take back the garlic knots that they screwed up anyway so basically he threatened me as opposed to acting in a professional capacity and having a conversation with me tomorrow along with apology that I certainly would deserve after being treated poorly as well as them screwing up my order.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
If you like overpriced , poorly made food with good service, this is the pace for you.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Best ? in Babylon. Nobody's even close!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really well cooked pizza and quick wait time, very nice inside decor as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Long story short our waiter was not satisfied with her tip and made it be known in front of our entire family that her tip wasn't enough. It was extremely embarrassing and unprofessional on her part. We will be taking our business across the street to the pizzeria from now on.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Although the regular slice was on the thick side, it was pretty good. I got a vodka slice that had no hint of vodka sauce-maybe he gave me the wrong one-I'll go back and try again. The counter people were nice.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great authentic Italian style food. Service is great and atmosphere is nice too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good food very good staff. Big portions recommend highly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian
Marcy was absolutely amazing. Food was amazing it was all so good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We were having a special Almafi coast bridal shower on Sunday July 14th under tents in my yard. We had 50 people and we specifically served itslian apps and food. We ordered a half tray of fried calamari which was about 100.00 dollars. My son went to pick it up at 1200 which was the specified time and he waited a half hour. Which the bridal shower was for his fiancé on top of it. We set it out as soon as he arrived….. no one ate it I still have the whole tray. It was all rubbery chewy and filled with all breadcrumbs. Quite a few people told me this. I was upset since it was part of the chosen apps. I called to speak to the owner Nicole explained what happened I told her I have the whole tray would you like it back since no one can eat it.
She declined and said the best she could do was offer me a 25 dollar certificate which is a slap in the face. I spent close to 100 dollars and still have the whole tray which is being dumped. She could care less about the times I told her we were there through the YEARS for many family functions that’s why I chose the place. Because she didn’t credit me back I will no longer ever go to this restersunt in babylon ny ever again. Disgraceful. I am not even using the gift certificate. I wouldn’t give that place any more of my hard earned money!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dietary restrictions: Allergy conscious
Parking: Parking right out front
Kid-friendliness: Pizza
Wheelchair accessibility: Accessibile
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Salad
Always a great meal ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food svc atmosphere were excellent!
Went for bday dinner ..very nice. Owner friendly, and a doll!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dining room elegant and comfy, and not noisy. Went for my bday, had the gorganzola calamari..omg..delish..had the meatballs with spaghetti bolnaise.
My date had the stuffed rigatoni bolanaise..delish too.
Owner nice man..!
Parking: Big lot!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian, Meatballs
Loading...