Enjoyed a great meal after a show at the Argyle. Isaac was in training and very attentive waiter. Lovely experience all around from food to staff!
Sam
I order from here every weekend, their food is amazing! Best penne alla vodka on Long Island hands down. Amazing balsamic dressing and garlic knots! Staff is always so friendly when I come in. I come all the way from Sayville every weekend to get my penne alla vodka it makes my weekend after a long work week! They have a permanent customer here!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barry M.
I can sum it up in one word "PHENOMENAL" For years I have always driven pass this establishment and always said to my wife we've gotta try this place one day I've heard such great reviews about it. Well that time finally came this past Sunday 3/10/24. The best phrase to describe this establishment would be a hidden gem. For those who haven't been there yet, seriously consider a visit I'm sure you will not be disappointed. My wife and I would consider this to be a very nice upscale sophisticated pizzeria restaurant that hits (5 Stars) across the board, not only did we find our Waitress Service to be quite exceptional the Menu and Specials selections offered would be guaranteed to satisfy everyone. We found the taste and quality of ingredients in our meals were quite exceptional. The portions were quite large and plentiful as well as being very reasonably priced. Their prices and selection on their Wines, Beers and Other Beverages were surprisingly quite reasonable as well as inexpensive compared to neighboring establishments. This will definitely become an establishment my wife and I will be patronizing again in the near future.
Theresa T.
Dined in, 3 of us ,first time here. Delicious food, nice and hot, great portions!. Service was terrific, we were well taken care of. Friendly owner and staff. They work hard, and you can see that by quality of the food.. Ambiance was fine, busy around 530. We had reservations. Enjoyed, all around we will return for sure. Thank you for a nice meal!.
Denise Z.
Portions enormous. I found the food to be quite heavy, but I guess it depends on the dish. It's very tasty and fresh. Service is very good and you're not rushed. Friendly and homey ambiance.
Nellsss
It was very nice in there but the staff didn’t even acknowledge my friend and I even though they saw us walk in we stood there for about 10 mins waiting for someone if he didn’t say excuse me we would’ve been standing there longer and the pizza was bland not really good. Customer service needs to be worked on cause I didn’t get no warm friendly greetings when I came in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Victor Delacruz
It’s cozy and clean. Friendly staff, good service and the food was very tasty. The braised short rib was delicious! You also must try the rainbow cheesecake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Braised Short Ribs
Apryl H.
I will definitely be coming back! My best friend and I came for Restaurant Week but ended up eating off the regular menu. The food was so good. I was happy with everything I ordered. Even the bread basket was delicious. We had great service. Everyone was very friendly. The restaurant was clean and cozy. I had a great lunch.
John Stein
Friendly staff, great food and the take out order is always right!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John D.
We were there on sunday afternoon for early dinner. It was a little diffical to find parking, but the Food was delicious, service was excellent, the ambiance was good
I am so surprised by any negative reviews here because we eat dinner here at least twice a month and the food is always fresh and delicious. The wait staff here are the nicest people and can’t do enough for you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chuck A.
Very disappointing experience at Mulberry Street last evening. The wait for service and for our appetizers and entrees was ridiculous to the point where we told our waitress to cancel the appetizers and just bring our entrees. It was almost an hour from when we placed our order until the entrees arrived. Our waitress was very apologetic and said it was related to many of the people dining at the same time before showtime at the Argyle Theater. Several tables who arrived before us were just getting their appetizers when we were leaving. The food is excellent and the waitstaff was trying their best, but I will avoid Saturday evenings at this restaurant in the future.
Barbara L.
I went to this restaurant for the first time and I went to check out the reviews following since my food wasn't that great, I wanted to see what the people were recommending if I ever decided to give it another chance. I wanted to write an honest review but reading through the comments here I can really tell the owner is an angry and very abusive man that I wouldn't want to support regardless. He's a restaurant owner and apparently thinks it's appropriate to FAT SHAME his customers? It's completely baffling anyone would support this guys business moving forward. I also saw several health violations that the customers are clearly concerned about and he calls them 'dramatic babies' he thinks it's becoming to brag about yelling at ladies to get the F out and not come back... I've never witnessed such unprofessional behavior so publicly so obviously he's not ashamed at all. Please don't support this business, go somewhere else where the owner is a decent human who cares about the ship he's sailing.
Roy Scott
Thank you mulberry street for you top notch service, I ordered a chicken Parm with vodka sauce and just get regular chicken Parm. I ordered three sandwiches and only one was correct, I guess instead letting the customer know they aren't getting their order correct. You get what they give you. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Nathaniel Larson
Best pizza in town! Grandma vodka / Honey Pep / really any slice here is spot
Enjoyed a great meal after a show at the Argyle. Isaac was in training and very attentive waiter. Lovely experience all around from food to staff!
I order from here every weekend, their food is amazing! Best penne alla vodka on Long Island hands down. Amazing balsamic dressing and garlic knots! Staff is always so friendly when I come in. I come all the way from Sayville every weekend to get my penne alla vodka it makes my weekend after a long work week! They have a permanent customer here!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can sum it up in one word "PHENOMENAL" For years I have always driven pass this establishment and always said to my wife we've gotta try this place one day I've heard such great reviews about it. Well that time finally came this past Sunday 3/10/24. The best phrase to describe this establishment would be a hidden gem. For those who haven't been there yet, seriously consider a visit I'm sure you will not be disappointed. My wife and I would consider this to be a very nice upscale sophisticated pizzeria restaurant that hits (5 Stars) across the board, not only did we find our Waitress Service to be quite exceptional the Menu and Specials selections offered would be guaranteed to satisfy everyone. We found the taste and quality of ingredients in our meals were quite exceptional. The portions were quite large and plentiful as well as being very reasonably priced. Their prices and selection on their Wines, Beers and Other Beverages were surprisingly quite reasonable as well as inexpensive compared to neighboring establishments. This will definitely become an establishment my wife and I will be patronizing again in the near future.
Dined in, 3 of us ,first time here. Delicious food, nice and hot, great portions!. Service was terrific, we were well taken care of. Friendly owner and staff. They work hard, and you can see that by quality of the food.. Ambiance was fine, busy around 530. We had reservations. Enjoyed, all around we will return for sure. Thank you for a nice meal!.
Portions enormous. I found the food to be quite heavy, but I guess it depends on the dish. It's very tasty and fresh. Service is very good and you're not rushed. Friendly and homey ambiance.
It was very nice in there but the staff didn’t even acknowledge my friend and I even though they saw us walk in we stood there for about 10 mins waiting for someone if he didn’t say excuse me we would’ve been standing there longer and the pizza was bland not really good. Customer service needs to be worked on cause I didn’t get no warm friendly greetings when I came in
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
It’s cozy and clean. Friendly staff, good service and the food was very tasty. The braised short rib was delicious! You also must try the rainbow cheesecake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Braised Short Ribs
I will definitely be coming back! My best friend and I came for Restaurant Week but ended up eating off the regular menu. The food was so good. I was happy with everything I ordered. Even the bread basket was delicious. We had great service. Everyone was very friendly. The restaurant was clean and cozy. I had a great lunch.
Friendly staff, great food and the take out order is always right!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were there on sunday afternoon for early dinner. It was a little diffical to find parking, but the Food was delicious, service was excellent, the ambiance was good
Restaurantji Recommends
I am so surprised by any negative reviews here because we eat dinner here at least twice a month and the food is always fresh and delicious. The wait staff here are the nicest people and can’t do enough for you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very disappointing experience at Mulberry Street last evening. The wait for service and for our appetizers and entrees was ridiculous to the point where we told our waitress to cancel the appetizers and just bring our entrees. It was almost an hour from when we placed our order until the entrees arrived. Our waitress was very apologetic and said it was related to many of the people dining at the same time before showtime at the Argyle Theater. Several tables who arrived before us were just getting their appetizers when we were leaving. The food is excellent and the waitstaff was trying their best, but I will avoid Saturday evenings at this restaurant in the future.
I went to this restaurant for the first time and I went to check out the reviews following since my food wasn't that great, I wanted to see what the people were recommending if I ever decided to give it another chance. I wanted to write an honest review but reading through the comments here I can really tell the owner is an angry and very abusive man that I wouldn't want to support regardless. He's a restaurant owner and apparently thinks it's appropriate to FAT SHAME his customers? It's completely baffling anyone would support this guys business moving forward. I also saw several health violations that the customers are clearly concerned about and he calls them 'dramatic babies' he thinks it's becoming to brag about yelling at ladies to get the F out and not come back... I've never witnessed such unprofessional behavior so publicly so obviously he's not ashamed at all. Please don't support this business, go somewhere else where the owner is a decent human who cares about the ship he's sailing.
Thank you mulberry street for you top notch service, I ordered a chicken Parm with vodka sauce and just get regular chicken Parm. I ordered three sandwiches and only one was correct, I guess instead letting the customer know they aren't getting their order correct. You get what they give you. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Best pizza in town! Grandma vodka / Honey Pep / really any slice here is spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5