Sal's pizza is great brooklyn style / tasting pizza and all their other food is good as well people giving bad reviews or not wanting to try this place out over why the prices went up sign is a joke ... and the reason is 100% the truth ... they are great people / friendly etc ..
Mike Mullaney
The ? is great!You have the best pizza.
Yusuf Erdogan
Amazing place, prices were amazing and the owner was so kind and friendly. The pizza was delicious!
Timothy Farrelly
Best slice I’ve had in along time small little local place with a decent following will be back again
Peter S.
this is amazing pizza no joke. delicious thin crispy crust and just perfect amount and taste of cheese and sauce too. i will definite be stopping in at this place again if i'm heading to bartini for a jam or in the neighborhood again. this is way better than anything we have in long beach (sorry genos, east end cafe, west end). had a pepperoni pinwheel too, also very very good. if you love pizza you gotta try this place.
Hasan Altaf
I was on my way back to city from Montauk. I tried their cheese slice on my way back. It was sooo good. The guy at the counter was nice too. I definitely recommend it.
Bryce Rutzke
Great pizza, sandwiches and pastas.The family is also extremely nice!
Shalyn Abramovich
I can't believe it took me this long to order from Sal's Famous Pizzeria!! My staff called in a pie for delivery. The gentleman who took the order was very nice on the phone, delivery was speedy, and it was definitely the BEST pizza I've had in a while! We got the garlic knot pie which was devoured within minutes! 10/10 would recommend!
JC LI
A solid 4 stars. Great regular and Sicilian slice. Prices are comparable to the rest of Babylon. A small mom and pop store. Will definitely be back. You will no be disappointed
Lori Dreyfus
I just left there and I can't stop laughing. There was no one in there , at least enough pizza to feed 20 and the man behind the counter told me he had to make a pie before taking my order. As far as I could see they only offered pizza and slushy s I waited 10 minutes so he could spend 30 seconds putting my slice in the oven. Crazy, what the hell is going on?
Come for the misogyny, stay for the bad pizza. I recently placed an order under my name and my wife ran in to pick it up. They questioned her when she gave my name and she said "it's my husbands name," and the guy says, "oh I thought we were going to have to check something on you!" Just an inappropriate thing to say to a customer. Then there's the pizza. The first time I'd tasted it, I assumed they had to be running drugs out the back to stay open. It's like the pizza you would find in the south. Low on flavor, and the crust is like a very soft bread. Priced for the upper East side with the kind of pizza you'd expect from a suburb of Pittsburg.
Vincent Taormina
friendly people excellent food
Greg Merigliano
The owner mixes politics and food by writing his POV on his chalkboard adding to the divisiveness in this country. He never wore a mask during covid, his pizza is way over-prices for only a fair product.
Jeremy Bruno
Got a regular slice in the pm tasted like it was sitting there all day very disappointed won’t ever go back
Jacob Liers
For 40$ For a pizza pie, I expected the crust to not be burnt
Sal's pizza is great brooklyn style / tasting pizza and all their other food is good as well people giving bad reviews or not wanting to try this place out over why the prices went up sign is a joke ... and the reason is 100% the truth ... they are great people / friendly etc ..
The ? is great!You have the best pizza.
Amazing place, prices were amazing and the owner was so kind and friendly. The pizza was delicious!
Best slice I’ve had in along time small little local place with a decent following will be back again
this is amazing pizza no joke. delicious thin crispy crust and just perfect amount and taste of cheese and sauce too. i will definite be stopping in at this place again if i'm heading to bartini for a jam or in the neighborhood again. this is way better than anything we have in long beach (sorry genos, east end cafe, west end). had a pepperoni pinwheel too, also very very good. if you love pizza you gotta try this place.
I was on my way back to city from Montauk. I tried their cheese slice on my way back. It was sooo good. The guy at the counter was nice too. I definitely recommend it.
Great pizza, sandwiches and pastas.The family is also extremely nice!
I can't believe it took me this long to order from Sal's Famous Pizzeria!! My staff called in a pie for delivery. The gentleman who took the order was very nice on the phone, delivery was speedy, and it was definitely the BEST pizza I've had in a while! We got the garlic knot pie which was devoured within minutes! 10/10 would recommend!
A solid 4 stars. Great regular and Sicilian slice. Prices are comparable to the rest of Babylon. A small mom and pop store. Will definitely be back. You will no be disappointed
I just left there and I can't stop laughing. There was no one in there , at least enough pizza to feed 20 and the man behind the counter told me he had to make a pie before taking my order. As far as I could see they only offered pizza and slushy s I waited 10 minutes so he could spend 30 seconds putting my slice in the oven. Crazy, what the hell is going on?
Restaurantji Recommends
Come for the misogyny, stay for the bad pizza. I recently placed an order under my name and my wife ran in to pick it up. They questioned her when she gave my name and she said "it's my husbands name," and the guy says, "oh I thought we were going to have to check something on you!" Just an inappropriate thing to say to a customer. Then there's the pizza. The first time I'd tasted it, I assumed they had to be running drugs out the back to stay open. It's like the pizza you would find in the south. Low on flavor, and the crust is like a very soft bread. Priced for the upper East side with the kind of pizza you'd expect from a suburb of Pittsburg.
friendly people excellent food
The owner mixes politics and food by writing his POV on his chalkboard adding to the divisiveness in this country. He never wore a mask during covid, his pizza is way over-prices for only a fair product.
Got a regular slice in the pm tasted like it was sitting there all day very disappointed won’t ever go back
For 40$ For a pizza pie, I expected the crust to not be burnt