Shuga Pie Shop

135 Deer Pk Ave Unit 3, Babylon
(631) 669-1069

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie
Italian Cream Cake Shuga Pie
Death by Chocolate Shuga Pie
Cookies & Cream Shuga Pie
Rainbow Cookie Shuga Pie
Vanilla Crumb Shuga Pie
Red Velvet Shuga Pie
Mint Chocolate Chip
Funfetti Shuga Pie
Raspberry Macaroon

Desserts
Cookies & Cream Shuga Pie
Chocolate Cake filled with Cookies & Cream filling *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Death By Chocolate Shuga Pie
Chocolate Cake filled with chocolate cream & topped with chocolate ganache & mini chocolate chips. *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Vanilla Crumb Shuga Pie
Vanilla Cake with Cinnamon Crumb baked into the top, filled with cinnamon vanilla cream! *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Original Shuga Pie
The OG, how it all started, chocolate cake with vanilla filling *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Funfetti Shuga Pie
Vanilla Cake with rainbow sprinkles baked into the cake and filled with vanilla cream *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Assorted 6 Box-No Nuts No Coconut
Feeling adventurous? Choose this option & we will put together an assortment of whatever flavors we've baked for the day. This option will NOT include any nut or coconut flavors. *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn
Assorted 6 Box-Nut and/or Coconut Allowed
Feeling adventurous? Choose this option & we will put together an assortment of whatever flavors we've baked for the day. This option MAY include nut or coconut flavors. *Plant Based. Contains Pea Protein, Soy, Wheat, Gluten **Made in a shared facility with nuts, tree nuts, coconut, soy, wheat, pea protein, flax, hemp, sunflower, olive oil, corn

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+50 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Wow. These are so delicious and awesome. My friend and I tried the Lemon Poppy, Cookies and Cream, Blueberry Pancake, and Death by Chocolate and all of them were absolutely PHENOMENAL. Will most definitely be back here again please go and try this place out you will not be disappointed!
July 2025
This was a awesome place the walk up window was definitely 👌definitely worth the 60min drive from queens..we had a Lil car trouble and called and they were amazing and waited for us top notch customer service, pies definitely chefs kiss. Moist and flavorful...will highly recommend will be back. 😊
June 2025
Shuga Pies are the best! Their cakes are perfectly balanced—not too heavy or dense, and the cream is just right. It's a small, clean establishment with friendly and helpful owners. They expertly describe each cake, making your choice easy. Once you try Shuga Pies, you'll definitely want to come back for more.
November 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Swell Taco - 135 Deer Pk Ave
Tacos, Mexican, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
Mary Caroll’s - 121 Deer Pk Ave
Bar, Beer Gardens, Pet Friendly, Bar & Grill
Del Fuego - 117 Deer Pk Ave
Tex-Mex, Mexican, Bar, Tacos, Gluten-Free

Shuga Pie Shop

135 Deer Pk Ave Unit 3, Babylon, NY 11702
(631) 669-1069