Cooperage Inn

2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow
(631) 727-8994

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian

Our favorite area restaurant. We went there this time for restaurant weekon Thursday night. We were seated promptly. The service and food were great, as always. We ordered straight from the special menu and we're quite happy with our choices. Bravo!

Roy

My husband & I brought a friend to Cooperage Inn for LI Restaurant week. We love the extensive menu offerings at the two price points, $39 & $46. Appetizers were the Coooperage Inn salad, the Garden salad, and a crab cake. All delicious! For entrees, two of us got the broiled swordfish, and one got the potato crusted sea bass. It was the best swordfish I've had in a long time, and the sea bass was also a big hit. Desserts were rice pudding and Key Lime pie...scrumptious! Service was friendly & efficient, and the whole place was beautifully decorated. Highly recommend this fine establishment.

jennifer

Always great dinner! Atmosphere and service is great. The onion soup was on point, had the pork chop and mashed potatoes special--only complaint we all had is our food was warm or cold. Had our server re-heat and everything was much better. Tried the coconut cream pie for dessert, it was ok. There coconut in the lime martini is one of my favorites.

Megan

I am obsessed with this restaurant. There are so many options, and the food and service were wonderful. I can't wait to go back.

Elizabeth

The chicken pie crunch roll was to die for! Waitress was excellent. Chicken pot pie is always a crowd pleaser. My only suggestion would be that the plates are not cleared before everyone at the table was finished. Other than that, food, staff and ambience were wonderful

Angela

Have been here before and each time the dining experience was good. Good food and good service

Bob

The food and service were excellent. The menu has many choices and the specials were great. The wine list was also good.

Barry

We were disappointed yesterday. None of the meals were quite as good as in the past. The service was very slow, probably due to a party in another room. This was a birthday lunch for my wife with my son, and frankly we were not happy with it. In the past, we have been very happy with the quality of the food at the Cooperage.

Danny

This place never disappoints, been going here for a few years now, always great food and service.

Susan

The major complaint of our very large group is that it was very cold in the area where our table was located. Next time I will request the room with the fireplace as it is much cozier and warm. Also, our waitress was awesome and really made our dinner special, but the server/busboy seemed annoyed with our group. He tried to take our plates before we were done. Gave us a look when some of us asked for new utensils and then never brought them. He definitely was lacking in his customer service skills.

Kelly

Been many times and never had a bad meal. Atmosphere is great, feels warm and inviting. However, this time waitress was not very friendly or pleasant. Not a deal breaker, but was reflected in the tip.

Matthew

We have been going to The Cooperage for years and last night did not disappoint as usual. They have perfected their menu and added amazing specials. It was the perfect meal for my wife's birthday.

Janet

Dinner was delicious. The place was decorated so pretty!! Our waitress was very nice and got our whole order perfect! I love this restaurant.

Lauri A

We had a lovely dining experience at the Cooperage. The food was very good. Loved the ambiance. The waitress made us feel a little rushed but she was really very well intentioned.

Pat

Food what excellent 2 people got duck, 1 got salmon & I got Shimp & Chicken Francess. Everyone loved there meal. Definitely a place to visit and eat. Will be back.

Loading...