Cooperage Inn

2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow
(631) 727-8994

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nancy

The Cooperage never disappoints! Excellent food, service and ambience are always wonderful!

Huntley

Occasionally we eat at Cooperage Inn with friends who live nearby or visitors who come from anywhere. Each meal has been delightful. Knowledgeable staff who are patient and helpful as excellent preparation and presentation are hallmarks. As we age, hearing has become problematic, so tonight the noise level appeared to be louder than usual. We would gladly return.

Greg

Went with a group of 6 and everyone had a great time. We shared calamari and stuffed clams for appetizers and we all enjoyed our mains of duck, lobster, scallops and ribs. Their homemade ice cream topped it all off perfectly. The service was very attentive and and we all plan to return again in the future.

Frank

Service was awesome! Food was just okay as opposed to past experience dining here. Hopefully a one off.

STEVEN

Excellent service and food. My wife and I went for lunch. Cheeseburger and flounder sandwich were tasty. Peach martini was great, raspberry pineapple martini was just ok. Overall, I would highly recommend!

Joe

In fairness to the team out there we showed up late to a Sunday night reservation. However, it was clear they wanted us out. Next time I would suggest making people feel a bit more welcome.

Gail

We left the restaurant at 7:55 only to realize i had left my steak leftovers on the table . The restaurant closes at 8:00 and when i went back to retrieve my steak the doors were locked and the phone sent me to voicemail. Left me feeling upset and had no recourse

Ramona

Everything was outstanding, service was great, food exceptional, pot pies to die for, my friend had shrimps stuffed with crabmeat, we had a salad, wine and dirty martini!!!

Carol Ann

We have loved Cooperage Inn for years! Always a great experience with friendly, attentive & helpful staff. The food is always amazing no matter what we get!

Anita

The food and service for a busy Father's Day was fantastic! Great specials and local strawberries on short cake and strawberry cream pie were so delicious

Rosemarie

It was my husband and my first time at Cooperage Inn. We arrived 30 minutes early and they were most accommodating and seated us without a fuss. Our waitress Joanne was lovely, she helped us with our choices and was very polite and cheerful. My husband was happy with his cowboy steak and I with my rack of lamb. Thank you to all the staff for making this Father's Day special for my husband.

Steve

Drinks were good as was the server Terry. If you order an entree, you can order a “small” salad for an additional $ 7. I have ordered a salad at many restaurants for double the price and they were not as large or as good as the small salad at the Cooperage. I had the rack of lamb. It was . outstanding. For desert, I had 2 scoops of ice cream. Again, very happy with my choice. Certainly worth the trip.

Robert

Dining at the Cooperage Inn was a very nice experience. Kerri our server was very attentive. The meal was superb. Everything was prepared perfectly. We will be back soon!

Lori

We took friends to cooperage. They had never been there but we have been several times. The food was wonderful and the service was excellent. It never disappoints.

Edward

It was a date night for me and my Bride of 32 years. Outstanding time. Food was off the hook. Staff attentive. We'll be back.

Loading...