Restaurants near Baiting Hollow

“Exceptional Bakery! Delicious cakes and cookies! Wonderful Service! Great People! They went out of their way for my brother’s birthday and made his day! He loves his cake and cookies!!! Thank you.”

“Had a great time, love the restaurant, but the grilled chicken was over cooked this time, required a steak knife to cut through, it is usually tender, perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. With that said, a great restaurant, highly recommend it!”

“Just ate dinner there. Excellent food and service. Cozy, friendly atmosphere. Will definitely go back. Especially liked the Jersey burger with the toot beer barbecue sauce, Applewood bacon, and cheddar on a pretzel roll.”

“Hands-down this is the best place for ice cream on the North Fork. During the summer, there are lines down the street to get into this place , so off-season it's a breeze to get the best ice cream or soft serve. Staff are very friendly and I highly recommend this place all year round! Gave it 4 stars bc it lacks ambience (yet you will not care!!). The homemade pistachio ice cream is something you must try . And it is right next door to Funchos, another great local place to frequent.”

“Absolutely loved their baked goods here especially the apple cider donuts. Prices for the baked goods are very good. My family had multiple allergies and I’m glad this place is able to make delicious treats that are allergy friendly.”

“Had a great dinner with friends last night. Service was the best ever and food was excellent! One of the few restaurants we’ve been to that don’t add a credit card fee to your check so we will be back! I gave it a 4 star for atmosphere only because I am not a fan of ultra contemporary decor because it lacks warmth and coziness and I remember that feeling of the ‘ol 2 x 4 restaurant from years past.”

“Just had lunch from A Wing Away Kitchen. The food was excellent, wings cooked perfectly, sauces were incredible. The best part was the staff! The owner gave us a taste of his chicken and rice (absolutely incredible!) and his “not spicys” sauce was better than spicys ever was! If you haven’t checked it out you should have dinner there tonight.”

“Being a Bariatric , Crohn’s patient its very hard to get proper mealsI stopped into this location and spoke with sydneyShe was kind helpful and now will be a regular customer !”

“Fantastic Polish Deli and grocery run by some really nice people. They have a big selection of kielbasa and their prepared dishes are delicious. Their stuffed cabbage was fantastic with so much flavor. The pigs knuckle was also extremely good if you're into that. There was also a large pastry section that I'm going back to check out.”

“Personally I had the Curry and it was GREAT. Some things could use some refining but all it all great atmosphere, good food. One of the better options on the north fork”

“Unbelievable such amazing cafe does exist on Long Island. Excellent espresso, fantastic and authentic tiramisu and tres leches. This now is our coffee place for eastern LI trips.”

“My first visit to Jerry and the Mermaid was nothing short of magical. Nestled along the seaside, this charming restaurant boasts not only impeccable food but also a breathtaking setting that instantly transports you to a coastal paradise.From the moment we stepped inside, we were welcomed with warmth and hospitality that made us feel like longtime regulars, despite it being our first time there. Jerry himself checked in on us multiple times, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was nothing short of perfection.Despite the bustling Friday crowd during Easter weekend, Jerry’s accommodating nature and honesty about the wait time made our decision to stay worth it. And oh, was it worth it! As we strolled along the docks, soaking in the ocean breeze, anticipation built for what turned out to be a phenomenal experience.The food, oh the food! Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and made with the utmost care. From the freshest seafood to delectable appetizers, every bite was a delight to the senses.But it wasn’t just the food that left a lasting impression. The atmosphere of the restaurant, with its cozy yet vibrant ambiance, added an extra layer of charm to the entire experience. Surrounded by the sound of waves and the sight of boats swaying gently in the harbor, we found ourselves lost in the moment, savoring each bite and each precious moment spent at Jerry and the Mermaid.In a world where exceptional dining experiences are rare gems, Jerry and the Mermaid shines brightly as a beacon of excellence. Whether you’re a local or a visitor passing through, do yourself a favor and make a reservation at this seaside paradise. You won’t regret it!”

“We spent valentines at one of our favorite local places yesterday, it was really busy our reservation was at 7 the height of dinner rush. We enjoyed every aspect of JC’s from the hostess to the servers to the much needed delicious dinner and ambiance! We started with chicken nachos and garlic bread, main course we had Norwegian lamb chops on a mountain of potatoes yum! I ordered the panko chicken with baby rigatonis peas buratta in a sherry sauce and what a trip to flavor town! The food here never disappoints even when we order takeout it’s always delicious. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner what a lovely hard working lady! All that she does to provide the best experience shines bright through her staff and patrons. We tested out little cheese cakes that were outrageous I don’t even like cheesecake and I ate them at first not knowing what they were. they were creamy and yummy and delicious I didn’t know I could like something so much that I didn’t like anywhere else. The strawberry was Huge and I ate every last bit we were stuffed I had to take home almost half of my dinner which we ate today! Jcs you do a exemplary service to our town thank you for a wonderful night, my pictures don’t do your food justice but I’m posting them anyway lol!”

“Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating to allergies restrictions. Everything was cooked to perfection.Parking: Plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Several tables had kids the servers were very friendly. Everyone that came to the diner seemed to be happy to be there. They seemed like they frequent this place.”

“Went for lunch while in the area and was pleasantly surprised. I did a quick search for gluten free and found this place. My mother has Celiac and was over the moon that she could have anything on the menu! My shakshuka was good, she loved her chicken sandwich. But the star of lunch was the fried calamari. The place is cute and intimate, good music playing. We'll be back next time we're near.”

“Some of the best Mexican food I’ve had in Long Island. Super authentic and great portions. Workers were really nice and the restaurant itself was really clean. Will be coming back ?”

“LOVE THIS PLACE! Whenever I'm out east I make it a point to come to this deli for lunch! Everything on the menu is great! The staff is extremely nice, welcoming and friendly. And it is always immaculately clean!”

“Got to sample 4 beers including the delicious Farmhouse Saison. One is more delicious than the other! And if you're lucky enough to catch the Right Coast Taco Truck, then you've hit the jackpot!”

“The food is excellent and the service is great. I highly recommend this spot. I had the Eggs Benedict with Lox, and it was superb. Their Suasage with gravy is the out of this world.”

“this place was awesome! Great century old/ modern atmosphere with a ton of history.owner owns a bison farm i believe, so the meat if farm fresh.Great drinks, great food, great people.A real gem for the area!”

“From service to presentation to flavor, North Tavern is absolutely wonderful. The Italian Toast appetizer is a great way to start the meal for a salad/bread plate beginning. The Fish Tasting had beautiful presentation and the flavor was phenomenal! Rounding the dinner off with a warm brownie recommended by our server was the way to go! Thank you to the owners, server, and especially to the chefs; my family and I talked about the meal on the way home… until it was too much and then had the change the subject. ?”

“Wife and I had dinner there the other night food is delicious. Highly recommend it we had burn brisket, sweet taters, and some kind of other Parmesan crusted potatoes. Definitely go back there.{ REAL FOOD }Vegetarian options: They had vegetarian tater saladGluten-free items also I can’t remember what though”

“Been here a few times and the food is excellent. Made to order. Owner very friendly. Not only is the food good but there is a bakery. Bakery items all made in store. You want good Mexican food try this place.”

“Came here the first time I visited Rivehead and now I make sure I leave time to visit each time I come back! I l always order sandwiches because they have not yet disappointed! I've brought my whole family as well as friends here and every single person has LOVED it. The place is family owned and it looks probably a lot like it did when it first opened. So cute and old fashioned. Also, I love their egg creams and their chocolate shakes! Definitely worth ordering. Everything is reasonably priced and just perfectly made. It's just nice to have some simple foods perfectly made! Highly recommend to anyone in town for the day. (Hours are unpredictable so just give them a call before heading over, but honestly it's part of the charm, it's a family place!)”

“Best place we ate food in Riverhead, hands down. Come as you are and enjoy some good ol' home cooking. Cash only and a super great environment. The food was great. We should have got a roll egg sandwich. ?”

“While in town for a few days we stopped here because I had a Groupon for a flight of 4 five oz beer/wine option. The place was kind of tucked away but had outdoor and indoor seating. The bartender helped us right away and we picked our 4 options and sat outside. They had some games indoor to play and it was pet friendly. Only takeaway was the very small amount of cider beer options on the menu other than that it was good.”

“We had two beer flights. Great price and great staff! So friendly. Live music. The beer is very good, they brew it there. The pretzel was really good too. Used the Habitat for Humanity card. What a deal. Go see them! Tell 'em Barsnobs sent ya!”

“Awesome Local Shop!I go here with my family and friends a lot and their service is always phenomenal along with the atmosphere!Kid-friendliness: This place is very good and friendly for kids it has a fun atmosphere and other kid friendly things.”

“I got so drunk! They say it must have been good it you can't remember ? The owner is Portuguese, he gave us his secret private bottle. When he found out my friends n I speak Portuguese . Come w friends taste everything. Great place to hang w friends.”

“Visited On the Docks for dinner during a quick getaway to Aquebogue and was really impressed with the food and service. I wish I could remember our server’s name, but he was exceptionally pleasant and attentive, without being annoying. The food was great too. We had the oysters (which were very fresh) and duck wings to start and then split a fried seafood platter and everything was delicious and well prepared.”