Sugar Sweet Treats

4603 Middle Country Rd, Baiting Hollow
(631) 766-9470

Recent Reviews

Sort by
eric bender

Stopped by the other day.. service was slow.. Overrated and pricey entenmans

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

John Thomas

Not sure why this has 5 stars, probably friends and family. Pastry was stale and fruit tasted spoiled. Not worth the money, stay away.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Maria Balbin

My daughter got the Gluten free Almond Raspberry cookies as a gift from her NY friend when my daughter visited NY. The cookies traveled with my daughter from NY to Pittsburgh PA (home). OMG!!! my daughter shared a cookie with me . Best cookies EVER!!! Simply delicious!! Perfect all over. Right away I looked for the bakery’s location and hope one day to visit your bakery, enjoy all other treats from your store and bring tons of them home :). This little box of cookies is a treasure. All about these cookies bring happiness to our hearts ❤️. Thank you!!✨

Food: 5

Robert Coleman

Excellent Raspberry Almond Cookies and Ricotta Cookies. Delicious and not overly sweet tasting. I purchased a two pack of each.

Food: 5

Natalie

They have the best gluten free desserts I have ever had. Their raspberry almond cookies are my favorite. Not too sweet and clearly made with quality ingredients. Really appreciate their customer service and their communication was great. Thank you!

Food: 5

Service: 5

susan frank

Love your glutin free cookies ?

Food: 5

Mark

I tried the crumble cake and the almond raspberry cookies. Both are incredible! I ate the whole cake in one sitting. It looked like a single portion but I was full after, yet it wasn’t so heavy that I regretted my decision. Most importantly all the ingredients they use are clean because they make everything from scratch. Nothing weird you’d see in mass produced sweets. I met the owners and they are great people. I’ll definitely need to order some more cookies to ship home to Chicago.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ray Moeck

Almond Rasberry cookies wonderful. Can't wait to try more goodies!

Food: 5

Lisa Jelinek

Exceptional Bakery! Delicious cakes and cookies! Wonderful Service! Great People! They went out of their way for my brother’s birthday and made his day! He loves his cake and cookies!!! Thank you.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anne Dean

Delicious Almond Raspberry heart cookies! The best and so fresh!

G M

Yummy!! just bought gluten free almond raspberry cookies, taste homemade!! delicious thank g__d now a good cookie!!

Susan Sutton

I stopped at a rest stop on my way to a wedding in Montauk and bought Ricotta Cookies…. Omg better than Aunt Katie’s……

Rachel Adam

just wanted to say that the lemon bars are delicious and incredibly addictive lol.

Mary Lehman

Linger tart cookies are delicious.

Rachel Adam (Rae)

just wanted to say that the lemon bars are delicious and incredibly addictive lol.

Loading...