Cinquino's Pizza

314 Ellicott St, Batavia
(585) 343-2447

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Loy Gross

Has become one of our go-to pizza shops locally. Pizza is good and they cook correctly to order.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

erick lindberg

Pizza was unfortunately undercooked. The dough was still partially uncooked. The guy at the counter didn’t seem to care about the customer. I gave it a second shot and experienced the same.
I wish I could give a better review without being dishonest.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Daniel LaRusso

Terrific if you like flaky greasy pizza crusts

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Alexa Smart

Consistent food, especially the salads, which always have fresh ingredients. The fried dough I ordered was overcooked and uneatable, but maybe it was the employee, who was on the fry line, just didn't care for his job. I walked in to place an order for take out (not at a busy time) the manager was on it right away, but I will think twice to eating in with friends, as I never heard such language from one the employees, very loud and unprofessional.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Cristina Paul

We LOVE your Pizza ABOVE ALL OTHERS!!!!
I would fly back from FL to Batavia to EAT a Whole Pizza by my little self of 98.6lbs,🥰😋🤪OUT of this WORLD!!!!! I am in LOVE!!!💕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anthony Mana

I ordered a foot-long chicken Parmesan sub two slices of pizza and a 2 L soda. They said it would be here in an hour. Less than half hour is here very hot and fresh. The best sub I’ve had in a very long time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chantal Lord

Every time we order, the food is stellar. The staff is friendly and the food is amazing.

JCS Cards and collectibles

My first time there tonight Excellent food and service
Nice to see ppl happy when working

SCOTT FARNER

The Uncle Nick is delicious! Friendly,fast,and excellent service.

Brian Haley

Meat ravioli was great, sauce had a subtle sweet flavor. Excellent garlic bread. My wife and daughter agreed their chicken fingers and chicken club sandwich were great as well. Friendly staff and clean bathroom.

MrMrs “Noneyabizness” Kro.

I know a guy! And his whole family make great pizza and pasta! Shout out from Rochester,NY.

Srividya Reddy

Best garlic bread I have had! We went in there with zero expectations but the bread was so damn good! Must try pizza place, looking forward to have pizza next time.

mallory bumpers

DELIVERS TO AREA51 MOTOCROSS TRACK!!!!!

(Sorry for the caps lock, just want other riders and their families to see that we have an option)
We are not locals to the area. We ride Motocross at the local track. We have never found a pizzeria that will deliver to the specific address. However! That changed this weekend. The pizza and wings were EXCEPTIONAL. I said extra crispy, extra saucy on the wings, and man did they follow the instructions!

We will DEFINITELY be ordering from here again at the next event! I ordered online, and it said 75 min. Which is fine. The food was hot, and right on point.

The delivery driver was super awesome to my husband, and was pleased to say that The track was now in there delivery radius.

Thank you again fir the great food, prompt service and awesome driver!

J R

Best spaghetti in town!

Brendalee Schultz

Crust was light and fluffy, crunchy in the right places. Needed much more cheese. Nick's daughter is beautiful, just like her dad.

Loading...