They wanted to charge a high surcharge because we wanted reservations for 14 for dinner and drinks. No way! Never again. I know of no other Batavia restaurant that tries such a thing. ?
Cheryl Kowalik
Very disappointing how 14 people wanted to get together for dinner and go to a restaurant we went to precovid. This restaurant was going to charge us a party charge of normally $75 but would only charge us $50 instead. We said no thank you and taking our business to a place that will not charge us for getting together for dinner.
Lynn Kubik Szott
Very disappointed. Was told the fish was amazing and I wouldn’t even say that it was good.
Angel Berry
We had an amazing experience here! Music, food and service was impeccable. Thank you Valerie for an awesome first time experience! We will be back for sure!
Christina H
Very good seafood!! Service is pretty good as well. Sometimes it's a little busy if you're looking for drinks with dinner but still a very good spot!
Josh Jurs
Absolutely amazing if I could have given it 10 Stars I would. By far the best seafood I've ever had in New York state.
Richard Puccio
Very good food.pleasant, hospitable, knowledgeableEmployees.
Bonnie Moser
Was pleasantly surprised on every detail including the back ground music , the food was fantastic and decently priced , our server was lovely , she answered any question we or other guest had and was quick about service as well , my only complaint would be the back room could use a little dimming it was a bit bright for a dinner that was as elegant as it was .
Mark Moser
Small place with great friendly staff. Food was perfect especially bacon jam scallops. Batavias secret seafood place.
RN4VETS NY
What a secret place this is!! Great fish fry and the seafood chowder is delicious! Don’t judge this place from the outside.
Wonderful off the beaten path gem in Batavia. Food was fantastic and well presented. Staff was awesome and so was the service. Highly recommend and will be back!
Liz T
Awesome local spot. Great food. Well executed menu. Very reasonable prices. Good selection. Seafood heavy but good choices for non seafood eaters. Dive bar feel with foodie execution. Decent wine and cocktail options too.
Mike Will
An absolute gem. Well done Fish Tails for aspiring to be better and delivering.
Dave Stanley
I can't believe I've never been here before. A great find in the heart of Batavia. The food is amazing, the service is great and even the other customers are amazingly friendly. This is the best seafood I've had in Batavia and is easily at the top tier of western New York. Come in and sit outside and enjoy the breeze and atmosphere.
Cynthia Marie Dolores Appleton
super service! great food! the seafood chowder is delish! all with live music! perfect combination.
They wanted to charge a high surcharge because we wanted reservations for 14 for dinner and drinks. No way! Never again. I know of no other Batavia restaurant that tries such a thing. ?
Very disappointing how 14 people wanted to get together for dinner and go to a restaurant we went to precovid. This restaurant was going to charge us a party charge of normally $75 but would only charge us $50 instead. We said no thank you and taking our business to a place that will not charge us for getting together for dinner.
Very disappointed. Was told the fish was amazing and I wouldn’t even say that it was good.
We had an amazing experience here! Music, food and service was impeccable. Thank you Valerie for an awesome first time experience! We will be back for sure!
Very good seafood!! Service is pretty good as well. Sometimes it's a little busy if you're looking for drinks with dinner but still a very good spot!
Absolutely amazing if I could have given it 10 Stars I would. By far the best seafood I've ever had in New York state.
Very good food.pleasant, hospitable, knowledgeableEmployees.
Was pleasantly surprised on every detail including the back ground music , the food was fantastic and decently priced , our server was lovely , she answered any question we or other guest had and was quick about service as well , my only complaint would be the back room could use a little dimming it was a bit bright for a dinner that was as elegant as it was .
Small place with great friendly staff. Food was perfect especially bacon jam scallops. Batavias secret seafood place.
What a secret place this is!! Great fish fry and the seafood chowder is delicious! Don’t judge this place from the outside.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wonderful off the beaten path gem in Batavia. Food was fantastic and well presented. Staff was awesome and so was the service. Highly recommend and will be back!
Awesome local spot. Great food. Well executed menu. Very reasonable prices. Good selection. Seafood heavy but good choices for non seafood eaters. Dive bar feel with foodie execution. Decent wine and cocktail options too.
An absolute gem. Well done Fish Tails for aspiring to be better and delivering.
I can't believe I've never been here before. A great find in the heart of Batavia. The food is amazing, the service is great and even the other customers are amazingly friendly. This is the best seafood I've had in Batavia and is easily at the top tier of western New York. Come in and sit outside and enjoy the breeze and atmosphere.
super service! great food! the seafood chowder is delish! all with live music! perfect combination.
Loading...