Coming back to Batavia we ended up getting Matty's because Matty's used to be my mother's favorite pizza before we moved out of state. 1st... the guy at the counter was VERY friendly and we talked about the pizza shops back in the day and got some Matty's history. 2nd, the place it is located ( Eli Fish Brewing Co ) is soooo spacious with friendly workers. 3rd...the pizza...oh my gosh! So yummy! Crust not too thick but not thin either. Cooked perfectly. We got a large cheese, pepperoni and mushroom. Perfect amount of cheese, large pepperoni and those thick mushrooms. Toppings were plenty. We ordered at the pizza counter within Eli's.and it didn't take very long at all. Totally recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abi Ston
Ordered thru doordash and arrived in 20mins me and my husband were surprised but the large pepperoni pizza was delicious we will definitely order again and next will get the pizza and wings :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pete
This is My first time ever ordering and trying Mattys Pizza. I moved near the area about a year ago and I usually order pizza from 151 Pizza which is pretty good but I wanted to try something different so I ordered a large one topping cup and char pepperoni from Mattys. Only took 15 minutes to make which is great but for some reason the cheese just had a weird taste/texture. The cheese tasted like it was very very cheap cheese. The pepperoni was good The pizza itself with the sauce was good but that cheese, I just can get past it... There was something about it, It tastes like skim milk Aldi's shredded cheese. Would I go back to try it again? probably not, The pizza itself 1-10 I'd give it a 5.9.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Joseph Harper
I ordered a 10” Supreme pizza through DoorDash but was delivered a Pepperoni its all on this restaurant because of my bad experience first time ordering from here is this what they do to Doordash customers or is it just me
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Supreme
Katie Keedy
Pretty gross that someone thought this was acceptable. Not one pepperoni was edible; all burnt to heck.
Tim Nickels
Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.
Sean Maloney
Pizza is good, definitely above average! Medium wings were on the salty side (go figure since they want you to drink at Eli Fish) but overall not bad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Justanother Googleaccount
Paid 75 dollars for 2 pizzas and 2 apps. Not worth the $$. Go somewhere else or just get some red barron...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Diana
OMG, are you guys from NYC? I came here three years ago and couldn't find a pizzaria I liked. Matty's Pizza is literally the very best pizza here in Batavia, it tastes like NYC pizza. I tried every pizzeria in Batavia and you guys are the very best here. I mean, I've waited 3 whole years to find a pizzaria that actually tastes good, no lie! Your pizza has good mozzarella cheese and I'm allergic to immitation cheese. Also, the sauce has seasoning on it and that's important. The bottom of the pizza is not burnt nor does it have that nasty residue in the bottom. I didn't struggle eating the pizza either. I just had to take time out writing this well deserved excellent review of you. A diamond in the rough! Will definitely buy again & recommend to anybody I know. Great job!
OMG, are you guys from NYC? I came here three years ago and couldn't find a pizzaria I liked. Matty's Pizza is literally the very best pizza here in Batavia, it tastes like NYC pizza. I tried every pizzeria in Batavia and you guys are the very best here. I mean, I've waited 3 whole years to find a pizzaria that actually tastes good, no lie! Your pizza has good mozzarella cheese and I'm allergic to immitation cheese. Also, the sauce has seasoning on it and that's important. The bottom of the pizza is not burnt nor does it have that nasty residue in the bottom. I didn't struggle eating the pizza either. I just had to take time out writing this well deserved excellent review of you. A diamond in the rough! Will definitely buy again & recommend to anybody I know. Great job!
ANGELO SO
Great pizzas ? and very delicious ?
John Pelton
Best buffalo chicken pizza ever! I loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kathleen Kozlowski
One of the best pizza's I've ever had!! They are a must try with a big selection of pizzas. They have become our works #1 pizza place!!
Sonya Zielinski
Absolutely the best pizza I ever had!!! Will definitely be ordering from there again.
This is great pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Coming back to Batavia we ended up getting Matty's because Matty's used to be my mother's favorite pizza before we moved out of state. 1st... the guy at the counter was VERY friendly and we talked about the pizza shops back in the day and got some Matty's history. 2nd, the place it is located ( Eli Fish Brewing Co ) is soooo spacious with friendly workers. 3rd...the pizza...oh my gosh! So yummy! Crust not too thick but not thin either. Cooked perfectly. We got a large cheese, pepperoni and mushroom. Perfect amount of cheese, large pepperoni and those thick mushrooms. Toppings were plenty. We ordered at the pizza counter within Eli's.and it didn't take very long at all. Totally recommend it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered thru doordash and arrived in 20mins me and my husband were surprised but the large pepperoni pizza was delicious we will definitely order again and next will get the pizza and wings :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is My first time ever ordering and trying Mattys Pizza. I moved near the area about a year ago and I usually order pizza from 151 Pizza which is pretty good but I wanted to try something different so I ordered a large one topping cup and char pepperoni from Mattys. Only took 15 minutes to make which is great but for some reason the cheese just had a weird taste/texture. The cheese tasted like it was very very cheap cheese. The pepperoni was good The pizza itself with the sauce was good but that cheese, I just can get past it... There was something about it, It tastes like skim milk Aldi's shredded cheese. Would I go back to try it again? probably not, The pizza itself 1-10 I'd give it a 5.9.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
I ordered a 10” Supreme pizza through DoorDash but was delivered a Pepperoni its all on this restaurant because of my bad experience first time ordering from here is this what they do to Doordash customers or is it just me
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Supreme
Pretty gross that someone thought this was acceptable. Not one pepperoni was edible; all burnt to heck.
Best Pizza around hands down. We've had every slice from every joint around Genesee County. If you haven't tried Mattys, do yourself a favor and order one from them. You won't be disappointed.
Pizza is good, definitely above average! Medium wings were on the salty side (go figure since they want you to drink at Eli Fish) but overall not bad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Paid 75 dollars for 2 pizzas and 2 apps. Not worth the $$. Go somewhere else or just get some red barron...
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
OMG, are you guys from NYC? I came here three years ago and couldn't find a pizzaria I liked. Matty's Pizza is literally the very best pizza here in Batavia, it tastes like NYC pizza. I tried every pizzeria in Batavia and you guys are the very best here. I mean, I've waited 3 whole years to find a pizzaria that actually tastes good, no lie! Your pizza has good mozzarella cheese and I'm allergic to immitation cheese. Also, the sauce has seasoning on it and that's important. The bottom of the pizza is not burnt nor does it have that nasty residue in the bottom. I didn't struggle eating the pizza either. I just had to take time out writing this well deserved excellent review of you. A diamond in the rough! Will definitely buy again & recommend to anybody I know. Great job!
Restaurantji Recommends
OMG, are you guys from NYC? I came here three years ago and couldn't find a pizzaria I liked. Matty's Pizza is literally the very best pizza here in Batavia, it tastes like NYC pizza. I tried every pizzeria in Batavia and you guys are the very best here. I mean, I've waited 3 whole years to find a pizzaria that actually tastes good, no lie! Your pizza has good mozzarella cheese and I'm allergic to immitation cheese. Also, the sauce has seasoning on it and that's important. The bottom of the pizza is not burnt nor does it have that nasty residue in the bottom. I didn't struggle eating the pizza either. I just had to take time out writing this well deserved excellent review of you. A diamond in the rough! Will definitely buy again & recommend to anybody I know. Great job!
Great pizzas ? and very delicious ?
Best buffalo chicken pizza ever! I loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the best pizza's I've ever had!! They are a must try with a big selection of pizzas. They have become our works #1 pizza place!!
Absolutely the best pizza I ever had!!! Will definitely be ordering from there again.
Loading...