Stumbled upon this while driving ... delicious pizza!!!
Brian BAtes
This place is a hidden gem. Damn good Sicilian slice. Good crust. Flavorful sauce and good cheese. Definitely check this place out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Dark Chylde
If I could give 10 stars I would. The whole staff here is beyond amazing. They make my mother in law feel so special every time we come in, and the food is always hot and fresh. Full of flavor but not grease.Wheelchair accessibility: My Mother in Law is in a wheelchair after having a stroke, and the Men there all rally around here whenever we're there. They move tables, constantly check if she needs anything, will do table service for her, hold the door when going in or out, even helping her into an Uber.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Donna Caswell
I have lived in Bay Shore my entire life, and I just found this hidden Gem! Orders for take out never disappoints! Best food and service! When I ask for thin crust pizza , it is thin , crispy and oh my gosh, Best pizza ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Steiner
Ordered an XL Garbage pie and delivered is something totally different from past orders. The meat Garbage pie was more vegetables than meat. $29.95 for thin crust, burnt onions and under cooked green peppers and barely any meat and not able to be cut with a sharp knife. Not to mention the unprofessional way the phone was answered, yelling could be heard. Amore's quality is going down hill. When the delivery person called the store they were argumentative, stating it was what I ordered.I won't be ordering again. Wish I could post a picture of the pie today verses the same pie ordered 12/22, totally different. Wish I could give zero stars! The owner is just as rude cursing us out over the phone because of this review. I guess he can't handle the truth about the business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Gary B.
My girlfriend and I (repeat customers) ordered a $40 'garbage pie' and called to speak to someone because we werent satisfied and got the garbage owner. He told me to get lost and "go to Joe's" from now on (we will) or the Pie at Salvatore's, The Slice etc. there are quite a few places to get a pizza in Bayshore and not have to deal with low IQ and attitude. Your food sucks "amore" and so does your punkass owner who needs to hang up his phone like a pussy rather than talk out a simple business dispute like a man.
Raza Haider
Dont go to this place, they were cursing a disable person when i went there , these people are not humans and they were threatening that poor lady and all those racist discriminatory comments.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Holly
Best pizza place in the area hands
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Coral Jones
Best Blue Cheese on this side of Earth.
Jeanne Landolfi
I ordered the 14" garbage pie expecting it to be a small version of the vegetable garbage pie because I am allergic to dairy. It was missing the spinach, broccoli, and eggplant. It had pepperoni and sausage. This was a phone order so I ate it, but I am disappointed. I will not be ordering from this restaurant again. They are not reliable. Also, the spaghetti sauce was very little and needed to use more than what was given. These meals were not worth the cost.
I ordered by phone, I was waiting for for my order to be delivered. I got charged! I call and they told me they never received my order. I have to go there and show proof. They did not compromise, they did nothing. The big question is who changed my card and there my money was going to. One thing I can say about Sketchy people in Amore Pizza!
Service: 1
Anthony J.
I went there tonight at about 5:30PM to order a few pizza pies for my 23 students, to bless them with a holiday pizza party to no avail. I stood there in front of about 5 workers who basically ignored my presence for about a good 5-10 minutes. They saw me, and most of them glanced into my face, but never asked me what I needed! So I looked at my wrist watch, turned, and left to go to Pizzaiola in N. Babylon, which is more near the Elementary School where I teach. It costed more, but the quality of food, respect, and honor of my soon ending career as a 31 year veteran teacher is emphatically appreciated!
Tiffany J.
These guys are the best. We had a small pizza party for my son last night and they could not have been more welcoming or accommodating. They even set up a table for us with a tablecloth and made the kids feel super special. And the pizza and garlic knots were absolutely delicious. This is a place that feels like a neighborhood staple with folks who care.
Rob Sep
Great service, great guys! Had a ziti slice with three garlic knots and two pepperoni bites. Thank You."AMORE"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
Frank Howard
Traditional Pizza place. Love there Philly cheese steak pie. ❤️❤️
Stumbled upon this while driving ... delicious pizza!!!
This place is a hidden gem. Damn good Sicilian slice. Good crust. Flavorful sauce and good cheese. Definitely check this place out.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Cheese Pizza
If I could give 10 stars I would. The whole staff here is beyond amazing. They make my mother in law feel so special every time we come in, and the food is always hot and fresh. Full of flavor but not grease.Wheelchair accessibility: My Mother in Law is in a wheelchair after having a stroke, and the Men there all rally around here whenever we're there. They move tables, constantly check if she needs anything, will do table service for her, hold the door when going in or out, even helping her into an Uber.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
I have lived in Bay Shore my entire life, and I just found this hidden Gem! Orders for take out never disappoints! Best food and service! When I ask for thin crust pizza , it is thin , crispy and oh my gosh, Best pizza ever!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered an XL Garbage pie and delivered is something totally different from past orders. The meat Garbage pie was more vegetables than meat. $29.95 for thin crust, burnt onions and under cooked green peppers and barely any meat and not able to be cut with a sharp knife. Not to mention the unprofessional way the phone was answered, yelling could be heard. Amore's quality is going down hill. When the delivery person called the store they were argumentative, stating it was what I ordered.I won't be ordering again. Wish I could post a picture of the pie today verses the same pie ordered 12/22, totally different. Wish I could give zero stars! The owner is just as rude cursing us out over the phone because of this review. I guess he can't handle the truth about the business.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
My girlfriend and I (repeat customers) ordered a $40 'garbage pie' and called to speak to someone because we werent satisfied and got the garbage owner. He told me to get lost and "go to Joe's" from now on (we will) or the Pie at Salvatore's, The Slice etc. there are quite a few places to get a pizza in Bayshore and not have to deal with low IQ and attitude. Your food sucks "amore" and so does your punkass owner who needs to hang up his phone like a pussy rather than talk out a simple business dispute like a man.
Dont go to this place, they were cursing a disable person when i went there , these people are not humans and they were threatening that poor lady and all those racist discriminatory comments.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best pizza place in the area hands
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Best Blue Cheese on this side of Earth.
I ordered the 14" garbage pie expecting it to be a small version of the vegetable garbage pie because I am allergic to dairy. It was missing the spinach, broccoli, and eggplant. It had pepperoni and sausage. This was a phone order so I ate it, but I am disappointed. I will not be ordering from this restaurant again. They are not reliable. Also, the spaghetti sauce was very little and needed to use more than what was given. These meals were not worth the cost.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered by phone, I was waiting for for my order to be delivered. I got charged! I call and they told me they never received my order. I have to go there and show proof. They did not compromise, they did nothing. The big question is who changed my card and there my money was going to. One thing I can say about Sketchy people in Amore Pizza!
Service: 1
I went there tonight at about 5:30PM to order a few pizza pies for my 23 students, to bless them with a holiday pizza party to no avail. I stood there in front of about 5 workers who basically ignored my presence for about a good 5-10 minutes. They saw me, and most of them glanced into my face, but never asked me what I needed! So I looked at my wrist watch, turned, and left to go to Pizzaiola in N. Babylon, which is more near the Elementary School where I teach. It costed more, but the quality of food, respect, and honor of my soon ending career as a 31 year veteran teacher is emphatically appreciated!
These guys are the best. We had a small pizza party for my son last night and they could not have been more welcoming or accommodating. They even set up a table for us with a tablecloth and made the kids feel super special. And the pizza and garlic knots were absolutely delicious. This is a place that feels like a neighborhood staple with folks who care.
Great service, great guys! Had a ziti slice with three garlic knots and two pepperoni bites. Thank You."AMORE"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch
Traditional Pizza place. Love there Philly cheese steak pie. ❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5