What are you looking for?

Restaurants in Bay Shore

The Best Restaurants

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore 8 Third Ave, Bay Shore
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore
Italian

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

So nice to have Chef Gary come out to the table to check on things. Had relatives from out of town visiting. They were surprised by the portions. BIG! Great...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb285 Reviews4.7
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails 150 E Main St, Bay Shore
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
American • $$$

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails

150 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

It Started with a joyful greeting from the hostess ! Our waitress Emily was very knowledgeable about the food and offered some great recommendations. The food...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb361 Reviews4.6
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge
Japanese • $$

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went for dinner. Had udon noodles w chicken=good. Wife had pineapple fried rice w shrimp & chicken= insipid, hardly any pineapple & chicken dry. Only...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb146 Reviews4.7
Tula Kitchen 41 E Main St, Bay Shore
Tula Kitchen
Fine Dining • $$

Tula Kitchen

41 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

It was my first time there last night and it was perfect! The hostess and staff were so personable and attentive. We didn’t have a reservation, and they...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb237 Reviews4.5
The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St, Bay Shore
The Pie at Salvatore's
Pizza • $$

The Pie at Salvatore's

120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Best thin crust pizza!! We had the Supreme which is amazing! Prosciutto, Pepperoni, sausage are incredibly delish! Their beer selection is great!! Love this...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb145 Reviews4.6
Amanda's Bakery Co. 184 W Main St, Bay Shore
Amanda's Bakery Co.
Custom Cakes

Amanda's Bakery Co.

184 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Amazing service !!! Thank you Amanda for creating an incredible and delicious cake with Army logo! Also thanking Kayla, Hannah and Natalie!!! You girls are the...

  • Delivery
  • Superb79 Reviews4.8
ITA Kitchen 45 W Main St, Bay Shore
ITA Kitchen
Pizza

ITA Kitchen

45 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went to ITA for Christmas Eve. My family was worried about going out during the Covid spike and the Host assured me that he would put us in a far off corner...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb341 Reviews4.4
Bella Vie 240 W Main St, Bay Shore
Bella Vie
Mediterranean

Bella Vie

240 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Just a fantastic place to have a great dinner or lunch. I really like the view of the pond and wildlife. Dinner was excellent as well as the service. Very...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb302 Reviews4.4
Pecado Mexican 49 W Main St, Bay Shore
Pecado Mexican
Mexican

Pecado Mexican

49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went there in NYD for mine and my father’s birthday and got treated with the utmost respect. The drinks were amazing and the food was even better. Can’t...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb117 Reviews4.6
FIRE ISLAND VINES (FIV) 17 E Main St, Bay Shore
FIRE ISLAND VINES (FIV)
Wine Bar

FIRE ISLAND VINES (FIV)

17 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Place has great atmosphere, service and drinks! Don't let the name fool you because they serve plenty of food, wine and beer ! Will definitely be coming...

  • Delivery
  • Superb61 Reviews4.9
Tullulah's 12 4th Ave, Bay Shore
Tullulah's
Tapas/Small Plates • $$

Tullulah's

12 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Food was great. The aranchini and scallops were especially delicious. Surprisingly, the dining area was pretty empty. The only thing I would nitpick would be...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb292 Reviews4.4
Captree State Park 3500 Ocean Pkwy, Bay Shore
Captree State Park
Seafood

Captree State Park

3500 Ocean Pkwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Cycled from Jones Beach to the marina at Captree... nice ride and nice scenery, right at sunset... but chilly that evening but that's to be expected in...

  • Delivery
  • Superb79 Reviews4.7
Savor Eatery 631 E Main St, Bay Shore
Savor Eatery
Salad

Savor Eatery

631 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I’ve gotten their food on multiple occasions and every single time it is incredibly delicious. The kitchen and restaurant are very clean and the food tastes...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb101 Reviews4.6
Lakehouse 135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore
Lakehouse
New American • $$$

Lakehouse

135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Wanted to treat an elderly friend from Manhattan to a drive and a memorable holiday lunch...chose The LakeHouse based on reviews and it was perfect! They...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb551 Reviews4.3
The Tap Room - Bay Shore 44 E Main St #46, Bay Shore
The Tap Room - Bay Shore
Sports Bar • $$

The Tap Room - Bay Shore

44 E Main St #46, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Been there twice great both times. 1st off Prices are reasonable. There was 5 of us we ordered three apps, each had two beers and a burger or sandwich the...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb116 Reviews4.5
JBBQ & Shabu Shabu 11 E Main St, Bay Shore
JBBQ & Shabu Shabu
Japanese

JBBQ & Shabu Shabu

11 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Can't say enough good things about this place! Reasonable prices and really great food. The BBQ and Hot Pot is a 10/10. Highly recommend for group outing...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb110 Reviews4.5
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails 70 E Main St, Bay Shore
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
Mexican • $$

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

70 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I hosted a party here and wow, did everyone deliver. The staff were very kind, patient, and helpful. Shout out to the hostess, our waiter John, and the staff...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb340 Reviews4.3
Mustang Sally's 186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
Mustang Sally's
Bar & Grill

Mustang Sally's

186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Main menu offers: Reuben, Cheese Burger, Fish and Chips, Chicken Sandwich, Chicken Tenders w/ Fries. - All $10Appetizers: Mozzarella Sticks, Fries, Jalapeno...

  • Delivery
  • Superb51 Reviews4.8
Leggio's Deli 305 4th Ave, Bay Shore
Leggio's Deli
Deli • $

Leggio's Deli

305 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Leggio's Deli is the best old school deli around! I'm happy to say that my family has been going there for over 50 years! Joey & Louie are such...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb90 Reviews4.5
Fratelli Pizzeria 553 E Main St, Bay Shore
Fratelli Pizzeria
Pizza • $$

Fratelli Pizzeria

553 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Best Italian food on Long Island! Can always count on fresh, great food. They don't skimp on quality or quantity. You can't get better food in fancy,...

  • Take-Out
  • Drive-Through
  • Superb130 Reviews4.4
La cubanita 1831 5th Ave, Bay Shore
La cubanita
Deli • $

La cubanita

1831 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I travel from Manhattan for their chicken sandwich. Absolutely ridiculous. I've never eaten something so delicious, from Jamaican patties to potato balls...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb108 Reviews4.4
Whalers 124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore
Whalers
New American • $$$

Whalers

124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Meeting our son’s new in laws to be. Wonderful day, perfect in every way. Delicious food, great service and terrific ambiance. Would definitely come back...

  • Delivery
  • Good465 Reviews4.2
Salt & Barrel 61 W Main St, Bay Shore
Salt & Barrel
Seafood • $$$

Salt & Barrel

61 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

It was a perfect meal with exceptional service. My husband said that was the best burger he has ever had on the Island. He is not a big fry guy but loved these...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good435 Reviews4.2
Union Blvd Deli 2116 Union Blvd, Bay Shore
Union Blvd Deli
Spanish

Union Blvd Deli

2116 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

This by far my favorite deli in the world !!! Owners Eddie & Daisy are such awesome . I got them to cater my babyshower and the food was out of this world...

  • Delivery
  • Superb92 Reviews4.4
Buseto Pizza 1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Buseto Pizza
Pizza • $

Buseto Pizza

1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Great pizzeria. Their heroes and dinners are top notch. I've had 2 parties catered by them and the food and delivery were top notch. I highly recommend...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb128 Reviews4.3
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks Inc. 1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks Inc.
Food Trucks • $

Chiddy's Cheesesteaks Inc.

1851 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Incredibly delicious!! We had the tacos and ohhhh the flavors, textures and freshness is amazing! Price is good and quality food i cannot replicate! Amazing...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb124 Reviews4.3
Toast Coffeehouse 9 S Park Ave, Bay Shore
Toast Coffeehouse
Breakfast • $$

Toast Coffeehouse

9 S Park Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

My sweet friends threw me a baby sprinkle here this month. We were given a separate area, which we greatly appreciated for our group of 11. I mean, pregnancy...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good258 Reviews4.2
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar 12 E Main St, Bay Shore
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar
Cocktail Bar • $$

Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar

12 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Delicious food! Great drinks! (Which have improved since the last time my fiance and i dined here! Vibes were popping here too for a Saturday afternoon! Def...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good216 Reviews4.2
Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant 53 E Main St, Bay Shore
Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant
Sushi Bar • $$

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant

53 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

We have been to Aji many times and we will continue to go back. We have had Charlie as our server/bartender and he is amazing. The food is delicious whether...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good191 Reviews4.2
Rock City Dogs 3 E Main St, Bay Shore
Rock City Dogs
Bar & Grill

Rock City Dogs

3 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I came here not happy,not hungry even know it was my Bday celeb. Owner welcomed us. Great food! Great staff! Everything on the menu is delicous! Came here with...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb92 Reviews4.3

American Restaurants

American in Bay Shore
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails 150 E Main St, Bay Shore
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
American • $$$

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails

150 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

It Started with a joyful greeting from the hostess ! Our waitress Emily was very knowledgeable about the food and offered some great recommendations. The food...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb361 Reviews4.6
Peter Pan Diner 999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Peter Pan Diner
American • $$

Peter Pan Diner

999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

We love Peter Pan diner. The food and service is always great and it comes with a smile. It is not inexpensive but it worth the money every once in a while....

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good217 Reviews4.1
Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille 29 E Main St, Bay Shore
Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille
American • $$

Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille

29 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Solid place to get some good bar food and watch a game. Didn't go inside to check their beer selection, but the beers on tap outside were Bud Light and a...

  • Take-Out
  • Drive-Through
  • Good190 Reviews3.8

Pizza Restaurants

Pizza in Bay Shore
The Pie at Salvatore's 120 E Main St, Bay Shore
The Pie at Salvatore's
Pizza • $$

The Pie at Salvatore's

120 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Best thin crust pizza!! We had the Supreme which is amazing! Prosciutto, Pepperoni, sausage are incredibly delish! Their beer selection is great!! Love this...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb145 Reviews4.6
ITA Kitchen 45 W Main St, Bay Shore
ITA Kitchen
Pizza

ITA Kitchen

45 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went to ITA for Christmas Eve. My family was worried about going out during the Covid spike and the Host assured me that he would put us in a far off corner...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb341 Reviews4.4
Fratelli Pizzeria 553 E Main St, Bay Shore
Fratelli Pizzeria
Pizza • $$

Fratelli Pizzeria

553 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Best Italian food on Long Island! Can always count on fresh, great food. They don't skimp on quality or quantity. You can't get better food in fancy,...

  • Take-Out
  • Drive-Through
  • Superb130 Reviews4.4

Mexican Restaurants

Mexican in Bay Shore
Pecado Mexican 49 W Main St, Bay Shore
Pecado Mexican
Mexican

Pecado Mexican

49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went there in NYD for mine and my father’s birthday and got treated with the utmost respect. The drinks were amazing and the food was even better. Can’t...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb117 Reviews4.6
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails 70 E Main St, Bay Shore
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails
Mexican • $$

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

70 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I hosted a party here and wow, did everyone deliver. The staff were very kind, patient, and helpful. Shout out to the hostess, our waiter John, and the staff...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb340 Reviews4.3
Taco Bell 1701 Sunrise Hwy FC-6, Bay Shore
Taco Bell
Mexican • $

Taco Bell

1701 Sunrise Hwy FC-6, Bay Shore, NY 11706

  • Drive-Through
  • Delivery
  • Good24 Reviews3.7

Chinese Restaurants

Chinese in Bay Shore
Number 1 Chinese Kitchen 2102 Union Blvd, Bay Shore
Number 1 Chinese Kitchen
Chinese • $

Number 1 Chinese Kitchen

2102 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

From simple American Chinese food to authentic Chinese food. Just ask and they'll make it. Clean facility. Clean kitchen. Fast friendly service from the...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb49 Reviews4.3
Peking Kitchen 1387 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore
Peking Kitchen
Chinese

Peking Kitchen

1387 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Favorite Chinese food place pork with Chinese vegetable or hot and sour soup are my regulars. I've tried other dishes, just as good. Wish they would take...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good71 Reviews4.2
Food King Chinese Kitchen 182 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
Food King Chinese Kitchen
Chinese • $

Food King Chinese Kitchen

182 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Nothing bad to say! Food is the best Chinese around in this area. Always consistent! And they are always quick with the delivery! Also all employees are always...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good76 Reviews4.1

Seafood Restaurants

Seafood in Bay Shore
Captree State Park 3500 Ocean Pkwy, Bay Shore
Captree State Park
Seafood

Captree State Park

3500 Ocean Pkwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Cycled from Jones Beach to the marina at Captree... nice ride and nice scenery, right at sunset... but chilly that evening but that's to be expected in...

  • Delivery
  • Superb79 Reviews4.7
Salt & Barrel 61 W Main St, Bay Shore
Salt & Barrel
Seafood • $$$

Salt & Barrel

61 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

It was a perfect meal with exceptional service. My husband said that was the best burger he has ever had on the Island. He is not a big fry guy but loved these...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good435 Reviews4.2
Chowder Bar 123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore
Chowder Bar
Seafood • $$

Chowder Bar

123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

My colleague and I stopped in for dinner and could not have been more happy with the Chowder Bar. Cute older establishment with phenomenal food. We shared...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good167 Reviews4.2

Italian Restaurants

Italian in Bay Shore
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore 8 Third Ave, Bay Shore
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore
Italian

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

8 Third Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

So nice to have Chef Gary come out to the table to check on things. Had relatives from out of town visiting. They were surprised by the portions. BIG! Great...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb285 Reviews4.7
The Classic New York Pizza Joint 2042 Sunrise Hwy, N Service Rd, Bay Shore
The Classic New York Pizza Joint
Italian

The Classic New York Pizza Joint

2042 Sunrise Hwy, N Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Just moved out to bay shore a couple weeks ago from New Jersey where I had my favorite local pizza spot. The classic New York pizza joint is exactly what I had...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb54 Reviews4.4
Amore Pizza 2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore
Amore Pizza
Italian • $

Amore Pizza

2110 Union Blvd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Always a great experience at Amore. Food always fresh and delicious. Some of the best garlic knots I ever tasted. Nice specials each day of the week as well. I...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good128 Reviews4.1
Grace Deli 77 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
Grace Deli
Sandwich Shop • $$

Grace Deli

77 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Visited the East Islip location, when I first walked in I had to step over a vacuum cleaner. Three employees behind the counter & no one came out from...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good97 Reviews3.9
The Hero Joint 182 W Main St, Bay Shore
The Hero Joint
Sandwich Shop

The Hero Joint

182 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Whoever Andre is, he is going to go far in life. Super attentive on the phone, accurate, fast order and a pleasure to deal with. Chicken Club was delicious, I...

  • Delivery
  • Good13 Reviews3.9
Subway 1490 5th Ave, Bay Shore
Subway
Sandwich Shop • $

Subway

1490 5th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Ordered an Italian BMT foot long on Ubereats. I’m not sure if I’m hungry tonight but this has been one of the best Subway sandwiches I’ve ever...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good39 Reviews3.8
Fried Chicken & Deli 3 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore
Fried Chicken & Deli
Chicken Wings

Fried Chicken & Deli

3 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Great food. Great prices. The foods are delicious. I’ve had most of the hot dishes here. The fried chicken is right on point. And make sure to get the side...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb12 Reviews4.8
Pollo Peruano 1754 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore
Pollo Peruano
Chicken

Pollo Peruano

1754 Sunrise Hwy South Service Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Loveeee the chafa... Everyone was super nice and helpful for my first time there... There is a good amount of food with each order... The cookies are...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb9 Reviews4.4
It's Just Wings 2020 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
It's Just Wings
Chicken Wings

It's Just Wings

2020 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

These are the nastiest wings I ever had in my life, I ordered a 16 piece lemon pepper hot wing and they sent one order of bland hot wings with curly frys and...

  • Delivery
  • Good3 Reviews3.7

Japanese Restaurants

Japanese in Bay Shore
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge 1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge
Japanese • $$

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went for dinner. Had udon noodles w chicken=good. Wife had pineapple fried rice w shrimp & chicken= insipid, hardly any pineapple & chicken dry. Only...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb146 Reviews4.7
JBBQ & Shabu Shabu 11 E Main St, Bay Shore
JBBQ & Shabu Shabu
Japanese

JBBQ & Shabu Shabu

11 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Can't say enough good things about this place! Reasonable prices and really great food. The BBQ and Hot Pot is a 10/10. Highly recommend for group outing...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb110 Reviews4.5
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi 551 E Main St, Bay Shore
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi
Japanese • $$

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

551 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Went here with my friend who came to celebrated his soon to be born son (Casper) with some crispy duck salad. Did not disappointed me since it wasn't too...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Good127 Reviews4.2
Mustang Sally's 186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore
Mustang Sally's
Bar & Grill

Mustang Sally's

186 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Main menu offers: Reuben, Cheese Burger, Fish and Chips, Chicken Sandwich, Chicken Tenders w/ Fries. - All $10Appetizers: Mozzarella Sticks, Fries, Jalapeno...

  • Delivery
  • Superb51 Reviews4.8
Rock City Dogs 3 E Main St, Bay Shore
Rock City Dogs
Bar & Grill

Rock City Dogs

3 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

I came here not happy,not hungry even know it was my Bday celeb. Owner welcomed us. Great food! Great staff! Everything on the menu is delicous! Came here with...

  • Take-Out
  • Delivery
  • Superb92 Reviews4.3
Veranda at the Long Island Eagle 94 N Clinton Ave, Bay Shore
Veranda at the Long Island Eagle
Bar & Grill • $$

Veranda at the Long Island Eagle

94 N Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706

The Eagle is one of the most fun and welcoming bars around. The crowd is very warm and friendly, and the drinks are well priced, served by attentive, kind...

  • Delivery
  • Good60 Reviews4.1