16 Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Browse menus, reviews and photos of American Restaurants in Bay Shore.

Showing 16 of 20 restaurants

  • Tap Room 44 East Main Street Suite 46, Bay Shore American · $$

    1 Tap Room

    4.7 Superb 378 Reviews

    44 East Main Street Suite 46, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Strawberry Fields Salad with Grilled Shrimp
    • Warm Oreo Brownie with Ice Cream
    • Kona Coffee Crusted Steak & Eggs
    • Carolina Chicken Sandwich

    “Great staff! Hannah makes a great margarita!”

  • Zest 298 West Main Street, Bay Shore American · $

    2 Zest

    4.8 Superb 263 Reviews

    298 West Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Grilled Skirt Steak on Mashed Potatoes with Gorgonzola
    • PB and J Pulled Pork Sandwich
    • Loaded Grilled Cheese Pretzel
    • Buffalo and BBQ Smoked Wings

    “I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.”

  • Peter Pan Diner 999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore American · $$

    3 Peter Pan Diner

    4.4 Superb 330 Reviews

    999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Western Omelet with Home Fries
    • The Breakfast Cheese Scramble
    • Black Forrest Cake Slice
    • Apple Cinnamon Pancakes

    “There are diners and there is Peter Pan in Bay Shore at a level of great heights. My wife and I patiently waited for its reopening and our expectations were above and beyond what we expected. The decor is modern and beautiful, yet it has that warm at-home feel. The Menu consists of a variation of eclectic items that greatly touches the culinary senses with delight. Owners Nick and Peter are often present to greet the customers like old friends and the staff are very friendly, professional and thorough. From breakfast to lunch and dinner we have always enjoyed. And to boot, there is wide variety of beverages to meet all tastes. Thank you for being a part of of our lives, Peter Pan. Looking forward to partaking in your delicious meals for years to come!”

  • Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille 29 East Main Street, Bay Shore American · $$

    4 Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille

    4.3 Superb 243 Reviews

    29 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Funnel Cake Fries with Chocolate & Raspberry Dipping Sauces
    • Texas Toast Grilled Cheese Sandwich
    • Skillet Baked Mac & Cheese
    • Chicken Cutlet Wrap

    “the fish bowls are such a good drinking investment lol !!”

  • Roadtrip 3 East Main Street, Bay Shore Cocktail Bar · $$

    5 Roadtrip

    4.5 Superb 403 Reviews

    3 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “excellent food, the service is awesome. Colleen was excellent. cocktails are awesome. they have unique specials.”

  • Chowder Bar 123 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore Seafood · $$

    6 Chowder Bar

    4.6 Superb 255 Reviews

    123 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Deep Fried Ice Cream Warm Brownie Sundae
    • Open Faced Fish Sandwich Combo
    • Fried Seafood Platter
    • Frozen Lemonade Pie

    “Great cozy little place with the greatest staff and good food. It’s a must try”

  • The Lakehouse 135 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore New American · $$$$

    7 The Lakehouse

    4.4 Superb 793 Reviews

    135 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Crisp Long Island Duck Breast and Crisp Leg Confit
    • Herb-Marinated East Coast Striped Bass Filet
    • Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak & Herb Frites
    • Lake House Flourless Chocolate Cake

    “It was a very nice lunch with friends. The restaurant staff and service was very friendly and we were left to our leisure for dining as there were very few diners there. Weather was a factor for low turn out. We all enjoyed our meal and would absolutely recommend The Lakehouse to others. Thank you.”

  • Whalers 124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore New American · $$$

    8 Whalers

    4.4 Superb 453 Reviews

    124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

    Customers’ favorites

    • Korean Double Fried Chicken Wings
    • Sweet Chili Glazed Calamari
    • New England Clam Chowder
    • Whalers French Fries

    “Love John the bartender. Great food and atmosphere”

  • Tula Kitchen 41 East Main Street, Bay Shore Fine Dining · $$$

    9 Tula Kitchen

    4.4 Superb 325 Reviews

    41 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Sandwich
    • Mediterranean Platter
    • Vegan Tofu Crab Cakes
    • Rockin Vegan Cupcake

    “Delicious cocktails and food! We all had a difficult time deciding on a meal, everything sound so good! Friendly helpful staff, would totally recommend!”

  • Salt & Barrel 61 West Main Street, Bay Shore Seafood · $$$

    10 Salt & Barrel

    4.3 Superb 516 Reviews

    61 West Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet with Vanilla Gelato
    • Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
    • Bigeye Tuna Tartare Avocado
    • New England Clam Chowder

    “My Husband and I stumble across this place tonight and couldn’t be happier about it! From the moment we walked through the door on a busy Saturday night at 7:00pm we walk in simply based on a great name! The hostess Deanna was lovely and welcoming we were able to sit right away! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the drinks!! But the star of the show was the staff our waitress Emily was the best we have ever had! Just the right amount of attentive that we never looked for her and always felt taking care up. The busser also did an amazing job never a dirty plate on our table. We go out alot and I can’t remember the last time a restaurant covered it all flawlessly Service drinks and food. We have already texted friend excited to bring them here! Can’t wait to come back keep up the amazing work!”

  • Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub 615 East Main Street, Bay Shore Irish Pub · $$

    11 Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

    4.5 Superb 142 Reviews

    615 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Corned Beef Cabbage & Potatoes
    • Fried Mozzarella Squares
    • Dublin Chicken Dippers
    • Honey Mustard Chicken

    “Very good Irish pub with friendly people and live music 👍🏼”

  • Napper Tandy’s 60 East Main Street, Bay Shore Irish Pub · $$

    12 Napper Tandy’s

    4.2 Good 219 Reviews

    60 East Main Street, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Turkey Burger and Fries
    • Key West Fish Sandwich
    • Traditional Reuben
    • Warm Jumbo Pretzel

    “Large bar, big place, lots of tv’s, great space upstairs for private events, cold 🍺 and great food = good times 💫”

  • Le Dock 60 Bay Walk, Bay Shore Seafood · $$$

    13 Le Dock

    4.1 Good 190 Reviews

    60 Bay Walk, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Allegrini Palazzo Della Torre
    • Parmesan-Herb French Fries
    • Chablis Le Chablisienne
    • Blueberry Pancakes

    “You will not find a restaurant on fire Island that is better. From the food, the host, the bartenders, the food aervers. Our waiter Ben is the best in the business. Makes you feel welcome, one of the best waiters I have had in any restaurant experience. If I could give 10 stars to this restaurant, I would.”

  • Chili's Grill & Bar 2020 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore Tex-Mex · $

    14 Chili's Grill & Bar

    4.0 Good 393 Reviews

    2020 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Chicken Crisper with French Fries and Blossom Onions
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Quesadillas
    • Crispy Chicken Crispers Combos
    • Chili's Margarita of the Month

    “Your employee, Samantha in Bayshore was exceptional. She manages more tables than i usually see one waitress handle and did so without seeming rushed. She was personable snd efficient..”

  • Charleys Cheesesteaks 1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore Cheesesteaks · $

    15 Charleys Cheesesteaks

    3.6 Good 76 Reviews

    1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “Best philly steak around 😋🤗 can't beat the price”

  • IHOP 1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore Breakfast · $

    16 IHOP

    3.8 Good 324 Reviews

    1701 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Original Gluten-Friendly Pancake Combo
    • Steak Omelette Pancakes Turkey Bacon
    • Original Buttermilk Pancakes 3 Stack
    • Chocolate Chocolate Chip Pancakes

    “We always had a enjoy ihop in Vernon hill last time we went the waitress name Ramon was very attentive and respectful with taking our order absolutely recommended”

American Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like

  • Waffle House Launches Nationwide Delivery for the First Time

    Waffle House Launches Nationwide Delivery for the First Time

    Waffle House is finally delivering. The iconic 24/7 diner chain has partnered with DoorDash to bring its comfort food to customers' doorsteps across all 2,000-plus locations for the first time in its 70-year history. Customers can now order through Waffle House's website or mobile app, with DoorDash drivers handling fulfillment.