8 Best Seafood Restaurants in Bay Shore

Salt & Barrel Seafood • $$$
61 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet with Vanilla Gelato
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Charred Baby Octopus
Crab Cake Benedict
Tarragon Biscuits
Warm Lobster Roll
Day Boat Scallops
Tuna Tartare
Shrimp Tacos

“We had an awesome server. The food was delicious and beautifully presented. We had 2 appetizers, the mushroom flatbread and burata. Our dinners were awesome also. So many nice things to say. They were both filling and delicious. We had an enjoyable evening and will gladly come back.“

4.3 Superb161 Reviews
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering Seafood • $$$
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Pan Seared Shinnecock Sea Scallops
Linguini with Lobster and Shrimp
Horseradish Crusted Grouper
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
Whole Live Maine Lobster
Broiled Seafood Platter
Grilled Atlantic Salmon
Crispy Fried Calamari
Blackened Tuna
Halibut Dinner

“Husband had seafood platter and was disappointed that it didn't come with pasta.He thought it did last time he ordered.Was celebrating friend's b-day and poor man found it very hard to go up and down steps!!!!!No handicap ♿️ ramp???really?Wheelchair accessibility: Didn't see one!!“

4.2 Good302 Reviews
Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar Seafood • $$
25 Bayview Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Sesame Duck Wings
La Street Corn
Truffle Fries
Street Tacos
Chicken Torta
Tuna Tartare
Yucca Poppers
Cheesy Mac
Calamari
Churros

“Recently went here for a date night with friends. This place is tucked away off the beaten place but truly a hidden gem. Our food was delicious, we had some appetizers which we loved. Lobster roll was to die for. Tacos were flavorful. And drinks were AWESOME!! Live music during dinner was a plus. Can't wait to visit during the warmer months.“

4.4 Superb74 Reviews
Chowder Bar Seafood • $$
123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Deep Fried Ice Cream Warm Brownie Sundae
Open Faced Fish Sandwich Combo
Fried Seafood Platter
Long Island Chowder
Fried Catfish Wrap
Seafood Chowder
Shrimp Cocktail
Grilled Cheese
Seafood Bisque
Fish and Chips

“A hidden gem on Long Island. Everyone should know this place by now.Don't know where to start? Read the menu entirely, and you will know that the chowder soups are the best. Do not skip these soups. You'll want a bowl, not a cup, and even then, you'll be asking for seconds. Don't sleep on the seafood bisque either. Definitely buy some to take home.The appetizers were a bit small, but with the prices of everything these days, you get what you paid for. The crab cakes were delicious and full of crab while other places go heavy on the breading instead.We ended up having the shrimp boat, shrimp po boy, blackened catfish tacos and shrimp salad. Everything was flavorful. Big portions as well.I do believe they are closed for the month of February but I will be going back myself when it opens in March.“

4.4 Superb53 Reviews
Mi Campo Deli Deli •
1389 5th Ave, Bay Shore

“Great fresh hot food.The food is Dominican home style, laid out in big trays.Lots of variety of food to choose from- Rice and beans, spaghetti, chicken baked and stewed, pork chops and ribs, beef stew, fried seafood and shrimp.They have nice creamy deli salads as well - egg, potato and macaroni.The staff is helpful and friendly.The place is nice and clean inside. And brightly lit.It also has few places to sit and eat at the counter.Plenty of parking outside.Their coffee is really good too.I would definitely come back!“

4.3 Superb26 Reviews
The Shack Seafood • $
245 Central Walk, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Wrap
Cheeseburger

“Cannot imagine rating The Shack poorly. Where do you think you are, the Waldorf?? Skilled bartenders pouring great drinks (rocket fuels with the actual correct ingredients, unlike other establishments on the island!) Fun environment with live music on the weekend. Just steps from the beach too! Nothing better on a hot beach day!“

4.3 Superb22 Reviews
Victorio's Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
1205 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pizza with Ricotta
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Sausage Parmigiana
Garlic Knot Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Alfredo
Mushroom Sauce
Chicken Wings
Baked Ravioli
Regular Pizza

“Victorios one, on 27. Absolutely the best Pizza anywhere I have ever been and you always get friendly service.8/5/22 Ordered a chicken Alfredo, absolutely delicious, just can't find tastier food or pizza no matter where I go in the 5 boroughs. Even the fancier, much more expensive restaurants like Maggianos little italy, I find myself returning the food.“

4.3 Superb18 Reviews
Nicky's Clam Bar Seafood • $$
99 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Fried Oysters
Clam Bisque

“Good spot to grab some take out and a drink as you wait for the Fire Island ferry. Friendly service at the take out counter, good comfort food, large selection of seafood fares, and reasonable prices.Parking: Parking is free if you just come to grab a quick order to go, but you'll have to use the paid parking lot if you're staying longer.“

4 Good42 Reviews
Loading...
map Map