21 Best Seafood Restaurants in Bay Shore

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering Seafood • $$
122 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Clams \u0026 Oysters on the Half Shell
Pan Seared Shinnecock Sea Scallops
Linguini with Lobster and Shrimp
Horseradish Crusted Grouper
Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
Whole Live Maine Lobster
Broiled Seafood Platter
Grilled Atlantic Salmon
Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes
Crispy Fried Calamari

“Excellent food and service great memories“

4.4 Superb730 Reviews
Chowder Bar Seafood • $$
123 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Deep Fried Ice Cream Warm Brownie Sundae
Open Faced Fish Sandwich Combo
Fried Seafood Platter
Frozen Lemonade Pie
Long Island Chowder
Fried Catfish Wrap
Shrimp Cocktail
Seafood Chowder
Fish and Chips
Grilled Cheese

“Great cozy little place with the greatest staff and good food. It’s a must try“

4.6 Superb248 Reviews
Fatfish Seafood • $$$
28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

East Coast and West Coast Oysters
Vanilla Bean Créme Brulee
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Whole Maine Lobster
Chargrilled Octopus
Mushroom Gnocchi
Seafood Salad
Lobster Bisque
Lobster Salad
Fish & Chips

“Everything was wonderful! We had a lovely luncheon!“

4.2 Good369 Reviews
Salt & Barrel Seafood • $$$
61 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet with Vanilla Gelato
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Bigeye Tuna Tartare Avocado
New England Clam Chowder
Clams \u0026 Bone Marrow
Charred Baby Octopus
Crab Cake Benedict
Tuna Tartare Tacos
Warm Lobster Roll
Tarragon Biscuits

“My Husband and I stumble across this place tonight and couldn’t be happier about it! From the moment we walked through the door on a busy Saturday night at 7:00pm we walk in simply based on a great name! The hostess Deanna was lovely and welcoming we were able to sit right away! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the drinks!! But the star of the show was the staff our waitress Emily was the best we have ever had! Just the right amount of attentive that we never looked for her and always felt taking care up. The busser also did an amazing job never a dirty plate on our table. We go out alot and I can’t remember the last time a restaurant covered it all flawlessly Service drinks and food. We have already texted friend excited to bring them here! Can’t wait to come back keep up the amazing work!“

4.3 Superb491 Reviews
Ditch - Bay Shore Seafood • $$
25 Bayview Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

BeachFire Chicken Taco
Montauk Lobster Roll
Sesame Tuna Steak
Sesame Duck Wings
Grilled Fish Taco
Jerk Shrimp Taco
Carne Asada Taco
Crispy Calamari
Fried Calamari
Baja Fish Taco

“BEST TACOS ON THE NORTH SHORE. We stumbled into Ditch solely by chance and we are so happy we did. It’s a breath of fresh air for a rather stale Main Street in PJ. Very beachy vibes, feels more south shore LI than snobby north shore which is probably why I love it so much. The menu has a little bit of everything and everything we saw coming out of the kitchen looked amazing. We ordered tacos, five different tacos so we could try a bit of everything. From the perfect corn tortilla to the pineapple toppings, everything was fresh and delicious. The owner Tracy came over to welcome us to his new spot and express his gratitude for giving the new spot a chance. Our server Brennan was working a busy lunch shift mostly solo and he still delivered a top notch experience. Very happy with our new discovery and we can’t wait to go back!“

4.3 Superb148 Reviews
Nicky's Clam Bar Seafood • $$
99 Maple Ave Suite A, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Little Neck Clams on the Half Shell
Fried Whole Belly Top Neck Clams
Sea Scallops Casino
Seafood Cobb Salad
Fried Clam Barge
Fried Calamari
Fried Oysters
Steamed Clams
Lobster Roll
Clam Bisque

“Delicious food, great service and enjoyable atmosphere. Would highly recommend this special gem“

4.2 Good200 Reviews
The Shack Seafood • $
245 Central Walk, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Crispy Chicken Wrap
Grilled Cheese
Cheeseburger
French Fries
Onion Rings

“Always a great time! Great music, decent bar food, and hands down the #1 place to get a Rocket Fuel. Sure, you’ll occasionally have to dodge a few loud, overgrown frat boys, but the awesome bartenders and staff keep the atmosphere fun and make everyone feel welcome.
This place and The Pink House are my too favorite places!“

4.2 Good75 Reviews
El Apretador - Pupusas & Salvadoran Grill Seafood • $$
1531 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Sopa de Mariscos

“Deliciosa toda la comida 🥘 y muy buena atención 😋“

4.1 Good113 Reviews
Le Dock Seafood • $$$
60 Bay Walk, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Allegrini Palazzo Della Torre
Parmesan-Herb French Fries
Chablis Le Chablisienne
Blueberry Pancakes
Coors Lite Bottled
Pizza Margherita
Stuffed Artichoke
Burrata Caprese
Pepperoni Pizza
Fried Calamari

“You will not find a restaurant on fire Island that is better. From the food, the host, the bartenders, the food aervers. Our waiter Ben is the best in the business. Makes you feel welcome, one of the best waiters I have had in any restaurant experience. If I could give 10 stars to this restaurant, I would.“

4 Good190 Reviews
Nicky’s on the Bay Seafood • $$
150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll Sweet Potato Fries and Cole Slaw
West Coast Oysters on the Half Shell
Nicky's Fried Calamari
East Coast Oysters
Sauteed Spinach
Fish and Chips
Seafood Bisque
Clam Chowder
Shrimp Tacos
Seafood

“Went this past week when they just opened up. The food, drinks and atmosphere was great. The staff is very nice. Will definitely be going back.“

3.9 Good447 Reviews
Tiki Joe's at Captree Boat Basin Seafood • $$
3500 Ocean Pkwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Lemonade Blast
Tiki Joe's Burger
Chicken Fingers
Baked Clams
Fish Tacos

“I threw a surprise 60th birthday party here over the weekend and it was wonderful. I am so glad I went with this location for the event. We had an indoor cocktail party, it was awesome. Gorgeous venue with a beautiful view. Kayla, Darlene and Vanessa worked the party and they were the best! Lots of my guests gave me compliments about the staff, on how pleasant and attentive they were. It is stressful to organize an event like this and they really put me at ease and made sure that not only my guests, but also I had a good time. To Elyse & Marybeth whom I booked with, and to the staff who worked the event, if you are reading this - Thank you all SO much! I can't wait to come back.“

3.8 Good79 Reviews
Mi Campo Deli Deli • $
1389 5th Ave, Bay Shore

“This place is home to whoever comes here. The food is home to whoever tastes it. This place is whole heartedly the best place on the island. Everything in one. This place makes the spirit and the soul happy.

Kid-friendliness: Family.“

4.3 Superb66 Reviews
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida Seafood • $$
140 Pine Aire Dr, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Desayuno Tipico Salvadoreno Omelet with Sour Cream Plaintains & Beans
Garlic Lobster Sauce on Lobster and Shrimp
Langosta Con Camarones Y Pan Con Ajo
Picadera De Corvina Con Tostones
Cubetazo Y Mariscos Al La Brasa
Camarones Entomatados Con
Diablo with Garlic Bread
Fried Shrimp Boquita
Salmón A la Plancha
Ceviche De Camaron

“Friendly staff, amazing food!!“

3.7 Good190 Reviews
Victorio's Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
1205 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Pizza with Ricotta
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Sausage Parmigiana
Garlic Knot Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Alfredo
Mushroom Sauce
Chicken Wings
Baked Ravioli
Regular Pizza

“We came from out of town, were exhausted from an incredibly long drive, snd looking for some amazing pizza. We definitely found it. We called in our order when we were about 45 minutes from arriving, and it was ready about 10 mins after we got there. Perfection. It was exactly what we needed. The pizza has a great balance between crust, sauce, and toppings. The Crico's bread was amazing as well. This will definitely be our go to when we come back for our next vacation.“

4.1 Good82 Reviews
Brazas Restaurant & Bar Seafood •
1383 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Mixed Seafood Ceviche over Oysters
Chicken Fingers with French Fries
Sopa de Mondongo Tripe Soup
Oysters on the Half Shell
Papas Fritas French Fries
Fish Sandwich
Fajitas Mixta
Chicken Parm
Garlic Bread
Seafood Soup

“Very good [Original] Muy bueno“

3.4 Good91 Reviews
Seaside Sally’s Shack Bar • $
142 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore
3.4 Good11 Reviews
Xing Wang Kitchen Chinese • $
36 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Lo Mein
Honey Chicken
Crab Rangoon
Fried Wonton
叉燒撈麵
Wonton Soup
Spring Roll

“Whenever I’m in the area, Xing Wong Kitchen is my go-to spot for Chinese takeout. Their fried chicken wings are consistently hot, crispy, and flavorful, and the French fries are always fresh and perfectly cooked. It’s one of those reliable places that never disappoints when you’re craving comfort food. Friendly service, generous portions, and great food keep me coming back every time I’m nearby.“

3.6 Good97 Reviews
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Chicken • $
1825 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

16pc Handcrafted Tenders Family Meal
Popeyes Golden BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Classic Chicken Sandwich Dinner
3pc Handcrafted Tenders Combo
New Honey Lemon Pepper Wings
Popeyes Chicken Sandwiches
New Popeyes Boneless Wings
24pc Nuggets Family Meal
12pc Handcrafted Tenders
20pc Handcrafted Tenders

“I love this place so much every time I go there I enjoy the food and it’s fresh every time I go, Yahir and Aida are the best service there, they treat u with respect and care for ur food, I would 100% go back there again 10/10 Popeyes I’ve been to.“

3.7 Good141 Reviews
Food King Chinese Kitchen Chinese • $
182 Howells Rd, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Vegetable Chow Mein or Chop Suey
Shrimp with Cashew Nuts
Crab Meat Egg Foo Young
Sweet and Sour Chicken
Young Chow Fried Rice
Twice Cooked Chicken
Chicken Fried Rice
House Special Soup
Vegetable Lo Mein
Chicken Lo Mein

“Love this spot been my go to since I was a kid food is always great and service is great my delivery man had been the same guy for as far back as I can remember and he’s always fast to deliver and pleasant to talk to. Been in bayshore my whole life and I will never go anywhere else but here !!!!“

3.4 Good100 Reviews
Sarku Japan Japanese • $
1701 Sunrise Highway Space, 1701 Sunrise Hwy FC-1, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Teriyaki
Beef Bento

“Great food , good service!!!“

3.3 Good109 Reviews
Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Chicken • $
1701 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Classic Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Popeye's Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Popeyes Strawberry Biscuits
Classic Chicken Sandwich
Popies Buttery Biscuit
Red Beans and Rice
Wild Honey Mustard
Popeyes Apple Pie
Corn on the Cob
Fried Chicken

“It’s relle comforting 👌I like it“

3.4 Good185 Reviews

You May Also Like