50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Amityville

“My family and I tried Park Avenue Grill because of their large gluten free menu. The brunch food was excellent. I tried the gluten free churro waffle bites, which were divine, and GF Tuscan eggs Benedict. There was also a decent sized vegan menu! Their specialty lattes were delicious. The atmosphere is cozy inside and they have an outdoor patio! All in all, I'm excited to go back and try more of the menu, maybe dinner next time.Dietary restrictions: They have an extensive gluten free menu and a dedicated space for itKid-friendliness: They had a decent sized kids menu that offers gluten free“

“A small, local bar with a big personality. My companion and I stopped by on a Sunday for the live music. The music was loud and good. Service was good thanks to the overly attentive bartender. We quickly received our drinks. The food? Well, it too a lonnnnng time, but the bartender was apologetic and kept providing us with updates.I ordered a cheeseburger with sweet potato fries and my companion ordered the shrimp tacos. Everything was flavorful and the burger patty was thick and had an excellent char. I would order it again.“

“You would never know that in a little spot in Amityville,LI there is the best pizza in all of America. Seriously, I just had a sweet & shrimp pizza. It as off the hook. You have to try it. Friendly service and music and atmosphere really nice. ????“

“I used to go there back in the 1970s , I was friends with Harry bowman… it was a seafood place back then and just started doing restaurant things, I met him in the marine Corp , I used to go there a lot..best sea food around… I wanted to know what happened to Harry? His friend Steve L. If he’s still around let me know?“

“I had my son take us there for my Birthday.Had a lot of fun. We got there a little early but it started off well the water was right there they we're pulling in on boats and jet skis. The band started to play we ordered drinks and appetizers. The music was good the drinks were good the food was good. It was a great time and will definitely be back. The band that played was burn unit they were really good.!!!“

“I was searching for a Jamaican spot for lunch, but accidentally arrived to this place, I was pressing for time..since it was during a lunch break, so i decided to just get it, and babyyy let me tell you!! The food was excellent, tasteful, and very filling!! They give a decent amount of food for the price!! Both my daughter and I enjoyed the food!! I will be going back!!“

“No matter how I dress or smell like oil from work, they serve me like a king. Kind service with patient employees. I couldn't afford to feed myself on my budget. This humble ownership made it possible for me to sustain a healthy life choice to eat. Life isn't easy, but this place makes one less thing to worry about. If you're looking for the best for a fair price. Encourage your pallet. Dine with me. I'll meet you there and don't you dare take all the rasta pasta lol. Enjoy!“

“Great birthday celebration with great food and a great atmosphere. Loved the hush puppies and coconut shrimp for appetizers. Everyone loved their dinners. Highly recommend the Queen’s Boil and the Seafood Boil. If you like dancing in your seat, this is the place for you. Great music had us moving the entire time. Our server Nicky was awesome! Very personable, friendly, and attentive. He was always there to check in on us. We will definitely be back!!!!“

“Everything was delicious as usual! Grace was our server, she was excellent, Thai Calamari was amazing as well as the Caesar salad, lamb chops, shrimp and surf and turf dinner. Omg almost forgot the garlic bread. We will definitely be back soon. Traveling from Queens definitely worth the trip!!!“

“Saturday evening dinner without a reservation. Walking in, my eyes immediately gravitated to the pictures of the owners and the many celebrities that have eaten and visited there before. The bar area is very nice and large, with TVs playing sports and news. We were greeted, welcomed and seated immediately. The dining area is very large and decorous. The tables large enough to sit us all. My cousin-in-law and his family frequent the restaurant and he practically knows everyone there, so as we sat, we were introduced to the owners and pretty much about a half dozen waiters and other staff members. All were extremely friendly and welcoming. As expected with all family style restaurants, the tables are very close to one another but positioned in a way that still allowed for ample space for you to move and sit comfortably. When we sat, there were hardly any people there, but within an hour it was full of patrons and large families. It was loud, but manageable. The food was unbelievably delicious. I haven't had true traditional family style Italian food in a long time. From the Fried Calamari and cold antipasto appetizers, to our Veal Parmigiana, Penne allá Vodka with Shrimp and prosciutto entrees. Paired with a Cabernet Sauvignon Palermo Napa, I truly enjoyed my meal. I haven't enjoyed food this good in a long time. My girls shared a huge plate of Chicken fingers and fries, and they loved it. I highly recommend anyone who's in the area to dine here. You won't regret it. Thank you for a great meal and patronage.“

“This restaurant is the greatest. The owner and he husband are extremely nice and their food is excellent. Our 2 year old always enjoys the food herself. They have an extensive menu and the dishes are made fresh after you order. The appetizers such as the baby octopus and shrimp wrapped in bacon are on another level. The picaña is also amazing. Most people who are there are regulars. Very relaxing atmosphere as well.“

“My brother moved by this spot like a month ago and I know this place OH SO WELL. ? I’m in Freeport and I haven’t found empanadas as good as Mamma Gina’s. When I tell you the food just hits every time, they’re honestly so consistently great.Parking: It’s a small lot, so just take it slow turning into it.“

“So I came to motor vehicle to drop off my plates and this place is right next door.My friends and I returned next weekend and it is now my new favorite local restaurant. We ordered quite a bunch of different things from the appetizers as well as an Old Bay shrimp boil and a Mussels boil. Calamari was ultra tender. Healthy portions, healthy food and reasonable prices!The walls are alive with tropical fishes swimming as beaming from overhead projectors.Looks like quite a bar too;though we were there for an early dinner.Highly recommend.I don’t understand the negative reviews from a year and more ago. This place only opened six weeks ago.“

“Today was my annual birthday dinner with my family and my little brother. It's both our birthdays so we get to choose where we want to go out to eat with all of us. So I had decided that we should try the New Restaurant Voodoo Crab in Massapequa and let me tell you, it was definitely better than I expected. The food was good, definitely reminds me of hook and reel up in Hicksville or sexy crab in Levittown… Food is definitely comparable and was very good. But What made this experience AMAZING was the impeccable customer service that we received! Lilliana was our waitress and she was wonderful to say the least… If I can give a 10 star rating for service, I would've given them a higher star. But the best part was the owner of the restaurant coming around to make sure everything was well with us. He definitely went above and beyond making sure that we were completely satisfied. And besides singing the regular, happy birthday to us, they surprised us with a couple of free desserts because of our birthdays. Not sure if that's a normal practice but I'd have to save out of the three restaurants mentioned, Voodoo Crab is now my absolute favorite because of the service! If you're looking for a great atmosphere, with great food, very fair pricing, and the best service I've had in a long time… I would highly recommend Voodoo Crab to you! The helpings are definitely bigger than I expected because of the price… Which is a good thing... excellent thing actually… and just overall what a great evening with the family Liliana thank you for making my birthday dinner such a great experience and so much fun, you went above and beyond and Bruce. Thank you for making my birthday just extra special tonight… What a great closing to my birthday weekend! Your restaurant is one of my absolute favorites now! Thank you guys for everything you made this year's birthday 100% aMAZING!“

“If you are looking for the best sushi on Long Island FUKEE is the spot. I have been to my fair share of sushi places and nothing even comes close to the freshness and quality here. Spicy kani rolls, shrimp tempura, spicy tuna rolls, green salad and miso soup are literally the best I’ve ever had in my life. I’ve been on a 60 day cleanse and I’m counting down the days it’s over so I can get FUKEE again. I usually get it a few nights a week and every night it’s better and better if that’s even possible! I cannot say enough great things about this spot!! If you never had it; this is your sign to go, you won’t be disappointed! They have a customer for life, words can’t describe how much I love this place <3“

“I enjoyed my experience there. Food was good, so was service. The price was right. I understand why they charge for uneaten food, it duscourages people from wasting. My wife and i shared several items without issue. My only issue was being expected to tip on top of the 15% gratuity that is automatically added to the bill. Other than that I'm satisfied. I will go back in foreseeable future. Also the mango martinis was hittin.“

“Excellent fish store. Always busy, always very friendly and patient, always a sufficient number of workers. All types of fish prepared and sliced according to your order. There is a restaurant attached that I have never had the opportunity to experience, but it is always spotlessly clean and delicious I am sure. My go to fish store when I am in the area. Plenty of parking in their free parking lot on the side of the store.Vegetarian options: PlentyDietary restrictions: There are optionsParking: Not an issueKid-friendliness: Very friendly to allWheelchair accessibility: It is accessible“

“Enjoyed an excellent steak dinner here. I had the bone in rib eye, and for the table we ordered hash browns, green beans, crispy onions, Brussel sprouts and creamed spinach.The creamed spinach was amazing, along with the rest of the sides.The steak was incredible, cooked to a perfect medium with just the right amount of seasoning, and incredibly tender.It's not cheap at over $800 (including tip) for 5 people, but for the first time I think it was worth the price.“

“My twin daughters' had their Sweet 16 dinner with 20 friends. The food, the atmosphere, the service, the accomodarions....OUTSTANDING!Vegetarian options: The have plenty of vegetarian options.Kid-friendliness: The staff was so welcoming to 20 teenagers for 3 hours! The owner and staff were so very considerate to them all!“

“Been here a bunch of times. Staff is always great.. Quality is always great. Food is always fresh and hot. Cool little vibe. Will continue to be a customer. Love the quesadillas, that’s my go to. My wife loves the shrimpy taco. Fair prices for great products.“

“We love Butera's and have had countless dinners at the restaurants and for delivery. The food is GREAT and we love the atmosphere. Among our favorites are their chicken meatballs and zucchini linguini. They also have great salads and the best pasta on Long Island!“

“Awesome food! Awesome drinks! Great service. Best mojitos and I complain about every place that makes my mojitos. They make them perfectly here every time. The wasabi chips are a wonderful surprise. Lovely ambiance. Definitely try the shrimp pops and sushi platter. We have been there several times and everything is delicious. The General Tso's chicken is slightly spicy and juicy. The dim sum sampler is a great introduction to figuring out what you like. The fried rice with bone marrow was definitely something unique to try. If you are looking for a great dining experience you have to try this place out.“

“I would have given them a 5 but since they got a new person, she's been messing up my orders. Forgetting a lot of ingredients and when I asked for a little salmon with my spicy tuna, she literally put one piece of it. I always pay extra for the salmon add on but she didn't let me explain. Then when my mom wanted peanuts on her order, she put a pinch of it. I'm sorry but I don't know if I can keep going somewhere and constantly telling them what to put on when she keeps looking back at the menu and still forgets. Before her, I had no problem at all! Literally would come here at least 2-3 times a week. Also you guys should put more seasoned tuna bc I always get the number 2. They never have any left and just put the giant onion pieces which I hate.“

“The owners, Mike & Terry are wonderful souls who care deeply about the community they serve, always going above and beyond to support KiDS NEED MoRE and other local causes. They also have absolutely the most delicious food and the staff is so friendly and fast. My wife loves the eggplant. Everytime I come home with Joe's Pizza I am a hero in my house!“

“I was here w about 6 friends from church. It is itallian, and the food I had was good, but be prepared for the prices of their fancy gourmet itallian meals. Their menu was a little limited for basic fair. I had spaghetti and meat balls, and several others had cheese ravioli.Parking: Their small parking lot was full, and apparently it appears to be full most of the time. Several of us had difficulty parking across the street on a busy highway. But it is located on waterfront.“

“I’ve never been to a rodizio restaurant before, and I came up to Long Island to spend Easter and my birthday with my daughter, son-in-law, and grandchildren. It was by far the best experience I’ve ever had in a restaurant, the staff were professional, knowledgeable, efficient , the food is constantly hot. I would rate this restaurant at 10 star! If you’re on Long Island, it’s a must to try!“

“It was my second visit in as many weeks and both visits were extremely enjoyable. Food is delicious and service is fantastic. They are willing to please wether it's substitutions to the menu or a complimentary canola for my sons birthday. Can't wait to go again!“

“This is our “go to “ place for years! Wonderful atmosphere and great food!We recently hosted a party for 50 people and could not have been more pleased with the service and food. The upstairs party room is beautiful and well suited for private events.“

“The lobster tails stuffed with crab meat was soo food and flavorful. I'll be back! However the steamed vegetables were soggy and completely overcooked. I wonder if they were frozen, the waitress said they were fresh didnttast like it!!“

“We planned a Christmas dinner here based on the reviews and the gluten free menu. We were one of two tables in the place. Food was great, service was great and we loved the holiday decorations. I’ve passed this place a million times with no hesitation but it’s definitely worth a visit.“

“Wednesday is pasta night at Giovanni’s on Merrick Rd. in Massapequa. $14.95 for a salad, garlic knots, choice of pasta, coffee and yummy cheesecake. Food was delicious, portions were huge and the service was impeccable. Wine is available for an additional charge. The owner came by before and after our meal to thank us for coming by and to ensure we enjoyed our meal. Highly recommended this neighborhood establishment! Also, I’d like to add on the recommendation of our attentive waitress we ordered a snack pizza as an appetizer for”National Pizza Day”. An exceptionally delicious thin, crispy crust pizza which we all enjoyed.“

“Had dinner here with my gf this past Friday pm.We sat at the bar.Chick parm was one of the best!Gf had shrimp Marsala. She loved it!The bar guys were friendly as well.We really enjoyed Bella Notte and will definitely go back.Teddy is the man!“

“I wanted to express the gratitude & appreciation I have for Jimmy, Armando & their staff. Simply Flawless.We had my daughters Baptism here & it was a perfect experience from the second we walked in. Starting with the attention to detail on how they set things up, to the service & to most importantly how delicious the food was.The Branzino's Family have not only encountered a new life long customer from myself, but everyone at the party will be looking to come back as well.Thank you, Team!“

“Since we went on Easter Sunday we expected a mediocre dining experience ourselves was THE BEST in a long time. The service was exceptional. We were 7 of us. We had lamb chops to Bronzino to sesame tuna to filet minion skewers to a burger. Everything was so delicious prepared to perfection. We will be returning and recommend this restaurant to everyone. The manager Nikko oversaw a wonderful dining experience..... Thank you“

“I’ve been to Lombardo’s pizza a few times. Really really great pizza. Tastes fresh like it came out of the oven. Really good texture. Melts in your mouth. I think the owners name is Anthony. Thank you for making great fresh pizza. Anthony’s bakery and cafe is good too.“

“Absolutely loved this place! The food isn't the best I've ever had but it is freshly prepared. What makes this place is the warm and cozy atmosphere and the excellent service! I love the real fireplace blazing away in the center of this little gem of a restaurant.“

“Food is very good. Prices are what they are like every where else. Lobster Roll very good and had a special on Mondays Lobster Roll only 22$. Think it's over not sure give a call. Service is right up there with the best, and they prepare everything in front of you.“

“Such an underrated gem in Seaford. They have both a nice patio in the back decorated to give all the island vibes as well seating out front on the street side, and of course indoor availability. Service was very personable and quick from drinks through the end of the meal. They certainly don't skimp on the variety of options food wise from starters, quesadillas, tacos to wraps etc. Drink wise I went with the "Mammacita Needs A Margarita" aka a Spicy Marg. Loved the addition of cucumber to the drink to balance it and give it a little refreshing aspect. Food wise we just got a smattering of tacos (Luger, Tropical Lobstahhh, Birria, Al Pastor, Carne Smack Dat Asad and the Cali-Flower) just to try and sample a little of everything. First and foremost, the portions are legit - they don't skimp out so you'll be full or even have extra to take home. Taste wise, my top 3 were the Luger, Lobster and Cali-Flower. All very flavorful and unique in their own way. Definitely will be back once the weather heats up!“

“I ordered from Hawaiian Kitchen on UberEats, so I can't comment on the service or ambiance at the actual restaurant. They were running a BOGO free deal on a few items, so I decided to order two of the Hawaiian Grilled Chicken Poke Bowl. The chicken itself wasn't anything special, and was a bit tough if anything. However, the rest of the toppings were pretty good. It was a satisfying meal and seemed healthy overall.“

“Hands down the best pizza place in the area. I tried the others nearby but after trying victors it’s all I will eat. They have a big selection of slices available , I usually get the brick oven pizzetta which is delicious. Their garlic knots are some of the best around. They also have pasta nights and chicken nights where there are specials on those dishes. It can be extremely busy sometimes, but the service is good and the guys behind the counter are all funny and treat you like family. Highly recommend!“

“From start to finish we had a wonderful dinner at Ruth's Chris. We were pleasantly welcomed to the restaurant by the valet even though we had parked our car ourselves. We were seated quickly and immediately were given water and our drink order taken. Our waiter Tyler was so attentive and our food was absolutely delicious!“

“I loved everything about this place! Me and my hubbs had our belated Vday dinner there and everything from the entrance to when we left was wonderful... I highly recommend the green Apple margarita!!! The food was also delicious! Will definitely be back!“

“First time going here, walked in and placed a decent sized order ($110.00) and was told 40 minutes. On the expensive side and long side of wait times for Chinese food, but ok. Wound up waiting 57 minutes for food to come out. They seem to need more help. All that being said, all the food that we ordered was fresh and delicious. On the expensive side for the portion size, but I would definitely go back as well as recommend this place.“

“Delish food,margaritas were delish too!!Steaks and shrimp ceviche was also very good . We also had creme brûlée for dessert ,amazing. We also loved the band that was playing. We will be back. Highly recommended!! we had a great experience!!!“

“I've been to the Margarita's in East Meadow many times, this was my first time at the Merrick branch. The food is similar but the Merrick outpost is much smaller than E.M., with funky decor and (IMHO) better food. I didn't have a rez, got the only empty table as a walk-in. Service was friendly but slow as only one person was serving the whole place plus there was a glitch with our order, but the excellent food and drink quality made up for those issues. We were too early for the Tuesday $3.50 margarita happy hour (starts at 4:00), so shared a half pitcher of house margaritas instead - they were tasty and strong. (Please don't judge me for early alcohol intake, had a hellish morning so needed a nice numbing agent:) My Mole Poblano Enchiladas were fantastic, 3 of them loaded with chunks of chicken and covered with a sublime mole sauce. Partner's Burrito Mojado was made with skirt steak, he said it was delicious as well. The dishes came with yummy rice and beans, and each plate was embellished with a lovely purple orchid.“

“came for lunch while shopping at the outlets. we were seated right away. we got the lobster flatbread along with three kinds of shrimp. they were both delicious along with the mango lemonade. our server was great as well. For a chain restaurant quality was very good.“

“Ordered a catering order for my birthday celebration yesterday and Chicken Au Go Go did not disappoint!! Order came on time, everything was hot and crispy and not greasy! Delicious ! I know prices have gone up everywhere, but it's worth it when the food is perfect!! Thanks Eric !“

“AMAZING...SPOTLESS. CLEAN. BEAUTIFUL..HOMEMADE..MINISTRONE..SOUP.. PASTA. PESATORE.. GRANDMA. PIZZA..I AM. 3rd. GENERATION. OLD..SCHOOL. N.Y. PIZZAMAN...THIS. PLACE..USES..THE. MOST EXPENSIVE. INGREDIENTS .MONEY. CAN..BUY..&.BLEND. IT. ALL. TOGETHER..TO. CREATE. A. MASTERPIECE..IN. EATING. ENJOYMENT..I...RATE. THE..THE. ENTIRE..EXPERICE..AT...8.9..& THE. PIZZA. AT. .9.5..ABOVE. TOPSHELF.....THE. PLEASURE. IS. 100% MINE. MAOLA. FAMILY. WITH. 40 PLUS. YEARS..IN..PIZZA./ RESTAURANT. BUSINESS....HELLO. GEORGE.&.ANTHONY...& ENTIRE..STAFF..ALSO. IN. CORNEILOUS. NORTH. CAROLINA..THE. PAST. # OF.YEARS...HELLO. LOUIE..“

“Love Crabby Amy's! It is a hidden gem, tucked away in Seaford. If you're on the water, or arriving by boat, do not miss out! Food is always fresh and wonderful, and the atmosphere is amazing! Outdoor seating only and of course, when the weather permits!“