33 Best Sandwich Shops near Bay Shore

“The friendly girl gave me a sample of chicken teriyaki. I wasn't looking for this but it was very tasty. I came back because it was the best option at the food court. 8.99 for 1 meat and two sides. I have to agree that the quantity and the quality of the food make this an absolute bargain.“

“I am astonished with this subway the sandwich was really good The food actually smells appetizing too, like I would go to the subway and stick to it. The employee is really sweet and kind I was not expecting a gas station Subway to taste this good but this Subway tastes so good. Like a luxury. I recommend you guys to come and take a bite of this Subway“

“I had a great experience at Subway! The sandwich was fresh, delicious, and made exactly the way I wanted. The ingredients tasted fresh, and the skinny girls was friendly and helpful. Everything was clean, and the service was quick. I definitely recommend Subway and will come back again!❤“

“Best philly steak around 😋🤗 can't beat the price“

“Great food, fresh ingredients, and excellent customer service. The sandwich was made perfectly, the store was clean, and the staff was friendly and welcoming. Fast service and a great experience overall. Highly recommend this Subway!”“

“There are a lot of delis on Long Island but not all of them make really good food. This one definitely delivers in that department. We get egg sandwiches and pancakes from this place often and they are consistently on point! I love living in Bay Shore bc I'm surrounded by awesomeness!“

“I had such a wonderful experience at Subway thanks to two amazing ladies, Samin and Sweety! They were both incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive. Their positive attitudes and excellent customer service made my visit even better. They went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. It’s so nice to walk into a place and be treated with such kindness and respect. Subway is lucky to have these two wonderful employees! Thank you, Samin and Sweety, for making my experience so special. Keep up the amazing work! 👏“

“My Favorite Jersey Mikes location. The workers are friendly and give me a picture perfect sub every time I go there. The restaurant is always clean. Whoever reads this, please make sure you leave a tip. They deserve it. To the owner of this location reading this, happy staff make a great product. They deserve positive praise.“

“I have been coming to this location for years and Mary is always the one here serving my family. She is so kind and happy every time we visit. She always greets us and has a conversation with us. I appreciate how she knows our order! We will definitely be coming back!“

“The best deli !!! & the people who work there are the best!!❤️ highly recommend 😊😊“

“Great place to eat. Food is fantastic“

“Best heroes on Long Island“

“This Subway is definitely my go-to place! I stop by for breakfast every day, and I’m always impressed by the professionalism and friendliness of the staff. The store is consistently clean, the food is fresh, and the service is excellent.

They always greets customers with a big smile and makes you feel welcomed. It’s clear that they genuinely care about their customers and take pride in providing a great experience. The prices are also better than many other Subway locations.

Highly recommended!“

“Excellent ,I have an autistic son that will only eat Subway. This is the second time we been there this week. It was Closing when we got there today. and he saw us at the door and opened it up and made a sandwich for my son you don’t know how much I appreciated that thank you“

“Good staff, young folks Working hard! Good to see!“

“I work in the mall for 4+ years and I think Charlie’s the best place to eat compared to other options. A beautiful worker, Sonny, has been there what feels like everyday. Every time I go she always has amazing energy and slides an extra sauce! She goes out of her way to make someone’s day. They always have good deals and an expansive menu, def recommend on a shopping trip!“

“They Prepare an excellent sub with the price you can’t beat it“

“I recently brought food there today. The staff member was super friendly and I loved how polite she was and how she melted my chocolate chip cookie. I loved when she was super understanding and allowed me to ask questions about how much my cost would total up to. GREAT STAFF OVERALL, 11/10, would recommend this place to anyone!“

“very clean, always fresh, I've been a customer for40 years!“

“Had a steak melt hero (Manhattan) solidly packed with meat and not too much cheese - was pretty hungry as was a 3pm lunch. Hit the spot just right. Good value for money + Friendly staff as well. Would definitely come back next time I am around the area.“

“This was my first time to this Subway. I've been to bad ones before where I've gotten sick so I stopped eating it for awhile but I had a random craving for Subway today. I came in around 11:30 am. There was one man ahead of me. The clerk finished with him much faster than I expected. I noticed the store was very clean. The atmosphere was comfortable. I happened for some reason to look at their prepping boards and they were pure white which actually calmed my fear about getting sick. I ordered a philly cheesesteak with provolone cheese, lettuce, onions, sweet peppers, pickles, black olives and jalapeno (like I said random craving) He made a joke when he rung up my order and said $125.40 instead of $12.54 I laughed and asked him his name. He told me his name is Rocky. He printed my receipt and said if I do the survey on the receipt I could get a free cookie. I went on the website right then and there and answered the questions. Rocky even helped me and I got a free cookie. Rocky had great customer service. He made me feel welcomed. Oh and the sanidwich? was awesome! Perfect amount of toppings to complement the steak. I recommend it. Thanks Rocky! Would definitely come back.“

“Just like Jimmy John’s from out of state. Great sandwich with fresh ingredients and fast and friendly service . Can’t wait for the one in Miller Place since it’s close to home, I’ll be going there all the time. Also the Dunkin inside is a great addition.“

“Awesome subs. Good tasting subs, fresh meats.“

“wonderful staff, great service, and great bagels“

“I was very happy when a Jersey Mike's opened up near me. My neighborhood is overrun with Subway and I am really not a fan.

This location is spotless and the staff is attentive and polite. They put together your sandwich quickly and accurately.

The best thing about Jersey Mike's is the quality of their ingredients and that everything tastes fresh.

Give this new location a try!“

“The couple who run this place make it a worth the trip. They are always friendly. We go there as much as possible. You can get your sandwich made to order. They are always a five stars eatery. Out of respect I don't post pictures. During the summer it is on the busy side.“

“I've decided to ditch the Subway app. I don't find this app to be of any great convenience and it's too time consuming to get them to work properly. I'm hoping I can get a gift card that I can use for points purposes. Besides the app, I think Jersey Mike's is stiff competition for Subway as far as portion size goes and the amount of meat/cheese on sandwiches. There are some Subways that will not accept coupons like the one in Central Islip on Carleton Ave. I walk out and won't patronize that location. Otherwise, the Subway experience is good.“

“By far my favorite Subway on Long Island. Clean restaurant, with professional and friendly staff…and TASTY FOOD. As someone who is constantly traveling Long Island for work, I can honestly say that this Subway goes the extra mile.

I’ve catered from here before, and other Subway’s barely put any meat on their sandwiches…THIS ONE DOES. This is how Subway should be. Check out this location next time for lunch, and I promise you will be happy!“

“Used the phone app for the first time. It took a little while to get use to. Once I figured out how to use it it was simple and everything I ordered was the way I ordered it. If you like a certain sandwich you can add it to your favorites list. I will definitely use it again.“

“The subway on 109 an straight path. The service always come with a friendly smile. There very patient. An there sandwich are made healthily. Very heavy plenty of meat. An tuna too. I had one i was going to for a long time. But my mom took me there. I'll be the re for good. Great people ?♥️?“

“I visit this Subway regularly. I have never had any issues with service or food quality. Friendly staff clean restaurant and good amount of seating. I've noticed over the years that it may have changed ownership a couple of times but still no issues and was a seamless transition. I would recommend this location to others as one of the better stores as I have been to a few which do not stack up as well. It is a convenient location in a strip mall with plenty of other shopping nearby.

Vegetarian options: Plenty of vegetables here. More than one person could want. The combinations are endless limited only by your imagination.

Parking: Parking is reasonable. Being tucked in a strip mall makes parking abundant. Handicap accessible parking is available too.“

“Visited the Bohemia location for the first time. I pulled up and panicked that they were closed. Relieved to find that it was open and was greeted by an amazing associate that I came to title “Mr Jersey Mike “ as he was a rockstar! He looked like a very young Michael J Fox ! As I said it was my first time and I was accompanied by 2 disabled gentleman that I was treating for dinner. It was Saturday early evening June 1st and I’m hoping you can check your payroll records and give recognition to this incredible helpful knowledgeable and polite dude ! He knew his stuff and made recommendations that were fabulous! The staff working with him were a great team and I left a good tip. Please acknowledge these young men. Their work ethic and professionalism with disabled adults is really worthy of notating! The world hasn’t really had a great work ethic since Covid and these dudes are changing that ! We will be back real soon !“