13 Best American Restaurants in Babylon

The Villager Bar • $$
262 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

The Villager Burger and Sweet Potato Tots
Fire Island Slaw Burger
Bang Bang Shrimp
Bavarian Pretzel
Breakfast Burger
Chicken Wings
Gouda Fries
Tater Tots

“Monday through Thursday 3:00 p.m. to 3:00 a.m. full bar full menu even longer on like Friday and Saturday or something like that. Sunday might be like an early night I think. But nobody's open like they are. There's a crowd. There's ladies this dudes I mean I guess if that's what you're into hahaha lol. Great “

4.6 Superb53 Reviews
Post Office Café American • $$
130 W Main St, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Nachos with Melted Cheddar and Jack Cheese
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
French Onion Soup
Fish and Chips
Avocado Toast
Thai Calamari
Buffalo Wings

“I had my baby shower at Goldy's Gems in November of 2023 and was absolutely thrilled by the customer service, food and atmosphere. Our guests raved about the food and how their glass was never empty, thanks to the chef, servers/bartenders! It's such a trendy place and gives off awesome vibes. We enjoyed the shower so much, that we wanted to hold our son's Baptism at another one of the restaurant groups locations. We chose to have the event at Post Office cafe and once again they knocked our socks off. We were fans just on an ordinary day, so we just knew the events would be even better and we were right. Melissa, Chris, Chris and our servers/bartender once again were amazing in every way. During our planning we also found out they just had a renovation in our event room that made it look so bright and welcoming. The staff is extremely accommodating, especially on the day of when it comes to decor setup. We were able to bring our decor earlier in the day and then have someone set up about a half hour-hour early so that when our guests arrived all was in its place. The staff at Post Office even offered to assist with some setup as long as it was simple placement. If you are ever in need of an event space, I would highly suggest Post Office Cafe and Goldy's Gems or any restaurant in this restaurant group, you just can't go wrong!“

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
Glen's Dinette American • $
23 E Main St, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Benedict Top Picture and Bacon and Eggs with Root Veggies Botom Pic
Homemade Banana Pecan Bread French Toast
Eggs with Cheese and Sausage
Pulled Pork Cuban Sandwich
Corned Beef Hash and Eggs
Hash and Eggs Any Style
Blue Monkey Pancakes
Smiley Pancakes
Scrambled Eggs
Home Fries

“Only got a coffee but it was very good. Place is not very spacious but atmosphere is great. Old school classic dinette. Not many places like this around anymore. Employees are very friendly. No gimmicks, no new wave fusion cuisine, no "modern" decor, just good food at a good price served by good people.Wheelchair accessibility: Definitely not getting a wheelchair in these tight quarters.“

4.5 Superb71 Reviews
Hostess With The Mostess Catering & Events Caterers • $$
504 Fire Island Ave, Babylon

“I had a party with 50+ people and thanks to the efforts of my Hostess with the Mostess crew, it went off flawlessly! I was provided 2 servers and a bartender and they began working immediately upon arrival. They were all professional, courteous and extremely pro-active! I didn’t have to ask them to do anything-they simply took the initiative themselves! I highly recommend this company as this was not the first time I used them and have always been happy the day after!!“

4.6 Superb23 Reviews
Overlook Beach Manager American • $$
Ocean Pkwy, Babylon

“This has been my beach for 58 years. I've seen the beach grow. I've seen the beach shrink. I've seen play items. Come and go. It's a great beach. It's protected by the Robert Moses sand bar. The food is good and fairly priced for being at a beach. They've added a bar area and it looks good. I'm not a drinker so I wouldn't know. The best thing they've added is closed showers. You can wash off and more showers outside to rinse feet. I love the upstairs area when I go in the winter it's protected, but you still get to enjoy the beach.“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Babylon Burger Bar Hamburger • $$
1 W Main St, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Mac and Cheese Burger
Goat Cheese Burger
Burger Bar Sundae
Brussels Sprouts
Grilled Chicken
Grilled Cheese
Great South Bay
French Fries
Onion Rings

“Me and my partner went to this fine restaurant for our dinner this evening and we put expectations we're very much exceeded. Our server was Alyssa and she was awesome even though she was super busy she was able to be there whenever we needed her. We will definitely be back her soon, knowing that we feel welcomed with amazing service and great meals.“

4.4 Superb136 Reviews
The Delica Sea Deli • $$
504 South Fire Island Ave, Babylon

“Great place for breakfast and lunch. Staff is friendly and professional. Awesome hot and cold coffee to go or enjoy there - inside or outside. They make awesome egg sandwiches and have delicious meals to go (including pasta and meatballs, turkey and mashed potatoes and salads). Highly recommend!“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Tricia's Cafe American • $$
26 E Main St, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Mississippi Jerk Chicken Wings with Fries
Maryland Crabcake Sandwich
BBQ Burger and Fries
Bacon Cheese Burger
Seasoned Fries
Coconut Shrimp
Buffalo Burger
BBQ Burger
Crab Cake

“Tricia's cafe is filled with a 50's museum like decor. Small but quaint, the food is absolutely delicious. Fresh made food, homey vibes, the servers treat you like you are part of the family. A small spot with plenty of flavor, love and good vibes. Definitely will be stopping by again next time I visit Robert Moses beach.P.S. Best steak quesadilla I have ever tried!“

4.4 Superb36 Reviews

9
IHOP

IHOP Breakfast • $
651 Montauk Hwy, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Original Buttermilk Pancakes 3 Stack
Create Your Own French Toast Combo
Grilled Chicken Omelet Fajitas
Double Blueberry Pancakes
Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken & Waffles
Belgian Waffle
Sausage Links
Hash Browns
Steak

“Ordered takeout, which included a few meals with pancakes, eggs, bacon, hash browns etc. Food was good! Only complaint - Checked “yes” for adding condiments, but was not given anything. Not even pancake syrup which unfortunately I did not discover until I got home and did not have any in the house. Ate the pancakes dry and they were still good.“

4.1 Good57 Reviews
Lily's Babylon American • $$
345 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Burren BBQ Short Ribs
French Onion Soup
Kerry Corned Beef
Grilled Salmon
Buffalo Wing
Seafood Pasta
French Fries
Skirt Steak
Beef Tacos

“Just had a birthday dinner for my mom's 80th and can't say enough good things about my experience. Such great customer service with Damien (Manager)and Chris the chef. Chris went above and beyond to provide a great menu and setting for the evening. Nicole the catering manager was great to work with. A Big shout out to Will, who was our go to for everything that night (bartender, server etc)! He really had his hands full and did everything with a smile and no problem attitude. Everyone enjoyed their food and praised the staff. My Mom was so surprised and loved how casual and friendly everyone was. Thank you again to Everyone at Lily's!!“

4.1 Good89 Reviews
Babylon Fish & Clam Restaurant Seafood • $$
458 Fire Island Ave, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
New England Clam Chowder
Clams on the Half Shell
Coconut Shrimp
Popcorn Shrimp
Seafood Bisque
Garlic Bread
Fra Diavolo
Baked Clams
French Fries

“Stopped in for our 29th wedding anniversary started off with an amazing bloody Mary appetizers and a five star dinner we were so please we came back two days in a row. Can’t say enough about the staff and owners Mellissa and Franz and the entire waitress staff they made us feel like we’re the only “

4 Good38 Reviews
Argyle Grill & Tavern American • $$
90 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Marinated Steak Sandwich
Coconut Crusted Shrimp
Sliced Sirloin Steak
Babylon Clam Chowder
Sweet Potato Fries
Sesame Seared Tuna
Crispy Calamari
Crab Cakes

“My husband and I came here for his birthday dinner. The hostess was so friendly and pleasant. Something we unfortunately have not experienced lately and it is definitely an important detail that plays a part in setting the tone for a dining experience. When we were seated, the waiter was prompt with introducing himself and getting drink orders. Throughout the night, he was attentive, prompt and so sweet. I had a Watermelon martini. There's was a little issue with the drink but very happy to say it was taken care of immediately. We had the calamari, Brie stuffed pretzel, skirt steak and stuff salmon. Everything was delicious. The one issue that I did have was that when we went to pay the bill with my Citibank card, the waiter returned and said that there is an issue with their machine so they can't take the card. When I questioned this, he said this has been happening for a few years where their machine doesn't process the Citibank cards. I was surprised to hear this because if it has been an issue that can't be resolved, something should be posted and patrons should be notified. I have worked in the restaurant business and have never heard of an issue like this lasting for years without it being resolved. My thought was though, what about patrons that all they have are citibank cards to pay without the option of getting cash. They would have dined and would be unable to pay? Overall we had a nice dining experience and will visit again but I hope the Citi issue can be resolved or posted.“

3.8 Good73 Reviews
Horace & Sylvia's Publick House American • $$
100 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon

Customers` Favorites

Skirt Steak w Mashed Potatoes and Asparagus
Flaky Cheddar Biscuits with Honey Butter
Southern Fried Chicken
Marinated Skirt Steak
Ahi Tuna with Zoodles
Baked Clams

“Went Saturday which was St Patrick's day eve ! We called ahead and a table was ready. The service from beginning to end was great. Friendly attentive and was just great. I loved the atmosphere where you can hang out by the bar watch games or even sit at high tops. The dining room was very comfortable for me but was a bit warm for my date especially with two drinks and hot delicious food Ordered from the specials and we both were not sure on the quesadilla but it was great! A little greasy for me but the tortilla still had crunch so it worked! I got an Irish mule which had ginger beer - yum & more newness! The Guinness beef was amazinggggg and I needed to substitute the mashed for broccoli to limit some carbs and calories. Broccoli was cooked perfect!“

3.7 Good71 Reviews
Loading...
map Map