4 Best Burger Restaurants in Bay Shore

Local Burger - Bay Shore Restaurant and Bar Hamburger • $$
62 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

PB\u0026B Burger Cheddar Cheese Bacon and Peanut Butter Trust Us All Burgers Cooked to Medium Well
PB&B Burger Cheddar Cheese Bacon and Peanut Butter Trust Us All Burgers Cooked to Medium Well
Local Burger and Fries with Gravy on the Side
Beer Battered Onion Rings
Your Creation Burger
Bleu Ribbon Burger
Hangover Burger
Atomic Burger
Vinegar Fries
Potato Fries

“Honestly this place blew me and my partners mind. We just got a Mac n cheese burger, the cheese burger nachos, cheese fries, wings and a milk shake. Everything was cooked to perfection and was crisp and fresh. We chose this place because of the gluten free options and was so surprised that the fries had their own fryer. The service was promt and attentive and knowledgeable. We must have come at a good time because the vibes were perfect. Wished we lived closer to visit more often.“

4.2 Good102 Reviews
Burger King Burgers • $
335 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Egg & Cheese Croissan'Wich Hasbrowns Fully Loaded Biscuit
Bacon Sausage Egg & Cheese Croissan'Wich Meals
Classic Wrap Spicy Wrap Honey Mustard Wrap
Fiery Royal Crispy Chicken
Double Cheeseburger
Impossible Whopper
Mozzarella Sticks
Flame Grilled Beef
Whopper Jr Burger
Whopper Sandwich

“Great service & nice atmosphere ☺“

3.9 Good113 Reviews
Peter Pan Diner American • $$
999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Western Omelet with Home Fries
The Breakfast Cheese Scramble
Black Forrest Cake Slice
Apple Cinnamon Pancakes
Chicken Noodle Soup
Sweet Potato Fries
Blueberry Pancakes
Grilled Cheese
Belgian Waffle
Chocolate Chip

“Today I came to visit and have a quick bite! The burger was phenomenal! And what made the burger even better was the outstanding service from Thomas! His energy and attentiveness makes me want to come back! I live in Huntington but would come back just for the service alone! Thank you Peter Pan for a great early dinner!“

4.4 Superb149 Reviews
Ends Meat Eats Food Trucks • $
20 Ackerson St B, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Sausage Egg \u0026 Cheese
Marauder Smash
House Smash
Fries

“Stopped by Ends Meat Eats on a cold day, and man — this place hit the spot! I ordered the lobster burger and pulled pork tots with Dr Pepper BBQ sauce, and both were absolutely phenomenal. The lobster burger was buttery, perfectly seasoned, and loaded with flavor — you could tell it was made fresh and with care. The pulled pork tots? Unreal. Crispy on the outside, tender pulled pork inside, and that Dr Pepper BBQ sauce ties everything together with the perfect mix of sweet and smoky.

What really made the experience stand out was the owner — super friendly, welcoming, and clearly passionate about the food. It honestly felt like eating at a friend’s house who just happens to be an incredible chef. Between the cozy vibes and amazing food, this spot turned a freezing day into one of the best meals I’ve had in a long time.

Highly recommend — Ends Meat Eats deserves all the love!“

5 Superb27 Reviews

You May Also Like