Bagels Restaurants near Bay Shore, NY

Browse menus, reviews and photos of Bagels Restaurants near Bay Shore.

Showing 10 of 10 restaurants

  • Bayshore Bagels & Deli 222 5th Ave, Bay Shore Bagels · $

    1 Bayshore Bagels & Deli

    4.3 Superb 86 Reviews

    222 5th Ave, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out

    “Their breakfast sandwiches have to be the best on the island. The two staff were incredibly efficient & got through orders quickly. I don’t often review, but had to to make sure I remember to come back here next time I’m in the area.”

  • Sunrise Bagel 2054 A Sunrise Hwy South Service Road, Bay Shore Bagels · $

    2 Sunrise Bagel

    3.8 Good 120 Reviews

    2054 A Sunrise Hwy South Service Road, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bakery
    • Bagels

    “This place is absolutely 10/10 I mean this little hidden gem was such a delight! I will be returning every chance I get!!! Don’t sleep on this place, it’s the perfect “mom & pop” feeling location. Feels like home! Vibes are on point and the food is so good it should be illegal! As a local guide who travels to every state every random food spot, today did not disappoint at all! Truly a life changing experience. Times are hard and business is slow for us all, let’s show support by enjoying good food with great company and let’s all share a laugh or 2!”

  • Exit 42 Deli 270 Spur Drive South, Bay Shore Deli · $

    3 Exit 42 Deli

    3.7 Good 116 Reviews

    270 Spur Drive South, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Hungryman Sandwich
    • Grilled Chicken
    • Crispy Chicken
    • Hot Food

    “Staff was very friendly.. place is nice and clean”

  • Bagel Boss East 555 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore Caterers · $

    4 Bagel Boss East

    2.9 Average 297 Reviews

    555 Montauk Highway, Bay Shore

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Egg on a Roll or Bagel
    • Scallion Cream Cheese
    • Egg Everything Bagel
    • Sesame Bagel

    “I moved to Bay Shore in 2019 and was very excited to find out that the store that the little guy had the tantrum at was only a few minutes away from where I lived. I went there the week after the video went viral and a few time after. I remember the bagels and sandwiches being pretty good but the lines are crazy long especially on the weekends”

  • West Islip Bagel 544 Hunter Avenue, West Islip Bagels · $

    5 West Islip Bagel

    4.6 Superb 110 Reviews

    544 Hunter Avenue, West Islip

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Everything Bagel Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich

    “Maybe the best bagel in the USA. I grew up on Long Island and this establishment is excellent 👌 I think Long Island really sucks all around when it comes to it's lack of culture and it's people (too many d bags) but if you ever wind up on this God forsaken Island do your self a favor and go to this eating establishment. 🙂🥯”

  • Corner Bagel 264 West Main Street, Smithtown Bagel shop

    6 Corner Bagel

    4.7 Superb 78 Reviews

    264 West Main Street, Smithtown

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    “As a dad, cleanliness and healthy food are a big deal to me, especially when it comes to my kids. It’s honestly pretty hard to find a place where you can grab a quick lunch and still feel good about what you’re feeding your family.Ive been coming here with all the kiddos and they love it every single time. First of all, this place is insanely clean. I mean seriously, probably one of the cleanest food places I’ve ever been to. The ingredients are fresh,the quality is great and you can tell they actually put some thought into what they’re serving. It’s the kind of attention Id give to making a sandwich for my own kids at home. And the staff is just great. Idk how they do it but somehow they’ve made a bagel shop feel like a neighborhood place you’ve been going to for years 👌 Everyone is genuinely friendly, not that fake customer service stuff. My kids are hooked on this place now and honestly I don’t mind one bit. I’ve lived on Long Island long enough to know places like this aren’t easy to find. I wouldn’t even call it just a bagel shop. It’s something different, in a really good way. Glad we found it. You guys ROCK!!”

  • Stuff A Bagel 863 West Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown Bagels · $

    7 Stuff A Bagel

    4.3 Superb 97 Reviews

    863 West Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • 9 2 Eggs with Ham Sausage & Cheese Sandwich
    • 6 Dozen Bulk Mini Bagels
    • Energy Multigrain Bagel
    • Everything Seasoning

    “I live in Austin, TX, and I love how I can have authentic New York bagels delivered to my front door. I am a new customer, and I love Just Bagels. I love their customer service, they answer their phone, and they answer my questions on Facebook. I will be using them again, and again. I love everything about them so far. My boyfriend is the bagel eater, and I ordered 2 dozen for him. The flavors we got were Everything, Sesame, Cinnamon Raisin, and Blueberry. He is in love with their blueberry bagels. Those are his favorite, but he loves them all. Thanks Just Babels for the wonderful bagels. We’ll be trying new flavors next time, but for sure blueberry again. :)”

  • Railroad Bagel Express 126 N Carll Ave, Babylon Bagels · $

    8 Railroad Bagel Express

    4.4 Superb 80 Reviews

    126 N Carll Ave, Babylon

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bacon Egg and Cheese on an Egg Everything Bagel
    • Bagels on a Dish from Railroad Bagels
    • Plain Cream Cheese and Jelly Bagel
    • House Salad with Scoop of Tuna

    “Bagels are always fresh. They have a great selection too. The Rye is my favorite!!!”

  • Commack Bagels Deli Market 260 Commack Road, Commack Bagel shop · $

    9 Commack Bagels Deli Market

    4.3 Superb 101 Reviews

    260 Commack Road, Commack

    • Take-Out
    • Delivery

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bagel with Cream Cheese
    • Chicken Caesar Wrap
    • BBQ Chicken Wrap
    • Grilled Cheese

    “Fresh food friendly service...”

  • Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor 1380 Montauk Highway, Oakdale Bagels · $

    10 Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor

    4.3 Superb 100 Reviews

    1380 Montauk Highway, Oakdale

    • Take-Out

    Customers’ favorites

    • Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Roll with Salt Pepper and Ketchup
    • Bagel

    “I gave five star review because I really do not go to this place but I was mortified by how dirty it was. It was disgustingly dirty. I don’t know if they just look at the place from the customers view. I would never eat there. They really need to clean that place up. They need a total overhaul in front that eating whatever’s in the back. It was worse than a dirty Chinese restaurant I’m sorry I threw my bagel out actually.”

Bagels Restaurants Nearby