Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor
$ • BagelsAbout Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor
Customers' Favorites
Bacon Egg and Cheese on a Roll with Salt Pepper and Ketchup
Bagel
Recent Reviews
96 ratings
Share your opinion about Bagels by the Bay / Bagel Doctor
Grew up in Oakdale and this was always my go to bagel place! Was on long island again for the first time in 10 years and I was so happy to enjoy their egg sandwiches again! Will always return when back on LI!
I gave five star review because I really do not go to this place but I was mortified by how dirty it was. It was disgustingly dirty. I don’t know if they just look at the place from the customers view. I would never eat there. They really need to clean that place up. They need a total overhaul in front that eating whatever’s in the back. It was worse than a dirty Chinese restaurant I’m sorry I threw my bagel out actually.
Great bagels still warm when we got home!! 👍🏻
Hours
| Monday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Tuesday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Wednesday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Thursday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Friday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Saturday | 5AM - 2:30PM |
| Sunday | 5AM - 2PM |
Bagels by the Bay, also known as Bagel Doctor, is a popular breakfast spot in Sayville/Oakdale. Known for its delicious and fresh bagels, the restaurant also offers tasty food, coffee, and breakfast sandwiches. The whole-wheat sunflower seed flagel is a customer favorite. Many customers appreciate the friendly service, noting that the staff is always nice and organized, even during busy times. The bagels are large, crusty, and have a good chew and taste, making them a favorite among bagel lovers. Customers often visit for the affordable breakfast options, including a sit-down platter under $8, and for the authentic bagels that are described as mouth-watering. The peaceful atmosphere, especially at the back table, is perfect for reading the paper. Despite long morning lines, customers value the reasonable prices and delicious food. The place is also known for its regulars, who add to the welcoming vibe. While some say the restaurant could use a little updating and that the grill is sometimes too hot, overall, it remains a beloved spot for a satisfying breakfast.