Fratelli Pizzeria

Pizza, Italian, Fast Food

553 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 666-0458


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Fratelli Pizzeria

Jon and the staff at Fratelli are committed to helping people by serving them good food and doing right by the community. A group of friends pooled money to buy a meal for the ICU staff at a local hospital, where our friend's parent was being cared for. The hospital staff requested Fratelli's, so that's an endorsement already. Jon worked with us and the amount we had raised to get hot Italian food into the bellies of these essential workers, and he said he's been doing that full review
Pleasantly surprised! We meant to go to a different pizza place and made a wrong turn so we decided to stop and try this spot. Thank goodness we did! We started off with a slice of cheese pizza, the crust was authentic NY and we loved it. We also got an appetizer of calamari and it was excellent. Not chewy and the sauce was spectacular. I had a taste for pasta with Alfredo and a side of meatballs and let me tell you... it was amazing! The sauce was creamy and not thick and full review
Called Fratelli's this evening to place an order for pickup, a girl took my order and told me it would be ready in 25-30 minutes. I go to the restaurant and tell them I'm picking up and they said they didn't have an order placed and I must've called the wrong place. I showed them the number and confirmed that it was theirs. They said they'd make me my order and it would be ready in 15 minutes. 20 minutes later my order was ready and I go to pay, the owner full review

More Reviews(90)


Monday 11AM - 10PM
Tuesday 11AM - 10PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 11PM
Saturday 11AM - 11PM
Sunday 12 - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.